News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by lifeisstillgood on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:10AM (#5460498)
Wait, what?

I have never heard of Men's Rights Activism - and suddenly HN is a active example of such misanthropy?

Is this a different HN to this one? Or am I missing something?

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by jacobian on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:17AM (#5460527)
Go read any thread here touching on sexism, feminism, or gender equality. You get all the standard anti-feminist arguments ("it's not really a problem"; "men are oppressed too"; "she should have just asked nicely"; "my wife doesn't think that's sexist"; "it's just a joke"; etc. etc. etc.) I'm not sure I'd lump HN in with the MRA jerks wholesale, but in all HN reeks of privilege. There are several things HN does very well; gender equality really isn't one of them.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by kabuks on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:30AM (#5460577)
Yes.

I have been very surprised at the discrepancy between the level of dialogue.

When the discussion on HN is around almost anything, I find myself often learning, and surrounded by comments that are smarter, and more informed than any I would find in the real world.

When it comes to gender issues though, I think we as a community in general tend to be pretty behind.

I truly love HN. More than any other place on the interweb, this one has impacted my life in very real ways. I do however, cringe when the topic veers towards sexism. I think we can do better.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by mpyne on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:30AM (#5460895)
> I have been very surprised at the discrepancy between the level of dialogue.

I haven't been. Without doubt there are some brilliant minds on HN, but even this populace is not immune from "believing first, proving second". The group writ large tends to fall into that trap on different topics than most people, but it falls eventually. Not just regarding sexism in tech either; there are others.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by eric_bullington on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:07AM (#5460768)
I think the type of comments you mentioned are not only relatively rare, but they are quickly downvoted when they occur. The thing that HN does not do well is political correctness. I think the Richards case was jarring to most tech folks (men and women) because someone was fired for being very mildly politically incorrect in a private conversation.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by jacobian on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:34AM (#5460912)
> I think the type of comments you mentioned are not only relatively rare, but they are quickly downvoted when they occur.

Well, we see a very different subset of comments, apparently.

Look at the top comments in this very thread, for example...

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by lifeisstillgood on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:26AM (#5460561)
I see, I tend to ignore them, a mental defence mechanism evolved to deal with blog comments. I just assume anyone dumb enough to make a comment like that wont have anything much interesting to say on technology or entrepreneurship - it's been an accurate assumption so far as I can tell
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by austinee on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:05AM (#5460759)
That's a lot of ignoring to do. In the last feminism related thread I can think of (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5432277), the majority of people were, to put it mildly, not exactly progressive. That includes two mainstays of the HN community, with 15k+ karma.

The last one before that got flagged off the front page after one commenter declared that he was flagging it because programs that help women are sexist (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5353136). The story was highly upvoted, but it only takes a handful of flags to relegate a story to oblivion. Pg commented that it was an abuse of flagging, and it was restored, but pg usually doesn't show up, and most of these stories get buried, even when they're upvoted.

This story is a perfect example. With "19 points, 3 hours ago", it is ranked 151, right next two stories with "3 points, 14 hours ago".

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by lifeisstillgood on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:57AM (#5461040)
Thank you - that top comment by luu is right on the money
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by dccoolgai on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:15AM (#5460516)
Yeah...it seems like there's been a proliferation of people who have never had anything to do with the "tech community" ever making broad characterizations thereof, e.g "The Tech Community Hates Feminists", etc.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by austinee on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:55AM (#5460704)
You don't need to be a member of the tech community to see that. All you need to do is read the comments at any of the sites listed in the article. Yes, that includes HN.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by dccoolgai on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:12AM (#5460798)
Really? So you can ascribe sentiments like "Entire Community X Hates Community/Idea Y" based on comments in a forum?

Try this one on; "Feminism Hates Technology".

Sounds dumb, doesn't it? Because it's not a useful rhetorical approach to having a constructive debate - which, I am guessing by the hue of your comment, we would both strongly agree needs to happen. We need feminism in tech, for a lot of reasons - but not this "sensationalism at the cost of progress" flavor of it.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by austinee on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:21AM (#5460841)
That's fair. I shouldn't judge the entire community based on its loudest online members.

In any case, the sentiment in the article resonates with me, because it matches my anecdotal experience outside of online communities. I haven't seen the converse in the feminist community, but that's also anecdotal.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by dccoolgai on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:46AM (#5460973)
austinee, sir or madam; I propose the following format for the remainder of this thread:

We post awesome women engineers and developers for people to follow and be aware of. Let the rest of the internet wallow in its poisonous vat of sensationalist vitriol. Here, in our little corner of the internet, we will move the chain forward a few inches by enumerating incredible women in tech, the rest of the web be damned. Maybe no one will see it or care. But maybe - just maybe, some young lady will stumble across it and think "Hey, that could be me, too." and in that small chance will our entire effort henceforth be vindicated.

Allow me to begin: (others feel free to contribute as well).

Rebecca Murphey ( @rmurphey / http://rmurphey.com/ ) : I owe her so much for writing her infamous Jquery/Javascript training guide. She is certainly one of the most pivotal figures in the Javascript renaissance. Her writing hits the sweet-spot of technical depth and approchability. I firmly believe that she is the kind of innovator that whatever she is doing now, the rest of us will be doing in 5 yrs.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by dccoolgai on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:48AM (#5460983)
Next: Limor Fried ( @ladyada / adafruit.com)

If you don't know who this is, you are already being left behind in the new landscape of physical computing. Easily one of the top 5 most infulential people in the "New Hardware" movement.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by dccoolgai on Friday March 29, 2013 @11:01AM (#5461068)
Jeri Elsworth : @jerielsworth

The hacker's hacker. Major thought leader in modern electronics/hardware hacking.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by criley on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:18AM (#5460533)
It's also another shining example of being totally unable to separate the geeky hacker community with the larger internet community.

Yes, every message put on every blog was done by a full time developer working in our industry and not by thousands of children and teenagers and adults who have nothing to do with us but joined the bandwagon as it rolled along.

But hey, all nerdy men are all the same, right?

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by nkorth on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:46AM (#5460664)
Agreed, equating the entire internet with the "tech community" is more than a little bit sensational. There certainly are misogynists in the tech community, but I doubt they were responsible for all of the overall backlash.
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by stesch on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:23AM (#5460551)
MRA isn't misanthropy. What's wrong with you??
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by lifeisstillgood on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:25AM (#5460559)
Men's rights? Come on, a man in modern America and you feel oppressed?
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by mtrimpe on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:41AM (#5460638)
I'm an ardent supporter of women's rights, but I'm also a supporter of the men's rights movement.

The (valid part of the) men's right movement is mostly concerned with men who:

* have been raped or faced domestic abuse, but are met with ridicule when filing charges

* have lost custody of their children to unstable / irresponsible mothers

I fully agree that women's rights is several orders of magnitude more important / severe, but that doesn't make these men's plight inconsequential either. This is not an either-or situation.

What is a problem though, and what was raised in the article, is the large mass of mysoginists that are essentially hiding behind that same men's right banner.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by electronvolt on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:15AM (#5460812)
Some of those issues are also addressed/worked on by feminist groups, particularly the rape one. Almost every survivor counseling organization I know of provides services to men as well as women. I'd also characterize most of those groups as feminist. (In fact, it's the ones that don't provide services to men that I'd often characterize as not feminist and that get the most feminist criticism, such as the services offered by most universities).

My experience has been that the Men's Rights Movement's good parts are often what is basically non-radical feminist activism repackaged, and its bad parts are reprehensible. (Note: radical feminism is things like the SCUM manifesto; most feminism isn't particularly radical)

The article does make the important point that there aren't a lot of places for (straight) men to discuss cultural ideas of masculinity and its possible ill effects. (In my experience, gay men often have a better understanding of male dynamics than straight men, and there's more of a cultural discourse about masculinity in some parts of gay culture.)

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by mtrimpe on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:27AM (#5460876)
I wasn't aware of the feminist's support for these men's rights issues, which is admirable and good to know.

As far as your last comment is concerned; my support for women's rights comes out of having been gay and now being somewhere on the bi/genderqueer continuum so I can definitely relate to that.

If you're interested, this speech by Gary Carter captures it more beautifully than I've ever been able to: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=P...

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by illuminate on Friday March 29, 2013 @11:01AM (#5461067)
"The (valid part of the) men's right movement is mostly concerned with men who: * have been raped or faced domestic abuse, but are met with ridicule when filing charges * have lost custody of their children to unstable / irresponsible mothers"

And attacking women for both of these is folly. That's why MRAs are not taken seriously, because they misdirect their (legitimate in the aformentioned context) concerns.

Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by stesch on Friday March 29, 2013 @09:30AM (#5460578)
You assume men don't need rights. And you assume everybody here is a man, living in America. (I guess you mean USA.)
Re:Donglegate: Why the Tech Community Hates Feminists by illuminate on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:59AM (#5461056)
I'm more worried about, even today, men placing strict gender roles on me and the associated baggage than I am at women for "taking away my rights".

There are certainly strange expectations that guys have to deal with. The problem here is that they aren't challenging the norms because they're too "pussy" or "gay" and as far as I've seen, the MRAs are too wrapped up in their warm cloak of machismo and self-defeating. There are crazy women, as there are crazy men.

Systemically, guys are holding themselves back, and the way established law and custom are has more to do with irresponsible and/or overbearing guys in power in the past than it does some sort of gynocracy.