News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by toyg on Thursday March 28, 2013 @12:17PM (#5455726)
I still don't understand why Nokia are trolling Google so hard on this stuff.
Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 28, 2013 @12:33PM (#5455850)
Nokia is old-school telecoms. They're big on patents partly as a result of coming out of networking hardware, where that model traditionally makes a bit more sense.

However, in the software realm that just gives them a head start on the becoming trolls.

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by kamjam on Thursday March 28, 2013 @01:48PM (#5456437)
When you read an alternative view (see the comments also) actually makes more sense...

http://www.engadget.com/2013/03/25/nokia-attacks-google-over...

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by recoiledsnake on Thursday March 28, 2013 @12:25PM (#5455795)
Simple. Why should Nokia, whose mobile business was undercut by Google using its search monopoly profits to dump a free mobile OS onto the market, give away their hard earned patents for free to Google so that they can reduce their costs on Youtube? Google can easily pay them some of the $50B cash hoard they have for them to go away.

Nokia even sold off its headquarters lately to get some cash. It'd be a disservice to Nokia's shareholders if Nokia didn't try to extract some money for their IP from Google.

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by toyg on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:58PM (#5457258)
So it's just about desperation? We're witnessing another respected technology company morphing into a patent troll, like it happened to SCO?

That's incredibly sad.

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by OGinparadise on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:27PM (#5457083)
I still don't understand why Nokia are trolling Google so hard on this stuff.

Gee, why doesn't Google give away for free their algorithm or Adwords secrets? Why should they, should be the question. Every company has an obligation to, with all other things considered, make as much cash as possible for their shareholders. Who cares that you think that everyone should bow to Google or Microsoft or ...?

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by toyg on Thursday March 28, 2013 @04:07PM (#5457297)
VP8 is really not part of Nokia's core-business. Nokia's core business is making great, portable telecom hardware; a video codec they don't even use right now is not an essential part of it. In fact, it's not even a whole codec spec -- the actual patents are a bunch of implementation-specific tricks that can probably be coded around, if necessary. They make no money from these patents today and will likely never make any money at all; they've been left dormant for 8 years!

No, this is not a real industrial strategy nor "maximizing value for shareholders"; on the face of it, this is just gratuitous trolling of a competitor. It's incredibly sad and really, really unclassy, hence my struggle to understand why they're doing this. However, plenty of people seem to think it's an acceptable move to "disrupt a competitor", so hey.

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by georgemcbay on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:53PM (#5457229)
A more fitting analogy would be:

"Gee, why doesn't Google not sue people who created their own MapReduce (which Google has a number of patents on) implementations?"

Of course the problem with that is they don't sue others who use MapReduce, because while they aren't perfect, Google is pretty good about not abusing the legal system (unlike quite a few tech companies I could name).

Re:The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time by OGinparadise on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:37AM (#5459681)
If Nokia was making $60billion in revenue and $12 Billion in profits, like Google, than maybe. Bottom line is that every company has to do what is best for them, no go along because another one said so. Since things at Nokia aren't going as well, patents might been as having a higher priority. Nokia and others have spent decades inventing stuff about phones.

Google is doing this because they see something in it for themselves, make no mistake. The true intention will show a few years down the line.