They will find a way to make it really hard to block that stuff based on generic rules or by blocking the servers that serve the ads.
That's a fair point, to some extent.
It's no different than pirating stuff
Off the top of my head...
Piracy is illegal, while not watching ads isn't.
In general, when something is sold for a price it's normal to pay so you can buy it, while when ads are displayed in other media there's no expectation that people must stop and look at them and the advertiser knew that up-front.
Consuming pirated content is a security risk if you do the "wrong" thing, while displaying on-line ads is a security risk if you do the "right" thing.
The content providers.
The advertisers.
Me.
I'm ad tolerant; I don't run ad-blockers. This means I get to see all ads. And some of them a really awful. I feel sorry for content creators having to have those on their sites. A 30 minute YouTube video with a 5 minute advert? Those yelling smileys or buzzing mosquitoes? (I politely emails the site owner; I nearly installed ad-block) The really slow loading page-covering ad delaying access to the actual content?
I fully understand why people block ads.
I don't understand why advertisers ever thought that "Annoy the hell out of anyone seeing this advert" was the best way to go.
You're doing the right thing by not installing adblock, but really you should vote with your feet, by just not visiting those sites. As soon as you see ads that annoy you - go away. That's the right thing to do, because then you're not consuming the content. You're always free to consume content or not, but if you do, you should adhere to the rules that the owner of that content set - namely that you also view this ad.
I could say that I actually do whitelist sites to display ads, but we both know that I'm in the minority there, and beside the point.
Then me running AdBlock is not an issue, as the ads will be displayed as part of that requirement. There are numerous sites that do this already.
However, if the site chooses to render the site regardless of the capabilities of my browser, I can assume it's acceptable. Just as radio stations allow me the ability to change stations when commercials come on, or I can mute the TV and not watch the ads, requiring me to consume the advertising is silly.
And yes, I know what you are saying. Blah blah blah, it's what they intend the price to be and all that jazz. But at the end of the day, if I request something from you, and you give it to me, you can't be upset if I choose to read only part of it.
Hell, I counter it's more immoral to put demands on me before I agree to it. You say it's the price of the content? Well, my counter-offer is AdBlock. Sites are free to disagree with this counter-offer. Unless bargaining is off the table.
Should I be ashamed of myself for occasionally using lynx too?
> if everyone did this half the sites you ad-block wouldn't exist.
I'm not worried about that. I pay when given the opportunity for content on the web that I regularly enjoy.
> You're not participating in a fair transaction.
You seem to think that it's unfair that some people are able to negotiate a lower price than others.
You can rationalize it all you want but if everyone did what you propose we do, everything would be far more expensive.
People can and do detect my use of adblock and either ask me to disable it for their site, subscribe to their service, or decide not to serve me the data.
I have every write to request data from you while also instructing my browser not to request ads. You have every right to decide not to serve me any data. Until or unless I actually infringe your copyright, or enter into an agreement to see your ads and then renege, this is not equivalent to piracy.
> "They'll see untargeted ads, which will look like spam. We have to get this information to them somehow."
Oh really, you have to get this information to me? Seriously? I didn't ask for it, I have no desire for it, no you don't have to. You want to, because someone is paying you to do so. Yet another case of someone thinking they have a right to a business model. No you don't. If it fails it fails. Find something to sell that people want (or at least don't despise enough to actively put you out of business).
Speaking as someone who buys a fair bit of advertising, there are thousands of sites in the inventory of most RTB sellers which I'll just skip over unless their inventory is really cheap, because it's very hard to figure out a single product that most of the site's readership would use.
(Example site - Photobucket. What ads would obviously make money on there?)
Also, for quite a few sites where the core demographic does have some obvious interests, there aren't that many well-paying advertisers for that demo. Retargeting and similar tracking-based advertising systems help fill in the gaps when the core advertisers aren't buying all the inventory.
> Without third-party cookies, they will not be able to participate in the existing industry system for privacy protection.
Their privacy is still protected, but they can't participate in the privacy protection system! Oh noes!
> They will see an increase in the irrelevant spam advertising served to them
So you're telling me that when you serve ads for "RightWingNews.com, LiberalOasis.com, MotherhoodWTF.com, and SuburbanDaddy.com [and] thousands of small businesses" there's no possible way to find relevant ads without tracking the user?