News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by Aloha on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:23AM (#5427467)
I shouldnt need a compelling reason to work some place.

I - need a job, presumably they need someone with my skillset, now obvious, there are soft skill concerns, do I match the culture, is it going the direction I feel my career ought to go? Other then that, it should be pretty simple.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by hackinthebochs on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:45AM (#5428325)
A general rule for hiring is that one should never ask a question where its impossible to tell a good bullshit answer from a good answer. The bullshitters will always do better, and thus your biasing your hiring process to bullshitters. Answers to questions should be signal with extremely high information content. A question where a good bullshitter will get a disproportionate amount of points is in fact a net negative to your hiring process.

If you're the type that needs personal validation such that you would knock a candidate for saying something like "I need money, you guys are paying in money", then you simply shouldn't ask the question. Of course, people love to think that they have a highly tuned bullshit detector, are immune to blatant flattery, etc. The problem is everyone thinks that. We are all susceptible to these things and we need to make sure our process is such that its not biased towards people who are particularly good at telling you what you want to hear.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by doktrin on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:15PM (#5429073)
Thanks for writing this. It's a succinct and lucid description of the problem with the "commitment & faith" class of interview questions.

There are two sides to the coin, of course. I personally don't mind being asked about my motivations because I tend to only apply to companies that I actually want to work at (paychecks notwithstanding).

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by pbiggar on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:59PM (#5429019)
I'm hiring at the moment for CircleCI, and if you don't have a reason to work with us, that's a real red flag. That says you have no particular interest in the job, which means you either don't care about what we're building or what our customers need, or you might jump ship if a job comes up that you really do want.

That said, you applied for a job here, so there must be some reason you want it. Maybe "I ended up in a really bad job and I want people who care about their craft", "I love Clojure and you guys write everything in clojure", or "I love your flat organizational structure", or "I like making developer tools". But "i need a job" is a terrible answer, and won't even get you past the phone screen.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by ahk on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:30PM (#5429135)
Every girl wants to feel 'special' too. But really, there's 3.5 billion of them.

You are just going to weed out all the people who are not bullshitting you, and take in all the people who will. And amazingly, you are happy proclaiming this!

I'd thank you for weeding me out though. I like reality. Don't like happy rainbow snowflake dreamland, which you've just outed your company as. Since such things never last.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by pbiggar on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:55PM (#5429260)
It took me a long time to find the special girl for me. If you approach dating as "any girl will do", then I feel sorry for the girl that ends up with you.

I don't know how you translated "wanting to hire people who want to work here" into "happy rainbow snowflake dreamland", but so long as people who don't care about our product or market feel weeded out, then I'm happy. For others reading this who do actually care about the people, product and technology you work with, please let me know at [email protected].

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by jtheory on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:56PM (#5429265)
Meh. Look at the example reasons in the post you're responding to; you don't need an answer like "I want to save the world, and I'm pretty sure the best place to start is in the plastic chair manufacturing sector".

If the best you can offer is "uh I need a job" that means you don't know a damned thing about the company you're applying to, doesn't it? I.e., you found a list of 30 companies that are offering jobs in your city that vaguely match your CV, and instead of reading about them and choosing a few, you're taking the shotgun approach.

If you read about them, what made you choose this one?

Do they seem like they have a culture that's better than your last job? Do they use a language you like (and/or would like to use more)? Are they doing something you know anything about, or find interesting at all, or can at least categorize as "not morally objectionable"? Almost anything is better than "I need a job".

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by cujo on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:44PM (#5429206)
The 'feel special' analogy is a terrible one. Surely you don't propose picking the first person off the street to marry just because they want to be married?
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by SilasX on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:41PM (#5429448)
>"i need a job" is a terrible answer, and won't even get you past the phone screen.

Which is why it should be part of the phone screen. In the article, they didn't even ask this until after the 5 hours of interviews. Ouch.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by vellum on Saturday March 23, 2013 @09:03AM (#5427959)
You shouldn't need a reason. But if it's a close choice between you and someone who's really good at faking enthusiasm, who do you think they're going with? We're only human, and people like being told their company is awesome. It validates their life choices.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by megablast on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:04AM (#5428145)
Yeah, it might be fake, but it could also be the chance to work somewhere amazing. I have gone to a few jobs like this, where the job was fantastic, involved working on grid computing, traveling around europe. I did not have to fake enthusiasm, but I can imagine a lot of people would not have cared for it.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by nonamegiven on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:44PM (#5429207)
I agree with you, but honesty can be expressed in different ways.

"I'd never heard of you guys, but when I was searching around your thing seemed a lot more interesting than some of the other things."

And on the employer side, unless you've actually got tanks out back from having turned water into wine you might notch the erection down a few degrees. There's smart people everywhere, that's not special.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by jfoster on Saturday March 23, 2013 @05:36AM (#5427655)
You don't need it, but perhaps they do. It's far better for an employer if you're particularly enthusiastic about what you're going to be working on.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by Kudos on Saturday March 23, 2013 @06:03AM (#5427698)
I think you probably need a compelling reason if you're not unemployed and they didn't come to you first.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by hmottestad on Saturday March 23, 2013 @06:36AM (#5427725)
Since there are so many companies out there, giving some reason as to why you picked this particular one seems fair.

I would usually go with something compiled together from separate things: - New challenges - Location - Their field of expertise - Their culture

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by Klinky on Saturday March 23, 2013 @09:58AM (#5428118)
This is where it can get murky. If you are firing off a bunch of resumes to jump ship from a poor situation, honesty doesn't get you very far. While if you were targeting the company from the get go, honesty is your best option. It doesn't sound good to say "my current job sucks, and you guys responded to my resume", but if you don't want to say that, then you will scramble to come up with something that sounds like what you think they want to hear.

I can understand how a company wants someone enthusiastic for their product/company, on the other hand I can understand how alienating it is to have to bullshit about the reality of your situation.

Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by timv on Saturday March 23, 2013 @11:04AM (#5428390)
My "go to" answer in that situation is to describe the kind of role I'm looking for, and then give some reasons why I think their company matches that. If I'm wrong, and they're a terrible match, then I don't want them to hire me.
Re:A Tale of Two Interviews, Part 1 by Kequc on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:10AM (#5427845)
If you have any interest whatsoever in the product they are working on's success for example, tell them that. That's a good thing to tell them. If all you want is any job anywhere then you can probably work at Subway. If all you want is any job anywhere that pays as much as they do then at least tell them that.