News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by banned_man on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @02:13PM (#542202)
What about employees who think they deserve to be rated higher on the (somewhat subjective) scope and skills metrics?
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by coglethorpe on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @02:29PM (#542228)
They "negotiate" by leaving.
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by electromagnetic on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @07:40PM (#542663)
I agree, I work in construction where there are clear, visible differences between two employees. If this kind of thing happened at one of the companies I've worked for or with then everyone would quit.

The only people this benefits are the poor employees. I have some natural advantages over the next guy, namely that I can carry about 140 lbs of equipment, while a lot of the guys I've worked with can only carry probably 70-80 lbs. Basically I spend half the time with the petty crap and end up finishing the job sooner. I don't believe I should be getting paid the same as the next guy, I also don't think I should be paid as much as a guy who can carry 200 lbs and can get things done faster than me.

If someone does 20% more than me, they should be paid 20% more. I don't believe in pay brackets and crap like what Unions use, because I've seen what unions do to people. I knew a guy who'd been in a dry waller's union for 20 years, he hadn't had a single pay rise since he got put into a foreman role, and he'd seen a lot of guys his age be canned because their wage was ridiculously high and they were too old to do the heavy lifting.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by LSalin on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @08:23PM (#542709)
Based on Joel's ladder system, you would be paid more because your skills are higher (carrying 140 pounds versus 7-80 pounds for others).
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by ShabbyDoo on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @08:48PM (#542736)
I suspect (from nothing more than your writing skills) that you are quite a skilled tradesman.* Why don't construction companies hire strong but unskilled guys to haul stuff and let you be the guy who does the more technical stuff?

* People who write well generally think well. Construction, beyond brute strength, requires mechanical thought. Therefore,...

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by electromagnetic on Thursday April 02, 2009 @09:44AM (#543304)
It all depends on the construction site. The companies that do building houses and small business offices generally do have a few really strong guys doing the heavy hauling, back in the UK where I worked you'd get a guy carrying like 200 lbs of brick up a ladder.

However, I specialized in the Handy-Man kind of work so there's too many different job sites or the companies too small to actually have a specific guy hauling stuff. So in the jobs I worked you had to be both smart and strong. Electrical, plumbing and gas can be extremely complicated to put in, especially when you're modifying a house that's over 50 years old.

(At 17 I started working as a reviewer and the editor considered me the best they had. So I believe I have a high aptitude for writing. I've had a couple short stories published, and right now I'm working on a novel.)

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by radu_floricica on Thursday April 02, 2009 @05:57AM (#543126)
I have a client company who's receptionist has seen me as a courier, pc-repair main, client and programmer. Freelancing is fun :)
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by aboodman on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @11:48PM (#542884)
Wait, you work in construction and read hacker news?
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by muon on Thursday April 02, 2009 @06:22AM (#543148)
In have seen people, who leave at the critical time of project execution, then they back off with better deal.

This has made sick of those kind people, and the management. In the end others look foolish for being honest.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @02:37PM (#542237)
Immediately, you've now moved beyond salary and are discussing job performance.

That's what you want to be discussing after all.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by TomOfTTB on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @02:51PM (#542254)
You're just using word play to try to validate your point. Any salary discussion is going to go straight to the employee's performance.

The problem with this system is it takes the focus off that individual employees performance and puts it on the rest of the office's performance. Suddenly you aren't talking about how good that employee is you're talking about why Joe in the next cubicle over rates higher than him.

That's exactly where you don't want salary negotiations to go.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:08PM (#542270)
It not word play; there's a difference between "You aren't paying me enough for the work I'm doing" and "I don't belong at the level you say I do."

The former is open to much more interpretation than the latter, being that the latter has a documented set of predefined expectations, such as years of experience and daily duties. It's hard to be obscure about whether or not you lead a project, or whether or not you have 5 years experience. Joe in the next cubicle rates higher because he is either your - or your colleagues' - senior. This is self evident.

What you are left doing is saying "I lead my project better than Joe leads his project." This isn't a salary conversation, it's an annual bonus conversation. Annual bonuses are designed to measure performance in most cases.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by TomOfTTB on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:20PM (#542293)
I still don’t agree in that I simply don’t think the real world works that way.

On the Joel point: Joel runs a small-ish company and it’s become obvious in several HN threads that his employees are people who essentially worship the ground he walks on. That’s great for them, for him, and for that company and I’m happy for them all. But what that distinction means is that sometimes Joel’s advice doesn’t apply to the rest of the world outside his little utopia.

In my experience living in the rest of the world people don’t respond well to "your salary has nothing to do with your performance but you MIGHT get more 9 months from now." A bonus is great but it’s just that: a bonus. Salary is where employees are paid for their services and that’s where they expect to be rewarded for their performance.

Again, hopefully your employees are well off enough that they couldn’t care less about waiting 9 months. But in my experience the "wait for your annual bonus line" usually leads people to look for companies that pay their employees based on their performance.

P.S. You still didn't address my central point which is the fact that this method puts the focus on other people's performance in relation to the employee rather than the employee's performance alone

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:43PM (#542333)
I have no comment whatsoever on Joel, his company, or his products. I don't know him, anyone in his company and don't use his products. I've taken issue with him previously on this forum.

However, I think you're misunderstanding a Base Salary with a Performance Bonus - which may or may not be annual - and the notion of Total Compensation.

In most companies, including mine, the idea is a that a salary is what you earn in exchange for doing your job to the minimum expected standard. The only reason these salaries aren't equivalent to legislated minimum wage across the board is that there are market forces involved that companies must work within. Joel is simply stating that in most organizations, there is a drive to push this salary as low as possible, and that this creates problems. I see nothing in mine or other's experience that is contrary to that point.

His solution is to basically simplify this equation, and publish it. That's the exact same thing that every union workforce has. The only issue he has with this is that if he miscalculates the market value of a certain level, he'll basically create the conditions for a strike. He recognizes this and explains his workarounds in the article. He also retains the notion of a bonus to help him recognize those he chooses to.

Salary is where employees are paid for their services and that’s where they expect to be rewarded for their performance.

This is clearly where your opinion differs, but this attitude creates the entire situation that Joel is commenting on.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by gommm on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @04:16PM (#542390)
I'm quite sure that the bonus at fog creek is not based on performance... It is based on profit (he does say that he has a profit sharing plan) but joel is against giving bonuses as incentive... see http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000070.html

Compared to the situation at my old company where salary was determined by how well you negociated, I'm quite sure I prefer joel's version. And when reading the ladder http://joelonsoftware.com/articles/ladder.html, it's clear enough so that any disagreement are probably going to be minor (since he's using the average of skill and scope in a lot of cases a one point difference in the skill or scope won't make any difference to the level)

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @05:19PM (#542468)
Thanks for the clarification. And yeah, I agree with you, I'm quite fond of Joel's system on the surface.
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by wlievens on Thursday April 02, 2009 @04:05AM (#543048)
Bonuses are typically based on profit, and then use a small multiplier for performance.
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by TomOfTTB on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:47PM (#542342)
If the performance bonus isn't annual than it's no different than a salary. In terms of an employee asking for a raise, how is asking for a larger performance bonus any different than asking for a higher salary?

You've just categorized the money differently in your head at that point.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:53PM (#542356)
If the performance bonus isn't annual than it's no different than a salary.

Of course it is, in that it's the result of an outcome and isn't guaranteed.

There is no company in the world that would mind you asking for a larger bonus. After a certain level however, you need to qualify the value you bring to earn that bonus. If I said to my employer: "If I bring in 200 new users this year, will you give me X more (where X is a percentage of the revenue generated by 200 users) in bonus?"; No competent manager would deny you this.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by TomOfTTB on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @03:57PM (#542363)
I suppose I can see the distinction in that this allows a company to tailor how much each person makes dependent on their performance in a given time frame.

That said I certainly wouldn't want to work for that company. Basically what they're saying is "we don't trust you the employee to continue to perform optimally so we're going to make you prove yourself each and every (whatever the time period is) to get a bonus" while the employee has to wonder how much their pay check will be every month (or whatever)

That seems more cruel than anything

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @04:03PM (#542373)
I'm sorry Tom, but in 95% of for-profit enterprise, you are continually measured against the bottom line, and your performance is constantly evaluated.

Most companies do this via your salary in a secretive ranking ladder - which is exactly what Joel is speaking against.

I think you agree with him much more than you you think you do. :-)

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by RobGR on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @02:16PM (#542206)
Yeah, I agree - the negotiation comes in when someone says they are rated too low, asks to talk to the review comittee about it, and leaves when they don't get it.

That said, I think this system is probably superior to most.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by rgoddard on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @04:27PM (#542403)
If they think they should be rated higher, then they should give the reasons why. If those reasons are valid, then the employer can change the rating. If the employer is unwilling to change it for irrational reasons, that means that the rating system is not objective and the system is undermined and has lost its meaning. This becomes a separate problem entirely.

If the reasons for valuing themselves more are not valid or applicable to the company, then the employee is over valuing themselves in this context. If the employee is not willing to accept this, then they have the option of declining the offer and moving on.