Of course it is, in that it's the result of an outcome and isn't guaranteed.
There is no company in the world that would mind you asking for a larger bonus. After a certain level however, you need to qualify the value you bring to earn that bonus. If I said to my employer: "If I bring in 200 new users this year, will you give me X more (where X is a percentage of the revenue generated by 200 users) in bonus?"; No competent manager would deny you this.
That said I certainly wouldn't want to work for that company. Basically what they're saying is "we don't trust you the employee to continue to perform optimally so we're going to make you prove yourself each and every (whatever the time period is) to get a bonus" while the employee has to wonder how much their pay check will be every month (or whatever)
That seems more cruel than anything
Most companies do this via your salary in a secretive ranking ladder - which is exactly what Joel is speaking against.
I think you agree with him much more than you you think you do. :-)
You've just categorized the money differently in your head at that point.