Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by MrQuincle on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:47AM
(#5415884)
Perhaps some more attention need to be paid to keyboard people. :-) Just Ctrl and arrow to move things around e.g. and selection tools would be good. Personally though, I w'd like to actually generate a diagram like that without drawing anything, just a few lines of code, and preferably generated bottom-up from the code base itself, instead of concocted by some person who actually doesn't know how the system works, but that's my opinion on use cases in UML. :-)
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by arethuza on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:27AM
(#5415226)
No - I loathe the concept of UML almost as much as most of the ghastly tools that have been created to work with it [NB important to note that I am not including umlbin in this comment as I haven't tried it].
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by dmgrow on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:35AM
(#5415287)
I work at Lucidchart (http://www.lucidchart.com), a browser-based diagramming tool, and I can definitely confirm that UML is still used very widely. Though I can't share specifics, I can confirm it's among our most popular diagram types.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by trigras on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:15AM
(#5415129)
Strangely it is not dead. Do not know how widely it is used. From other hand what are other good standardized options to share/document software structure and behavior?
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by reeses on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:30PM
(#5421226)
A lot of people use it as intended, but most of us use a minimal variant to communicate ideas on a whiteboard or email. It also usually sticks to class and maybe interaction diagrams.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by xk_id on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:12AM
(#5415109)
Even my rather trivial undergraduate UML project required very advanced options, and the only software that fully satisfied my needs was astah professional. I struggled a lot with browser-based UML tools, always to come across a feature I needed but wasn't supported. It was very frustrating, because I had to restart work on several platform, until I gave up and started using astah.
For this reason, I personally avoid web-based UML tools ever since. But, there might be reasonable use cases for them.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by dmgrow on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:33AM
(#5415279)
Interesting to hear. Have you tried Lucidchart - http://www.lucidchart.com. We turn around improvements very quickly and I'd be interested to hear if it meets your needs, and if not, what we're currently missing for you. You can reach me at support [at] ...
And if you're still a student, we give free upgrades to Pro accounts so we'd be happy to hook you up.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by xk_id on Thursday March 21, 2013 @02:58PM
(#5417845)
Thanks. Actually, my university (UCL) was oferred access to Lucidchart for its students for that project that we did. So it was one of the web-based tools I tried. Looking over the paper I wrote, it seems I actually did happily use it for the domain model, the use case diagram and an early version of the class diagram. However, I think for the sequence diagrams I found it a bit clumsy (for example regarding activation boxes) and eventually gave up.
I should note that I think most (probably almost all) of my classmates also happily used Lucidchart, as it was recommended by the lecturer too. But I was a bit overzealous and preferred the more rigorous system of astah, like keeping track of the methods you add to each class and the stricter visual organisation of elements.
As for particular examples of UML elements that I wish lucidchart had, I can't really remember, unfortunately.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by davidjgraph on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:03AM
(#5415054)
Nice simple idea. Where are the diagrams stored? What measures are taken to avoid them being lost?
I could work out most of the interactions. I suspect people will struggle with connecting two vertices with an edge. You need some kind of visual indication that the creation of an edge has started. Maybe highlight the start vertex and preferably show a preview of the edge after you move around after having clicked on the source vertex.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by trigras on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:12AM
(#5415111)
Diagrams are stored in database.
Did not get about "lost diagrams"? Why should they be lost?
Generally agree there still are places for polishing. The idea was to create app that can just do it's job , to see if UML is still used at all (as stblack also asked) and then polish it according to the feedaback.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by mchaver on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:55AM
(#5415414)
Honest question, in what sort of situations is using UML diagrams beneficial? I have only used them in school, but never professionally. The most immediate use case I can think of is API, documentation for large code, etc., but lots of bad buzzwords pop into my head when I hear UML like huge Java programs and over management. That's probably not fair. Anyway, it's a nice looking project. Keep up the good work!
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by Someone on Thursday March 21, 2013 @01:32PM
(#5417115)
It helps me designing software and communicate the design to others. I find 'claying' with a design on the whiteboard both easier and faster than doing that in code.
The 'UML is useless; read the code' meme, IMO, is like the 'XML is overly complex' one. Both technologies can and have been overhyped and overused, but that does not mean all their use is useless.
Having said that, I think the idea to make UML complete in the sense that you can model any program in full detail with it and then generate source code as a sort of assembly from it has, to say it lightly, not yet brought the benefits proponents claimed it would, and has needlessly complicated the grammar for other use cases such as the one above.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by dsmithn on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:06AM
(#5415076)
This is the kind of thing that by the time I need to make another diagram I will have forgotten about it. Hopefully I'll never need to, but if I do I'm bookmarking this in hopes I'll remember.
It's not complicated, no fancy UI or flashy landing page. Nice web app.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by trigras on Friday March 22, 2013 @03:34AM
(#5421794)
Basically only tool selection menu was added (and some context menu removed ;). IMHO to use it out of the box it's quite easy, just maybe there is lack of documentation. As main drawbacks I could note missing documentation and not so easy configurable .. However at the moment it fits my needs.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by devgutt on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:53AM
(#5415399)
I used to use UML diagrams a lot, especially Sequence diagrams. But some time ago I started to use the own code as my sequence diagram, without comments, only declarative enough names. IMO Sequence diagrams are really helpful to explore ideas and make the first analysis, but terrible afterwards to maintain the code.
Re:Show HN: quickly share UML diagrams
by danesparza on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:00AM
(#5415461)
I'm pretty sure it's because you're using an AWS micro instance and trying to use tomcat java & mysql. Micro instances aren't good at that type of thing -- the instance is probably IO bound because it either a.) ran out of memory and is swapping or b.) disk access is being governed by AWS (because it's a micro instance)
oh my god im literally in tears. This is the best thing ever right when I wake up.
I'm sorry people are abusing your hard work though, I know thats a bummer. :(
http://app.umlbin.com/view.a?show=8a78d3b23d8d5a99013d8d62ff...
http://app.umlbin.com/view.a?show=8a78d3b23d8d5a99013d8d6588...
http://app.umlbin.com/view.a?show=8a78d3b23d8d5a99013d8d70a1...
What greeted me, however, when I opened the site is this:
http://app.umlbin.com/view.a?show=8a78d3b23d8d5a99013d8d698e...
Sketches are good (http://www.martinfowler.com/bliki/UmlAsSketch.html) but if you are simple sketching things then in my opinion you don't need all of the baggage that comes with UML.
Flow charts and swimlanes are much more common.
For this reason, I personally avoid web-based UML tools ever since. But, there might be reasonable use cases for them.
And if you're still a student, we give free upgrades to Pro accounts so we'd be happy to hook you up.
I should note that I think most (probably almost all) of my classmates also happily used Lucidchart, as it was recommended by the lecturer too. But I was a bit overzealous and preferred the more rigorous system of astah, like keeping track of the methods you add to each class and the stricter visual organisation of elements.
As for particular examples of UML elements that I wish lucidchart had, I can't really remember, unfortunately.
I could work out most of the interactions. I suspect people will struggle with connecting two vertices with an edge. You need some kind of visual indication that the creation of an edge has started. Maybe highlight the start vertex and preferably show a preview of the edge after you move around after having clicked on the source vertex.
Thanks.
The 'UML is useless; read the code' meme, IMO, is like the 'XML is overly complex' one. Both technologies can and have been overhyped and overused, but that does not mean all their use is useless.
Having said that, I think the idea to make UML complete in the sense that you can model any program in full detail with it and then generate source code as a sort of assembly from it has, to say it lightly, not yet brought the benefits proponents claimed it would, and has needlessly complicated the grammar for other use cases such as the one above.
It's not complicated, no fancy UI or flashy landing page. Nice web app.
I ask because jsUML2 looks interesting and I am wondering how usable it is out of the box. (I need statecharts which umlbin doesn't yet support).
Feature request: sequence diagrams. They love those things.
AWS micro instance apache + tomcat java, mysql
My ques is that may be due to some misconfiguration (java or tomcat).
http://www.yuml.me/