I also appreciate what an actual IDE offers in those environments. I use VS (C#) and WebStorm (NodeJS) more than anything lately.. and wouldn't give them up. I'm impressed when I see people get work done in VIM... I just don't think that way, and don't manage to memorize a bunch of hotkeys I don't use at least 10 times a day. Hard enough keeping the step keys for debugging in different IDEs straight, let alone, more esoteric things.
In my opinion, tooling is very important. You want something that makes you a wizard - something that's smooth and FAST.
I once worked with a very experienced gentleman who preferred Notepad to write 3-page-long SQL queries. He knew his craft very well, got the job done, but boy did he take his time :-)
As a Vim user, I consider the whole productivity thing about it quite over-rated. Yes it's efficient, yes it's faster, but in the end, anyone with a decent editor is going to go faster after a while.
The point is comfort. Once vim's mechanics are assimilated, you starts to memorize meaningful sequence of letters, like ci". And those sequences are just words you're typing, so typing code or entering commands is exactly the same thing.
And none of this require going too far frome the home row with your hands. This in my opinion is why Vim is so good :)
It is much more productive to use it in ST, just because I get immediate feedback. I get the full result in the editor in realtime, just as I'm writing the Zen Coding mantra.
The jump around all folder files in ST? Ctrl-P. It has fast and beautiful fuzzy matching. Do I need to open a file called Module/SuperCalliFractillicious.something? Ctrl-P, mscf, enter. File is opened and the cursor placed wherever it was the last time I edited it. Which could have been months ago.
Git integration? covered in several fronts. Git gutter was first seen in ST.
I do agree that tooling is very important. ST is a serious tool. Do not compare it to notepad.
OFMs like Far Manager, Midnight Commander or similar might fill that niche. Far does for me, at least and I tend to spend my time editing code either there, in VS or Eclipse, depending on the language and project. But it's more a file manager with an editor (which needs a few plugins to be used for coding) than an editor with a command line.
Sublime is really pretty, and has great functionality out of the box.
Ultimately, vi/vim's contribution is the modal editing method (and derived things like motions), which can be transplanted to any other IDE or editor that cares to support it. But for the fundamendals - editing and switching between files - I've so far found vim to be the cleanest, most natural vim.
[1]: http://jelv.is/emacs-blackboard.png
Also, have you tried Evil? Apparently it's a very good Vim-emulation mode for Emacs, highly recommended over Viper.
I haven't tried Evil, in my last emacs phase it wasn't mature yet IIRC - maybe I should give that a go and see if it tips the balance yet again.
Obligatory vim can be pretty too, and I am happy with how mine looks.
http://i.imgur.com/ZC2xDxH.png
On a related note, I like how my terminal vim looks better than how the GUI looks. I don't use emacs much, but same goes for emacs.
My screenshot doesn't have custom status bar shapes. GP does. Anyway, for that, you need powerline(available for both vim and emacs).
My color theme is ir_black https://github.com/wgibbs/vim-irblack If you are using it in terminal, you also need to set up ir_black theme for the terminal.
[1]: https://github.com/jonathanchu/emacs-powerline/blob/master/p...
Not sure what that means
> even after having in aggregate spent many days customizing it
Do your work and if you find you can add something to your ~/.emacs then do
> Vim feels cleaner and less annoying,
I cannot empathise with that. Model editing is awful. I feel like i should have a foot pedal to actually toggle it
/oldest debate in the world
2. By the end of month 1-2, vim had become completely second nature. I did stuff without thinking. Actually, thinking about what I was doing started to confuse me.
3. Sure we all spend lots of time thinking, but I also often find myself cranking out code and vim is quite amazing for that.
4. I ended up switching to emacs because a) I like learning about tools (see #1) b) emacs gives you a more IDE-like experience c) while retaining 90% of vim's editing power d) and in general has the similar "become an editor expert" philosophy to optimizing editing workflow
I haven't used sublime, but I'm quite fond of editors that are keyboard-only (especially for jumping around, etc.), cross-platform, have stood the test of time and have endless extensibility.
edit: I have customized both vim and emacs to crazy depths. There was a time when just as I started to code, I'd say "why can't I do this [blah] drudgery automatically?" and end up writing an emacs function to do it :-)