I maybe mistaken here, but I'm fairly sure reporting / reviews are classed as 'fair use'.
If this was ever to go to court, then I'm certain the judge would just throw the case out. However GoPro would never push it that far, their aim is just to take the review offline for the immediate 2 weeks in the hope that when it goes back online, most people would have moved on. Ironically though, GoPro have attracted significantly more attention to the article by trying to bury the review.
I say "ironically", but "deservedly" equally works. I hope this serves as a warning to other companies wishing to abuse DMCA take downs (though I doubt it will).
The only thing I can think of that would even be plausible is if the review site used official images of the product in its review without authorization. But the notice doesn't even begin to hint at that theory.
I'd tend to agree that this doesn't extend to straightforward images used to identify the product in a consumer review, but I'm not so sure it's as cut an dry a case as you think.
Right, if the photograph amounts to a reproduction of something that is itself copyrightable then it is copying and could be infringement. But a camera isn't copyrightable.
Elsewhere in this comment page, someone notes that the review is actually strongly favors the GoPro. Maybe this is some kind of incredibly perverse strategy...?
On the other hand, their brand recognition may go up...
I think it's more like "Only authorised online retailers can use GoPro's images to advertise GoPro products." Which is fair enough, since GoPro owns their photos, although seems like it will only hit the lowest effort retailers.
Either way, their DMCA notice was horribly worded.
Plus why does someone have to be an authorised retailer to sell a product? Once GoPro sells it to a wholesaler it literally isn't their stuff any more (first sale doctrine), now there are certain laws protecting GoPro from things like counterfeiting or trademark violations (basically still just counterfeiting) but that doesn't apply here (since they're selling the original product).
Does this also mean that if someone buys a GoPro and decides to sell it on eBay second hand GoPro are going to try and have it taken down? Haven't the courts found that that is unlawful (there was a big Oracle case about it I believe[1])?
In general GoPro just took a huge nosedive in terms of my opinion of them. Their statement actually lowers my opinion more than the original DMCA notice did.
[1]http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120703/11345519566/eu-cou...