News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by mikeash on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @08:03PM (#5404578)
> As much as you don't need it, a $2000 60" HDTV is still more functional than a purse that costs the same amount of money.

Are you serious? Is this a joke?

A purse actually serves a useful function. It doesn't serve $2000 of function, but it's useful in that it lets you carry around important items.

A TV serves no useful purpose whatsoever. None. Zero. There is nothing useful in your life that the TV lets you do.

I think your bias might be showing here just a little bit.

Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by wutbrodo on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @09:24PM (#5404945)
The purchase of the TV itself is not what's being discussed here, and frankly a bit of a strawman. As useless as it may be, a lot of households consider TV an essential item, so the question of TV marketing affecting men more has to do with _which_ television you buy, as opposed to buying a TV per se. Per Nielsen, women watch significantly more TV than men anyway[1], so talking about marketing to men in the context of _whether_ to buy a TV is pointless.

As far as the _quality_ of the TV being purchased, it seems the point that GP was making (whether I agree with his larger point or not) is that the 60" TV fills its function a lot better than the 19" one which costs a tenth of the price. By contrast, as far as I know there is no correlation to "how well a purse carries items" and its price (beyond the very very low end, of course, but far from the $2000 level). GP's point was that the price difference between a 200 and 2000 dollar purse is being spent almost entirely on brand (even the appearance is the same, when you consider off-brand purses), and the difference between a 200 and 2000 dollar TV is being spent on a VERY large difference in quality as far as functionality. This distinction between "paying for brand" and "paying for functionality" is exactly the point that GP is making about marketing.

As a thought experiment, consider what would happen if Sony started selling its current flagship $2000 TV for 20 dollars, and it was widely known and permanent. Now consider what would happen if the same happened for Louis Vuitton's flagship $2000 handbag. The perceived value of the handbag would vanish almost instantly. No one wants a status symbol that's cheap. You can't destroy _real_ consumer value (vs brand/marketing value) that easily just by dropping the price.

[1]http://techcrunch.com/2012/10/05/nielsen-gaming-tv-console/

Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by Zimahl on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @08:14PM (#5404629)
You are saying that a TV that probably costs to make at least a portion of that $2000 is worth less than a purse that can be knocked off to look EXACTLY THE SAME but cost 2 orders of magnitude less are the same?

I won't bother arguing the value of a TV. I think there are many that can argue the value of a designer purse.

Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by eli on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @08:39PM (#5404748)
What does the cost of manufacturing have to do with an item's utility? You can get a cheap knockoff TV that looks the same as the expensive brand too... It will look the same from a distance, anyway. Just like a cheap knockoff purse.
Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by mikeash on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @09:04PM (#5404862)
We're not talking about worth. The exact words were, "more functional". A purse is obviously more functional than a TV.
Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by g8oz on Tuesday March 19, 2013 @10:10PM (#5405160)
It could be argued that killing time is a function.
Re:Diamonds Are Bullshit by mikeash on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:41AM (#5407165)
Of course, in exactly the same way that it could be argued that "showing off your wealth with designer accessories" is a function.