It's massively hypocritical to single out diamonds amongst all this.
> "If you're an American, your comfortable life exists because of the American government's willingness to inflict violence on other people to maintain our status in the world"
There are few alternatives with our current technology, if the american way of life is not to be negotiated, so let's leave that aside. In any case, when north america becomes self sufficient again or even a net exporter of energy, things will change.
OTOH, for diamonds, there does not seems to be any change in sight. They are a massive hypocrisy, with the huge negative externality of fuelling wars and human misery - and they are controlled by a monopolist!
I'm sorry maybe I'm too heartless and an economist in the soul, but I just can't dig this idea. Diamonds are awful in any way I can see them. And I miss my life partner because of this IT WILL BE A GOOD THING: better splitting up early : both the costs and the emotional attachment will be lower.
EDIT: you talk about taking a train, walking, relocating - that's not acceptable for most people; also it will cause them undue burdens. Replacing a shiny rock by a purer shinier rock is possible and simple. It just requires some cultural or legal changes (think bald eagle feathers) which seems already underway.
The negative externality caused by diamonds is tiny in comparison to the ones caused by fossil fuels.
For individuals, there are reasonable, cost-effective substitutes to reduce oil consumption. I take an electric train to work and walk everywhere else. I own a car, but drive it maybe once a month. People choose to drive, they choose to live in places like Silicon Valley where driving is part of the culture, they choose to live in suburbs, etc. We could use a lot less oil if people chose to life in places like New York. But the choice to live a car-centric lifestyle probably won't engender as much vitriol here on HN as the choice to buy a diamond engagement ring, even though in the grand scheme of things it's far more damaging.
Not in the USA.
Building anything other than car-dependent sprawl is illegal in the USA. The few areas grandfathered in before New Deal laws and regulations in the 1930s are expensive for their scarcity. It's a major driver of NY and SF real estate prices that you're not allowed to build anything like them anywhere in the USA.
And if you do move to NY or SF, you're not doing the environment any good. You just displaced someone else out of the city into car-dependent sprawl. The only way to use quality and efficient urbanism to improve the environment is to build more of it and no demand or price increase will do that because, as I mentioned, it's illegal.
I recommend "The High Cost of Free Parking" by Dr. Shoup, and "The Geography of Nowhere" by Kunstler if you want to understand more.
For individuals, there are reasonable, cost-effective
substitutes to reduce oil consumption.
That may be true in Europe and the East coast but it is not true for large remote country areas etc. It's certainly not true for where I live -- there are no bus/train routes that can get me to my workplace from my home, and I cannot re-locate because of my financial position. I know of countless others in similarly tied positions with not much freedom of choice.http://www.theatlanticcities.com/commute/2012/12/are-silicon... http://www.theatlanticcities.com/commute/2013/01/silicon-val...
Comparatively, there is basically no lifestyle difference required to wear a ring without a diamond.
Many people doing other stupid and wasteful things is a poor justification to do any particular stupid and wasteful thing.
No it's not. Diamonds are far more optional than fuel. And tackling small problems does not need to be put off just because you haven't tackled a larger on yet. Faulty logic.
It's also really fulfilling. Just don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
You're trying to handwave over the fact that you're accepting something instead of dealing with it temporarily.
And if you're doing that, you've already lost, you just haven't admitted it to yourself.
Don't you get it? Here, right here and right now, is where we're having a conversation about what we want to value. And you're on the side that says we should still value it, and trying to excuse yourself by saying we're not having all of the other conversations.
But we are. Just not here.
2) I didn't say adoption is bad for smart parents I said its not equivalent to having children of your own for smart parents. There aren't exactly a ton of children of high IQ couples in the adoption market. My bother in law is adopted and he is a doll and adoption is great. But it's not completely equivalent to having your own kids.
2) I should've let it go, I have no desire to argue to have an irrelevant discussion about adoption that already offends my sensibilities.
I care that when the lens is focused on you, the only defense you have is that you're just as bad as the rest of us.
It's completely non-inspirational and devoid of the idea that we should try to be better.
It's as empty as the diamonds you're defending.
He's pointing out that you have a relatively weak argument to be standing on if you are going to get outraged over how evil diamond are, then continue to happily consume dozens of other "evil" products in your everyday life. The only reason these other "evil" products are being brushed under the table is they are much harder for you to do without day to day than a diamond.
This is utter failure.
Do you think I'm not outraged at all the other things we see?
It absolutely _infuriates_ me that you expect me _not_ to be outraged at something because I should be _more_ outraged at _everything_.
It's _so useless_. It's _so dysfunctional_.
Believe me, my outrage is very _active_ and directed towards things outside this conversation.
In this conversation, though, it just seems to me that... there's just nothing ambiguous! Diamonds are awful. They're just awful.
And if that means I'm firing on a hair-trigger, well... so be it.
Inconsistent with what? Only with the position you have projected on your readers. You can't say to your readers, "I assume you believe this. Therefore, you are illogical and inconsistent". That is illogical.
Raynier posted this deep down in a reply which might be lost to you if you don't read all the comments. It would be a shame to miss it. Read it, along with the reasoning where he says such criterias would be perfectly valid for his own daughter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5404423
It seems perfectly valid, yet I could not disagree more. We are forgetting a important (4) : you fund atrocious wars and dictatorships. That's a strong negative externality.
When you see a diamonds, instead of seeing a shiny rock, you should see part of a human soul instead, a fraction of a person who died in vain for this worthless piece of rock you want for your wives or daughters to "sustain the tradition".
If social convention required 1 pound of flesh taken by the knife on a living human, would you insist on it, for the sake of the tradition? (I fear many would - after all, it matches the 1,2,3 requirements)
If social convention requires a diamond, which you know very well will cause war, death and misery, and if you did not say yes to the previous question, why are you insisting on it?
It strikes me as illogical, inconsistent. Either you believe that human life is more important than tradition, or you don't. I can understand diverging opinions, I can hardly understand inconsistency in a system of belief, so I'm very sad to see intelligent replies advocating this 1,2,3 argument while missing the huge downside #4 is.
Maybe someday the sale of things containing "natural diamonds" will be banned - just like the sale of things containing bald eagles feathers.
IHMO, it should: as much as I love the market and freedom, sometimes externalities are just too big to be ignored - especially when there is also a monopolist in action, and perfect substitutes like man made diamonds.