News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:06AM (#5393843)
Calling the "naturalistic fallacy" a fallacy is a bit of an overstretch IMO, sure natural=better is not a rule true 100% of the time, but nevertheless until sufficient evidence has not been accumulated that some of the adjustments we make to our lifestyle are not harmful to us health-wise avoiding them is not an unreasonable heuristic to follow. One example is how it became clear in the last years in nutritional science that in general the more processed the food is the more harmful it is for us.

There is also the reverse problem, illustrated by the condescending attitude toward herbalism in this article, of people who idealize modernity, and for example believe only medicine in the form of pills can be effective, even though plants may contain exactly the same chemical compounds. I am not saying there is no fraud in herbalism, sure there is plenty of it, but herbs in general clearly can have strong both positive and negative effect on physiology, which is really quite obvious if you consider the variety of herbs existing and that they all contain lots of different chemical compounds.

In general I think it is ridiculous to ignore the thousands of years of experimentation and exploration of our ancestors just because it wasn't "science-based".

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by klodolph on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:24AM (#5393951)
I recently went to the doctor and got a recommendation to try one of three different medicines. Two were "supplements" and the third one was an off-label psychiatric medication. Each drug had its own set of side effects, and I chose one of the supplements because the off-label psychiatric drug required a prescription. I just didn't think "natural" versus "artificial" was relevant.

The things that concern me about herbalism are simple:

1. The compounds in herbs are not tested as rigorously as "modern" drugs, at least by the FDA in the US. Knowledge of side effects and safe dosage is more limited.

2. Herbs are often subject to variation in dosages from pill to pill, because the source plant matter is variable and the actual yields are difficult to determine.

It's not about ignoring thousands of years of experimentation, it's just that our standards are higher, and the old experiments were poorly conducted. We want to know the side effects and the interactions. We want to know the drug's mechanism. We want to know about the possible complications. We want to know the effective dose and the unsafe dose. And we want to be able to isolate things: herbs contain many chemicals: you might want one of the chemicals, but not want the side effects from one of the other chemicals.

It reminds me of the almond extract you can buy at the store. The natural almond extract tastes the same as artificial almond extract, but the natural almond extract contains more cyanide. People pay a premium for things labeled "natural".

The heuristic to use natural things works well for foods, but it's a harmful heuristic when considering drugs. It's also a bad heuristic for heating your home (wood fires), immunizing your children (let them die from whooping cough), family planning (pull out), et cetera.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:02AM (#5394188)
It's funny you mention family planning, it's actually a great example for what I am saying. Pull out might not be the best strategy for avoiding kids, but also effectively avoiding kids isn't something too heavily promoted by evolution ;) and in a sense you wouldn't do bad to stick to it if survival is the ultimate goal. You mention how modern drugs are rigorously tested, but just recently there was a big affair about Bayers contraceptive pills used by millions of women worldwide causing blood clogs:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drospirenone#Adverse_effects

So, being so incredibly lucky to be part of several thousands of years old lineage of people who managed to survive, it isn't unwise to stick to the traditional ways of living, when the new way wasn't tested for sufficiently long and/or when the old way wasn't proved to be harmful - remember I am talking about using it as a heuristic in situations where we don't have full knowledge. I am not saying that every single aspect of it will be beneficial, just that you will be unlikely to do very badly when following this strategy, simply because it was tested over a very long timespan.

Nassim Taleb makes a similar point in his book "Antifragile". To be honest I hated the book and think much of it is crap, but this aspect I agree with.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by klodolph on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:18AM (#5394283)
Yes, you can name a drug with bad side effects. FDA isn't 100% effective, my point is that the standards for herbal remedies are comparatively worse than those for "modern" drugs.

Kava has been linked to liver failure, Comfrey causes liver damage, Chaparral causes liver damage, and Pennyroyal is basically toxic. St John's Wort has so many interactions it's basically unsafe to take in conjunction with anything. On top of this, herbal medicines are often poorly-sourced, and substitutions are made overseas. The regulations just aren't good enough.

Then when you talk about the pull-out method of family planning, you say it's a good technique because you'll have kids. That's some impressive double-speak. Next you'll tell me that Caffeine is a good sleep aid because evolution wants you to be more productive.

The FDA's regulatory tools simply work better on "modern" drugs. Look at how Thalidomide was never approved for sale in the US, because the FDA said that more studies were needed. By comparison, "dietary supplements" can only be removed from the market if they show "significant or unreasonable risk". If those standards had been applied to Thalidomide, the human cost would have been terrible.

(Note: Apologies for the over-use of quote marks. "Modern" isn't quite the right term here, some of these drugs are quite old, but I'm not sure what is the right term.)

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:26AM (#5394340)
Then when you talk about the pull-out method of family planning, you say it's a good technique because you'll have kids. That's some impressive double-speak. Next you'll tell me that Caffeine is a good sleep aid because evolution wants you to be more productive.

I didn't phrase it clear enough, I admit, but what I meant is only that avoiding contraceptive pills would free you from the exposure to the pretty bad side effect they turned out to have even though they were supposedly well tested. I just used it as an illustration of my point that being a bit sceptical towards the very new lifestyle approaches is not a bad rule of thumb in abscence of other considerations.

I also of course agree herbs can have serious side effects. You really seem to want to turn it into an X vs Y thing where there has to be one winner. I just want to say that despite all the bad press science seems to indicate using herbs in some particular situations in particular ways might be very beneficial.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by klodolph on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:45AM (#5394451)
> You really seem to want to turn it into an X vs Y thing where there has to be one winner.

The only X versus Y here is scrutiny. Read my posts a little more carefully: my criticism of herbal remedies is not about the fact that they are herbal, but the fact that they are understood little and regulated poorly. That's not a problem with the remedies themselves, but with the laws and systems of incentives driving scientific research.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by saalweachter on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:26AM (#5393962)
The problem with herbalism is that it's the first place science-based medicine went looking for drugs. For basically any herb and effect someone ascribes to it, there have already been twenty rigorous studies, and either no statistical effect was found or the responsible chemicals were extracted, purified, concentrated, and synthesized and are now marketed under two brand names and three generics.

Going to herbs directly isn't going where no science has been before. At best you're getting a known drug which is poorly dosed and mixed with a shotgun of other chemicals which may be harmful. At worst you've just got a cocktail of potentially harmful (remember, even most of the "good" effects come from poisons the plants produce to keep things from eating them) chemicals with no actual benefit.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:52AM (#5394118)
Yours is a very common response I get to this - I wonder why, since there is absolutely no evidence for it. You vastly underestimate the number of plants in existence and vastly overestimate the fraction we have been able to study rigorously. You also hugely simplify the chemistry of it all, the main advantage of plants over modern medicine in its typical form is that they contain complex compounds of chemical substances which show a synergy in a certain direction e.g. they interact with the body in a different way when they are administered together than if they would be ingested separately. Analyzing such compounds and the interactions between them is still often beyond the current state of science and is also not as well funded as traditional drug research, simply because traditional drugs are easier to sell.

Please don't have the impression that I am somehow advocating herbs over traditional medicine, I don't, and there are surely problems with using herbs, but those are different problems that the one most often mentioned. The material you use has to be rather fresh because the concentration of active substances degenerates with time very quickly, the concentration also varies a lot from one area of growth to another so it might be difficult to come up with dosages, they can have serious side effects just like traditional medicine, they are inconvenient to store and use etc.

You can find scientific references for most of what I said and anyway it would come to no surprise to a second-year biology undergraduate. Just reading the wikipedia page about herbalism would clarify a lot of misunderstanding on the topic:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbalism

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by saalweachter on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:15AM (#5394267)
Following the reference through from the "clinical trials" section, the Wikipedia article is a little misleading. It makes it sound like only 356/1000 random plants have been studied, but in the paper [1] the breakdown is actually:

15.7% had been tested in clinical trials; 50.9% had been tested in vitro or in vivo; 20.8% had been subject to a phytochemical study; 12.1% had no studies found in the literature search; 0.5% were "dangerous".

That's not saying only 1/3 of plants had been studied. That is saying that 87% of plants have been studied.

[1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1111/j.1365-2710.200...

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:39AM (#5394419)
I was thinking we are talking about all plants in existence, this is a study of 1000 most commonly used herbs, still, I learned something new, so thanks. Still it doesn't prove your more bold claim that somehow all the potential benefits of using them are already available in a very safe to use pill.
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by saalweachter on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:16AM (#5394676)
My overconfidence is mostly coming from the long tail.

Even if there are millions of distinct plant chemistries out there, a small number (say, 100) will account for 90% of the herbal remedies prescribed and taken. These will have been studied by scientific methods exhaustively. The next most common chunk will have received some cursory attention, and then you enter into the vast fields of the unknown.

But the fields aren't unknown to just science: they're unknown to cultural practitioners as well. I'm willing to believe that, even without double-blind clinical trials, people were able to find effective treatments with enough trial and error. But "enough trial and error" means "not the long tail". So once you start talking the 1000th most common plant used for medicinal properties, the amount of experience pre-scientific practitioners have accumulated is negligible, and handful of anecdotes at best. Not even enough to ascribe correlation, let alone causation.

So on the head of plants of potential value, I'm betting that they've all been studied exhaustively. On the tail, there are countless plants which could have countless benefits, but essentially no evidence to do anything but pick one at random and hope it cures what ails you. The middle, of enough evidence to suspect or know a plant does something, but not how, is going to be fairly small.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:26AM (#5394737)
I agree with your reasoning, but you assume that the outcome of the research on a given plant will very quickly lead to a total understanding of its ingredients and effects and that it will always be feasible to develop a technological process to deliver the same complex of ingredients in the form of a pill, neither of which has to be the case.
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by Nursie on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:41AM (#5394844)
For something to be interesting the outcome of research on a given plant should at the very least be that there is an effect to study, or it's not worthwhile. Nobody says "we don't understand how it works, therefore it doesn't work and we should throw it away".
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by Nursie on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:12AM (#5394243)
"the main advantage of plants over modern medicine in its typical form is that they contain complex compounds of chemical substances which show a synergy in a certain direction"

This is such unutterable nonsense.

Take Aspirin vs. Willow Bark.

Aspirin is derived from substances found in willow bark. Aspirin will cure your headache with a known dose of a substance with a well documented harm profile.

Willow bark will cure your headache with a slightly less effective form of the compound, and if used often enough will harm your liver and kidneys because of all the other stuff that's in there.

Plants are not 'designed' to cure you, the 'spirit of the plant' does not lean in one way or other. This is animistic nonsense.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:30AM (#5394363)
You are very aggressive while you clearly do not know what I am talking about and doing a complete straw men. In fact the very same page referenced in this post confirms what I said:

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/scientific-evi...

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by Nursie on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:40AM (#5394424)
Cool, you found one example where the compounds in plant potentiate each other in a useful way. I gave you an example of where this is absolutely not true, and there are likely many more on both sides.

This absolutely does not support the statement "the main advantage of plants over modern medicine in its typical form is that they contain complex compounds of chemical substances which show a synergy in a certain direction ".

In fact it doesn't support that there is an advantage at all, and it shows that by scientifically studying the plant we can figure out the substances responsible for the effect (if it's reproducible), purify them and make use of them in preparations that can be applied more effectively than a poultice.

I'm not sure how you think this is a straw man either.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:49AM (#5394483)
The "spirit of the plant" wasn't a straw man?

What I mean is that _in cases where plants could have advantage over modern medicine_, they often do so because of their complex chemical constitution that can produce those kinds of synergies, where modern medicines are most often based on at most 2-3 active substances because we have trouble analyzing more complex interactions.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by Nursie on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:57AM (#5394541)
No, it was a poke at magical thinking. It may also have been unwarranted snark...

I'll agree that where it can be shown that a plant has an effect that modern medicine can't explain, complex interactions may well be at work. You gave me the impression that you think this is a general rule, where really it seems to be an exception.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by hmsimha on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:22AM (#5394307)
The idea that plants can always be reduced to merely one of their components is an oversimplification. Ask anyone who smokes marijuana why different 'strains' of the plant have different effects, or why Marinol (the pharmaceutical name for THC) is perhaps more dangerous and less helpful or pleasant than the complex cocktail of cannabanoids in their natural delivery[1]. It's also why I'll drink green tea over taking green tea extract any day.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marinol#Marinol

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by saalweachter on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:24AM (#5394720)
I am surprised you think this is a point in your favor. Yes, the primary active ingredient in marijuana is not sufficient. But you just said different strains of marijuana have different effects.

Which strain is most effective for glaucoma? Which strain is most effective for pain management during chemotherapy? Which strain doesn't help with either of those things? The same questions can be asked for any plant.

Medicines extracted from plants may not have the exact same effect as those plants, but they are much more predictable. The dose, the benefit, and the side effects can be studied and known. (And there is no reason to think the effect will be worse or weaker: the extra cocktail of chemicals in the plant could either amplify or dampen the primary active ingredients.)

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by hmsimha on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:59AM (#5394960)
I don't see how it fails to support my argument that by reducing a plant to one or a handful of alkaloids that represent a fraction of the body of the plants chemical makeup, we risk losing out on some of what the plant has to offer. I don't disagree that sometimes, that can be a good thing. However, it's not always; in the case of Marinol "While there has never been a documented human fatality from overdosing on tetrahydrocannabinol or cannabis in its natural form,[86] Marinol can lead to death"

Additionally, the process of isolating and combining the individual components of a plant in order to reproduce observed health benefits of the plant consumed as a whole can be a long and tedious process. Marinol's failure as a good substitute for most people who desire the effects of marijuana is a pretty good example of why, even in this age of science, it is still sometimes better to go back to the source. Green tea extracts, which I also mentioned, frequently consist of Green Tea Catechins, without including, or mentioning whether they contain, L-Theanine, an amino acid in Green tea that has been observed to have nootropic and mood-elevating effects. For someone who wants to reproduce the documented benefits of GTC, by all means go ahead and take the extract. But the benefits of green tea consumed in the traditional way have been enjoyed and observed both in studies over the last few decades, as well as by millions of people over the last thousands of years. Until we've rigorously studied every alkaloid contained in the plant individually, as well as the countless combinations and permutations of those alkaloids (also taking into account the innumerable relative concentrations in which they can be delivered and balanced), it will be hard for science to say whether the components of green tea are present in the most optimal way for X Y Z desired effects

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by OmIsMyShield on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:14AM (#5393888)
I think part of what the author sees as problematic is the loose definition of what "natural" means - to use your herbalism example, some people consider herbs to be automatically better than {mainstream_treatment_x} just because it is "natural", for a random value of "natural".

So you are probably saying the same / a similar thing as the author with slightly different emphasis.

edit: grammar, spelling mistakes, mainstream_treatment_x instead of "better tested"

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:57AM (#5394539)
Thanks for all the downvotes, aggressive trolling, comments on "pixie dust", "spirit of the planet", "poultices" etc., very constructive discussion, very scientific...
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by Nursie on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:48AM (#5394888)
You brought up poultices, or rather you linked to an article about them!
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by papsosouid on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:38AM (#5394411)
>sure natural=better is not a rule true 100% of the time

It isn't even a loose correlation. It is no better than random.

>One example is how it became clear in the last years in nutritional science that in general the more processed the food is the more harmful it is for us.

That has not become clear at all, that is something people like to repeat, but is simply a misinterpretation of the recommendation that people "eat mainly unprocessed foods" to maintain a healthy weight. The recommendation is not due to some magical pixie dust inherent in unprocessed food, it is because processed foods are often very high in calories.

>There is also the reverse problem, illustrated by the condescending attitude toward herbalism in this article, of people who idealize modernity, and for example believe only medicine in the form of pills can be effective, even though plants may contain exactly the same chemical compounds.

Except the article had no such attitude, and said nothing like what you are suggesting it says.

>In general I think it is ridiculous to ignore the thousands of years of experimentation and exploration of our ancestors just because it wasn't "science-based".

It isn't ignored. It is studied, and if it is found to actually be effective, it is used. If it is found not to be effective, it is not used. The quack/fraud "medicine" crowd really need to grow out of lying about this. Scientists do not ignore old herbal remedies, they study them.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by stiff on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:47AM (#5394463)
It isn't even a loose correlation. It is no better than random.

It depends what you mean by natural, I guess. Please read this in context, I am mostly talking about early adopting radical lifestyle changes vs. sticking to the status quo your ancestors followed, and the effects of doing so when employing exclusively one or the other strategy to all the choices.

That has not become clear at all, that is something people like to repeat, but is simply a misinterpretation of the recommendation that people "eat mainly unprocessed foods" to maintain a healthy weight. The recommendation is not due to some magical pixie dust inherent in unprocessed food, it is because processed foods are often very high in calories.

Oh yes, ridicule what I said to make your point, introduce the pixie dust despite me basing most of what I say on at least some evidence, this will make your reply so much more valuable. You are also actually only partially right, it is the amount of calories and the absence of fiber and vitamins and micronutrients (while those are used up during digestation) that makes processed foods unhealthy. I don't see how any of this has to do with what I said.

Except the article had no such attitude, and said nothing like what you are suggesting it says. ... It isn't ignored. It is studied, and if it is found to actually be effective, it is used. If it is found not to be effective, it is not used. The quack/fraud "medicine" crowd really need to grow out of lying about this. Scientists do not ignore old herbal remedies, they study them.

I didn't say any of this, this was a comment on the general attitude of some people.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by ericb on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:55AM (#5394521)
There's a tremendous amount of baggage in the loaded term "natural". But I think there might be a shred of reason to underlying the naturalistic fallacy if you interpret natural to mean "previously present in our evolutionary environment and therefore has previously exhibited evolutionary selective pressure on the development of our immune system and biochemistry."

In other words, novel, isolated chemicals and processes have more opportunity to present our bodies with circumstances their evolution has not "tuned" them for.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by papsosouid on Monday March 18, 2013 @10:59AM (#5394560)
That is a lovely hypothesis, but it has failed to stand up to testing. You go ahead and eat all natural poison ivy salads.
Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by ericb on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:26AM (#5394738)
What I am stating is limited in scope, and your response is as disingenuous as it is snarky.

Your example likely demonstrates selective pressure within species--specifically urushiol in plants as a protective mechanism against herbivores. But you are arguing against the relevance of selective pressure. So you have beat up a straw man in which all things natural are better, but of course, I never argued that.

Do you believe in selective pressure? Do you think digesting cow milk conferred no evolutionary advantage? There ARE studies on the prevalence of the genes for digesting dairy milk, and I think they back me up.

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/11/science/11evolve.html?_r=0

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by papsosouid on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:38AM (#5394819)
>But you are arguing against the relevance of selective pressure.

No, I am arguing against pretending there is a correlation between "natural" and "good" when there is not. Like I very clearly said.

Re:It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo ... by ericb on Monday March 18, 2013 @12:43PM (#5395318)
On a different note. I'm interested in a link to the study where where they studied my hypothesis and disproved it like you say. I've never seen a serious study attempt to disprove this. So, citation please?