News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by Snoptic on Saturday March 16, 2013 @11:58PM (#5388054)
The problem of habeas corpus isn't to protect Al Awalki, it is to prevent the government from torturing Al Avalki for ten years and then saying, oops, we got the wrong guy.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by rayiner on Monday March 18, 2013 @02:16PM (#5396079)
I absolutely agree that if Al Awalki was being detained by the government on American soil, he would have been entitled to file a habeas petition to contest his detention. Absolutely no doubt, and there was an 8-1 Supreme Court decision just this decade, post-9/11, that reaffirmed this principle. Habeas is the bedrock of our civil liberties and we should guard it jealously.

But habeas is a procedure for challenging illegal detention, meanwhile Al Awalki was a fugitive. He was not in the hands of U.S. authorities, on U.S. soil. He took up arms against America in Yemen, and was hiding, evading capture. Habeas is inapplicable to a person who is evading the government's attempts to bring him to justice, in effect evading the government's attempts to give him due process. It is inapplicable by the very nature of the device--a writ from a court to order the release of a prisoner being held by an executive authority within the court's jurisdiction. No U.S. court had jurisdiction over Al Awalki.

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by unclebucknasty on Monday March 18, 2013 @11:03PM (#5398660)
Yes, and the Supreme Court has already, in practice, retreated from a similar ruling it made regarding foreign detainees:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/14/opinion/the-supreme-court-...

The ruling was all talk and no action. It is only a matter of time before it is tested on U.S. citizens.

Then, there's this:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/03/ndaa-obama-indefini...

This is the slow drip of freedom and liberty on the decline. By the time America realizes what happened, it will be too late.

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by unclebucknasty on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:51AM (#5389354)
Yes. This.

These guys always assume the government only takes freedoms from the bad actors, but, that logic is completely circular. The entire point of our system is that the government doesn't get to make that determination unilaterally. When they do, and in particular when the Executive alone does so, it's called a dictatorship.