News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by edw519 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @01:43PM (#5386096)
Every once in a while you read something and shake your head thinking, "I always felt this but was never able to verbalize it like this." This is one such post: one of the best things I've discovered in 6 years of Hacker News.

As someone who has always built and shipped, I've been troubled by a subtle shift in thinking in our industry the last few years. Why so much hostility and failure to learn from others? Why so much attitude?

This brilliant post finally explains it: because so many of us who at one time would have been building products, services, and value are now building anything but: resumes, reputations, portfolios, and (Heaven forbid) "personal brands".

Thank you, Glenn Kelman, for one of the best arguments I've seen in a long time for builders to just shut up, find a customer, and satisfy them.

Just a few gems that really resonated with me:

But one crucial difference between this boom and the last is that the folks in the last boom had to ship or starve.

Amazing what you can do when you have to.

But how many engineers hired from Stanford or Berkeley in the past year will ever feel the savage need to make something happen, to bust out of the matrix, to push the limits of their abilities?

Is "bust out of the matrix" the new "think outside the box"?

The problem is that the young engineers earning that much become well-fed farm animals at the very moment in their lives when they should be running like wild horses.

What a great metaphor!

The result for many engineers and product managers is often a case of arrested development, as they drift from one startup to the next, dabbling in several side-projects, without the ballast of having solved some really hard problems or contributed to a lasting business.

Sometimes, not having an alternative is the best motivator to finish something.

After all, the only way to get much better at your craft is to be challenged in ways that make you uncomfortable. Yet not many people in high technology are uncomfortable these days.

I had no idea.

Startups, like professional football, are best done by the most desperate people on the planet.

Great observation!

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by DanielRibeiro on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:05PM (#5387164)
These are very good points. I believe this also echoes Bret Victor's comment at the end of his famous Inventing on Principle[1, 2]

There are many ways to live your life. That's maybe the most important thing to realize in your life, that every aspect of your life is a choice. There are default choices. You can choose to sleepwalk through your life, and accept the path that is laid out for you. You can choose to accept the world as it is. But you don't have to. If there's something in the world that you feel is a wrong, and you have a vision for what a better world could be, you can find your guiding principle, and you can fight for a cause. So after this talk, I'd like you to take a little time, and think about what matters to you, what you believe in, and what you might fight for.

The Passionate Programmer[3] had a similar point throughout the book. Pg said similar thing years ago on his You Weren't Meant to Have a Boss[4].

[1] http://vimeo.com/36579366

[2] http://gumption.typepad.com/blog/2012/03/principle-centered-...

[3] http://pragprog.com/book/cfcar2/the-passionate-programmer

[4] http://www.paulgraham.com/boss.html

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by tomrod on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:08PM (#5386383)
As someone outside the valley (but a fellow traveler on HN), this attitude of "personal brand" has always confused me. Are the problems being worked on so hard that genius defeats competition? In essence, are the incentives for people in Silicon Valley so misaligned that a person can open numerous unsuccessful companies and still have a positive brand?

When you say for builders to shut up, find a customer, and build--isn't that what was being done before? If so, how could this incentive setup of serial failure being rewarded be avoided?

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by dmiladinov on Saturday March 16, 2013 @02:38PM (#5386279)
The problem is that the young engineers earning that much become well-fed farm animals at the very moment in their lives when they should be running like wild horses.

It's a great metaphor, and I've heard it before - Dave Thomas gave a presentation on Herding Racehorses, Racing Sheep: http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Developing-Expertise-Dave...

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by nnq on Sunday March 17, 2013 @03:36AM (#5388497)
> well-fed farm animals

So you think that just paying a young grad $100k a year (which is a shitload of money by most European standards, but adjusting to your SV environment not that much) will just turn him into a well-fed far animal? will just put off their need to "break outside the matrix"? If you want most of your engineers to be mostly motivated by "hunger", you're doing something very wrong at one level or another!

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by jessedhillon on Sunday March 17, 2013 @03:49PM (#5390697)
$100k is beyond comfortable for everywhere in the Bay Area except SF. You can still spend ~$2700/mo on rent, and have money leftover for fun and savings. Hell, even in SF that will get you a pretty nice life.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by svachalek on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:32PM (#5386460)
I just noticed the football comment and now I'm wondering how bad I just got trolled. (Surely a $2M salary makes you desperate indeed.)
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by kybernetyk on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:50PM (#5386516)
Pro football players have to earn a life's salary in a few years before they get worn out. $2 million over 50+ years isn't really that much.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by ijk on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:14PM (#5387191)
And they often come out of it with long-term injuries that require ongoing, lifelong medical treatment, similar to boxers. Hence all of the recent discussion about concussions, though there are more factors than just that.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by mongol on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:06PM (#5387170)
They have the opportunity to. But they don't have to. They have their whole life to continue to make their living, they don't turn to vegetables without any ability to work.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by derekp7 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @06:18PM (#5387032)
You mean it is impossible for them to work a regular job after retiring from the NFL? Keep in mind that NFL recruits from College, and (if you ignore the cases of cheating the system) most colleges have academic eligibility requirements. Therefore pretty much all pro football players also have a college degree (except the ones that get drafted before graduating -- I don't know what that statistic is).

Heck, if I could have gotten a couple million dollar head start in life by working on my hobby once a week, I'd take that even if I had to delay a regular career by a few years.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by ijk on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:21PM (#5387219)
Except that you'd be betting that you're the exception:

"According to Sports Illustrated, 78% of NFL players are divorced, unemployed, or bankrupt two years after leaving the game, and MSNBC reports that one in four NFL players live paycheck to paycheck" [1].

Most athletes do not invest wisely, and often lack the experience to handle large sums of money [2]. Are you so sure that you'd be the exception?

[1] Slideshow warning: http://www.complex.com/sports/2012/04/six-reasons-why-pro-at...

[2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/don-mcnay/like-lottery-winners...

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by derekp7 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:04PM (#5391043)
I understand the statistics, I was just responding to "they have to earn a lifetimes salary". I was under the assumption that the reason for College sports eligibility requirements was so that athletes can have the ability to support themselves after their sports career is over. In fact, I've often run across people in various professions (such as the guy at the car dealership) who were former professional athletes.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by codesuela on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:04PM (#5387160)
I believe pro football is a full time job hence occupies more than one day a week.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by derekp7 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:01PM (#5391032)
Sorry, that was sort of an inside joke. A guy at work told me a story of how his nephew wanted to be a garbage man when he grew up, since they only have to "work one day a week".
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by RougeFemme on Saturday March 16, 2013 @09:43PM (#5387609)
I don't know the stats but I suspect that most of them don't have degrees. Many exhaust their college eligibility just "a few credits" shy of graduating.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by brianpan on Saturday March 16, 2013 @06:08PM (#5387002)
You make a good point, but football players also have the desperation maker of competition and winning. There are surely players that make it to the NFL and coast, but 1) they have competed to get to the NFL, 2) there are plenty of people willing to take their current jobs, and 3) a Super Bowl win is a big prize that they probably haven't gotten yet and requires some amount of "desperation" to achieve.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by walshemj on Saturday March 16, 2013 @09:13PM (#5387519)
ooh come one the NFL is cosy cartel ask a premiership football (soccer) manager about the pressure they are under.

In the UK the bottom 3 teams are relegated down to the lower division now if the NFC and AFL did that you'd seem some pressure.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by snowwrestler on Saturday March 16, 2013 @11:06PM (#5387911)
Most of the young men who play in the NFL do not come from money. In fact for a lot of them, being the best football player in their high school was their only hope to go to college at all, let alone earn millions of dollars.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:06PM (#5386373)
>>But one crucial difference between this boom and the last is that the folks in the last boom had to ship or starve.

>Amazing what you can do when you have to.

It's not any different this time around. We just haven't reached the starvation period.

But it's very, very close.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by tomrod on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:09PM (#5386386)
> very, very close

Why do you think this? What are the signals you're seeing?

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:35PM (#5386467)
Most returns on VC are negative, almost all are below-market versus standard investments.

EDIT: On the other hand, it's questionable the degree to which the market valuations of regular investments are being pumped up by our capitalism-and-bailouts-induced capital glut.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:34PM (#5386703)
... well, in some sense it's the same thing, isn't it?

Facebook's IPO is either symptom of or driving this whole mess.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:13PM (#5386610)
Here's a bit of nonsense logic for you:

The social craze was clear with Groupon's blunders and Facebook's IPO. That there is a crash coming should have been--and was--clear then.

Ever since then it's only gotten clearer that there's a crash coming, even if those that say "It's soon" were repeatedly proven wrong.

In other words, it is asymptotically becoming "sooner" the more and more it's being proven that "soon" isn't actually that "soon."

(This is, of course, the nature of predicting events that throw up so many signals.)

---

What I mean to say, actually, is that you're asking a pointless question. The signals that indicate "Crash imminent!" have long been fired.

When I say it's "very, very close," did you think I mean it's within a year, or within days?

From a certain way of looking at it, it's at the moment of _least_ certainty how 'soon' an event will occur that the event becomes very, very likely to occur. Because that's when we're the _most_ certain that it's inevitable, but the least certain how it will happen!

---

The answer you probably wanted: Google Reader's collapse makes it devastatingly clear to the tech world that there's a giant gaping opportunity to displace social media. All of it. App.net thinks too small, and the start-up world's programmers--all of them--are sharpening knives.

So... will Wednesday work for you?

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by calinet6 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @06:04PM (#5386990)
> the start-up world's programmers--all of them--are sharpening knives.

This is an astute observation—that is what we're all doing. But we've become so comfortable creating and sharpening knives that no one has dared make the cut. We're sharpening knives, sure, but that's all we're doing.

There are big things out there waiting to be built. An integrated social system that actually works, and fits within people's lives in a natural way that Facebook and twitter simply don't. There's room to bring in all of our connected experiences in the same way a great chef creates a seven course meal. Artfully. Human. I don't personally believe software has seen the magnum opus of which it is capable, yet.

I loved this article because it's so right. We're all so spoiled that we haven't been able to build the Great Wonder of the Internet. We're just making stones in a disorganized fashion. I have this feeling of desperation that I can barely explain, but I think that like most people who can just see a glimmer of the wonders we could be building, I am too comfortable where I am to act on it and create something truly grand.

Sharpening knives, creating better knives, sorting our knives, admiring our collection of knives. Someday they'll be used for the great art that is bound to come, because it's possible, and like countless cultures before us, we feel compelled to complete what we know is possible.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by waterlesscloud on Saturday March 16, 2013 @09:32PM (#5387576)
We're early on yet.

Early on in the internet era, much less the social network era. Everything we've done so far has been just mapping out the territory. The actual building on it is yet to come.

And it's ok if you're too comfortable where you are to build it. Others aren't. They'll get it done.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by whatusername on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:14PM (#5391082)
Actually - there's a decent argument that Wikipedia is the Great Wonder of the Internet.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:02PM (#5387155)
I found this very inspiring.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by tomrod on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:22PM (#5386642)
Would you mind elaborating why you think App.net thinks too small, and where the market disruption is indicated by how Google Reader collapsed?

Understand that I primarily stare at a shell most of the day, so I'm not completely savvy on newer startups. Google Reader shutting down just made me check out newsbeuter sooner rather than later :). App.net just seems like a Twitter competitor with longer strings; what do you see?

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:33PM (#5386699)
Facebook in flames.

Google Reader's demise is really strong proof that Larry Page is obsessed with Google Plus to the point of depravity. There are alternatives, but that doesn't distract from the point: _Google_, one of the bright centers of the Internet, is behaving with abject incompetence.

Google just made a huge mistake. It made that mistake because of a huger mistake in trying to compete with Facebook.

People don't like Facebook. The technically illiterate might allow it into their lives, but they have no loyalty to it.

However, Facebook is the center of mass for people's online selves. App.net _is_ just a Twitter competitor with longer strings.

And in a certain sense it only makes sense that the center of this social media nonsense gets shut down.

There'll be a new Facebook soon. Hopefully a better one.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by calinet6 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @06:06PM (#5386994)
Facebook is like a sand castle compared to the great pyramid to come. We need to start building that.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by tomrod on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:11PM (#5387181)
How can I help?
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by calinet6 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @10:27PM (#5387759)
I'm not sure. I need probably about a year to think, and about a dozen people to think with. And then maybe something might be possible.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by hello_newman on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:16PM (#5387201)
I agree with there being a new Facebook. If you look at Internet companies, after about the 7-8 year mark, they either rebuild, rebrand, and get better...or someone else comes along and makes a better mouse trap.

Although I use Facebook extensively, I do see where someone could come in and make a better one. The only thing is we have never seen something with the tentacles that Facebook & twitter have. Go to almost any page on the Internet and I can guarantee you'll see a "share" button. Did MySpace have that? I mean 1 out of every 12 people on the planet uses Facebook.

I am not tying to pessimistic, and I hope someone will take them off their high horse, but how will a service displace something that has over 1 billion active users? Maybe that just adds to the point that it is past their prime. Humans like the latest, greatest, shiniest this and that...so maybe everyone is ready to move on.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by RougeFemme on Saturday March 16, 2013 @09:46PM (#5387623)
Hopefully multiple services will displace Facebook. Facebook's 1 billion+ users use Facebook in so many different ways. I don't want to share a service with the "friends" who simply want to send me game invitations, show me the dinner they just cooked. . .or fight in public.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by strandev on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:53PM (#5386756)
So what are you doing about it?
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by Helianthus on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:54PM (#5386759)
Oh, you know. Writing HN comments.