News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by rayiner on Friday March 15, 2013 @08:01PM (#5383743)
Obama has been more or less the right-center President he was as a candidate. People who are surprised by this wishfully read too much into his rhetoric.

E.g. Obama has continued interventions in Pakistan, etc, even though some people pinned their hopes on him as an "anti-war" candidate. But he was never "anti-war." He was "anti-Iraq war." He ran on a platform of "Bush took us into Iraq instead of hitting the terrorists harder in Afghanistan." So why should anyone be surprised he took troops out of Iraq and put more in Afghanistan?

E.g. re: drone strikes, is it really any worse than the cruise missiles Clinton was fond of using?

"Civil liberties" in the abstract sense, are not a core issue to Obama's base in the same way that say abortion rights are. During Bush, Democrats opposed expansions such as military tribunals in Guantanamo, etc, but things like NSL's have been around since the 1970's. I don't think the bulk of Obama's base have a problem with the status quo circa 1995, or ever did, regardless of what adherent civil libertarians might have hoped.

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by neilk on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:50AM (#5384820)
Obama campaigned on closing Guantanamo[1], restoring habeas corpus for "enemy combatants"[2], abolishing military commissions for detainees[3], etc.

Moreover, as an Illinois state Senator, one of Obama's signature accomplishments was a reform in how prisoners were interrogated.[4]

Obama made less specific pledges about reducing the state secrets privileges. You can check out how surprised some judges were when, one month into his presidency, the Obama administration continued the Bush-era position that extraordinary rendition was too sensitive to even discuss in court.[5]

We can argue about how much his promises mattered to his getting elected. And I agree that his rhetoric interpreted wishfully by his supporters. But even with all that, there's no question there's been a real about-face once he took office.

[1] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/obameter/pr...

[2] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/obameter/pr...

[3] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/obameter/pr...

[4] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/01...

[5] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/10/us/10torture.html?_r=2&...;

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by rayiner on Saturday March 16, 2013 @12:27PM (#5385861)
He tried to close guantanamo and try detainees in EDVa. People in Virginia freaked. Gitmo detainees are getting habeas hearings.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by D9u on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:05AM (#5384828)
re: drone strikes, is it really any worse than the cruise missiles Clinton was fond of using?

Clinton wasn't targeting Americans.

If due process can be denied to any American, then our "Moral High Ground" has been forfeit. Even child molesters, and foreign spies, are afforded a trial. Terrorists should also face a trial, as well as punishment when convicted.

As for the right-center President, there is very little difference between the actions of Democrat and Republican presidents. It's like the difference between CocaCola and Pepsi when all we want is water.

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by jacquesm on Saturday March 16, 2013 @07:04AM (#5385067)
> If due process can be denied to any American, then our "Moral High Ground" has been forfeit.

If due process can be denied to anybody, then our "Moral High Ground" has been forfeit.

Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by SEMW on Saturday March 16, 2013 @08:00AM (#5385170)
Exactly right. A moral high ground built on an axiom of 'our citizens are now deserving of human rights than anyone else's' is more of a moral tar pit than a high ground.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by Snoptic on Sunday March 17, 2013 @12:01AM (#5388068)
If foreigners can't submit to our responsibilities, then they can't have our rights. The US doesn't rule the whole world, and the world doesn't want US to. Therefore, conflicts will arise, and there is no fair play among warring nations.
Re:Federal Judge Finds National Security Letters Unconstitut... by SEMW on Sunday March 17, 2013 @02:01PM (#5390222)
> there is no fair play among warring nations.

This might be a fair point if the US government was only claiming that the (supposedly inalienable) human rights which it respects in its own citizens are only suspended as against citizens of countries the US is in a state of war with.

But it doesn't. It claims that they don't apply to any non-Americans (outside US borders, at least - non-US citizens inside US borders do have some protections, IIRC). And the US courts seem to agree (e.g. US v. Verdugo-Urquidez)

The US is not at war with the entire rest of the world.

> If foreigners can't submit to our responsibilities, then they can't have our rights.

The original assertion was about what is moral. To make sure I understand you correctly - you're claiming that because I don't have responsibilities to the US government (I don't pay US taxes etc. being not a US citizen), it's not immoral for the US government to act in a way that, if I was a US citizen, would be an actionable breach of my fundamental rights?