News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by jcampbell1 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:45PM (#5376069)
This seems completely sound. Is it implicitly understood that all investors get the same terms? I assume that if there is an agreement to invest $100k at $5M cap, then the startup can't go take another $100k at a $4M cap, without giving that same deal to the first investor.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by pg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:51PM (#5376103)
There are cases where that would make sense, e.g. if the second investor was some famous domain expert. That said, it doesn't happen often.

The more common case is where the cap rises for later investors. Later investors gripe about that when it happens, but it's justifiable. The earlier investors took more risk. Plus the company actually is more valuable on account of their investment; a company that has raised $1m is at least $1m more valuable than when they started raising money.

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by samiur1204 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:56PM (#5376946)
There is also a case to be made that even though initial investors took the risk to get a lower cap, they benefit from later investments even if they get a lower cap since the company becomes more valuable, making it more likely that they will actually profit more. While I agree that it's not ideal to have to allow later investors at lower caps, it could still be beneficial to earlier investors for the startup to accept these later investments. I don't think the moral burden should rest on the startup to go back to the earlier investors and offer a revised deal. Not only is it inefficient, but it also gives earlier investors the advantage when it comes to a hot startup that everyone wants to investment in initially. They can just bid with a high cap, guaranteeing that their offer is accepted, expecting the startup to come back because of it's "moral obligation" later on when other investors offer them lower caps.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by jcampbell1 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:01PM (#5376187)
In my scenario, where the second investor isn't a domain expert, but says something like "I will say yes to $xxx at a a lower cap", then does the startup have a moral obligation to give the same deal to the first investor? I think so, but could be convinced otherwise. Maybe this never happens.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by pg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:11PM (#5376251)
It happens. There are investors who are notorious for offering lower caps to startups that have already started raising money. The solution is essentially to route around them. We advise startups to approach such investors last, when they've already raised enough that they feel comfortable saying "take it or leave it."

(There was a big kerfuffle a while ago when an email of this type got leaked.)

There's another case, though, when the startup has initially raised money at a higher cap than the market will bear. We warn founders about this, but they don't always listen. In that case they give the earlier investors the same lower cap that they negotiate with later investors.

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by wbl on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:35PM (#5376806)
This seems very inefficient for the startup. They have people willing to offer more money for less shares, so why not go down the list until they have enough money? Or are there second-order effects I am not seeing here.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by Jplenbrook on Friday March 15, 2013 @05:06AM (#5379739)
It may not necessarily be inefficient. YC has an established brand. Initial YC investors know they will get the best possible terms, so they would be wise to offer the max value. The start-up it could take this "max" valuation to all future investors.

The alternative would be a low initial offer which would essentially keep anyone else from paying more. In essence the YC start-ups are giving the initial investor a money back guarantee on the difference between their offer and the lowest offer.

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by cbhl on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:43PM (#5376493)
Are you suggesting that said moral obligation should be a part of the protocol?

I feel like it would make more sense for someone in that scenario to get advice for their specific situation, rather than spelling it out in the protocol.

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by pc86 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:18PM (#5376299)
Can someone define cap for me in this context?
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by lincolnq on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:42PM (#5376486)
Convertible debt is the trendy way to finance seed-stage startups these days. It allows early investors to essentially "punt" on determining the true valuation of the company at an early stage, while still ensuring that they get a decent deal when a valuation does get determined.

The way it works: instead of negotiating over true valuation early on, the seed investor hands over the cash as a debt instrument (so the startup technically owes the investor the money they paid), under the agreement that if the startup later raises a "real" (venture) investment round, the debt converts to equity at the price of the later round.

Of course, to avoid screwing the seed investors over, they typically insist on a "valuation cap" -- maximum valuation -- (so if you later raise venture at $10mm, but the cap was $5mm, the seed investors get twice as much equity as the venture investors per dollar paid). But if the venture investors only pay for a $5mm valuation, then they get the same equity-per-dollar as the seed investors.

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by pc86 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:13PM (#5376675)
This is exactly what I wanted to know, thank you!
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by jcampbell1 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:25PM (#5376363)
This seems like a reasonably good explanation:

http://www.askthevc.com/wp/archives/2011/09/convertible-debt...

Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by samstave on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:23PM (#5376337)
Valuation.
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by kcmarshall on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:26PM (#5376374)
Think "Market Capitalization" not "top" or "limit"
Re:The Handshake Deal Protocol by cwp on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:39PM (#5376470)
No, "limit" is the correct interpretation. For a convertible debt investment, it's the maximum valuation by which the debt can be converted to equity. (And therefor a minimum percentage of the company that the investor will receive.)