He's not written a scientific paper - don't assume that every single word he has written is meant to be interpreted in the strictest way possible.
By all means be sceptical, but while he might very well be wrong, at least he appears to be earnestly looking to identify and correct any flaws which already puts him far above a lot of charlatans selling risky diets.
It's all produced by self replicating lifeforms we've only begun to comprehend, right?
There's no reason to think we can't science out what that input needs to be, or at least to be able to find one or more valid subsets of input.
This is a rather large improvement over what most people do; one typically applies little to no science whatsoever. :-P
I'm getting the idea that people profess a "belief in science" in the general case, but then absolutely deny its applicability in the specific case here. ;-)