News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by shardling on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @01:43PM (#5369891)
It is exactly the job of the state, because the ignorant do not know how to protect themselves, or even that they are ignorant.

I dare say that every day you are protected by the state from those who would take advantage of your ignorance in many, many aspects of the world. The system works well enough that you don't even notice what you're ignorant of!

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by the_watcher on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @01:59PM (#5369984)
By this logic, ignorance should then be accepted as a defense to illegal activity, especially in today's world where, increasingly, everyday activity is a crime.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by rplacd on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:43PM (#5370263)
To be fair, he's never said anything about abstract defense or justification - rather, he's talking about government dealing with the consequences.

Edit: so I suppose the distinction's that that the first implies self-contradiction, and the other doesn't. Or perhaps the line is drawn when policy like that interferes with official judgment. Who knows.

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by the_watcher on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:00PM (#5369992)
This is also a disturbingly paternalist view of the role of the state, to me.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by shardling on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:54PM (#5370341)
That's hardly an argument -- it's barely rising above just calling the state names.

The exact role of the state in protecting it's citizens requires nuanced debate. Saying "it's not the state's job" doesn't cut it.

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by jessaustin on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @04:12PM (#5370827)
Let's be fair. the_watcher posts a comment of fifteen words. It's too much to expect "nuanced debate" in a single sentence. I take it you were unconvinced by that sentence; do you believe your three sentences are much more persuasive? Can you imagine a viewpoint that approves most state-provided security services, yet still rejects the actions of the Attorneys General in this case?

Perhaps you're upset by the language? "Paternalist", to my eye, is a descriptive term that closely matches the circumstances under discussion. If you find that adjective has unfortunate connotations, by all means suggest another that has approximately the same definition.

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by nulagrithom on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:19PM (#5370113)
This is how we end up with bans on soft drinks larger than 16 ounces.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by harshreality on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:35PM (#5370212)
Sorry, but I think Bloomberg is on the correct side of that issue, even if he won't win in court. It's becoming increasingly clear that large quantities of sugar are a long-term poison. Since there's no practical use for soft drinks other than "They taste good" (which is a personal-happiness argument, but a particularly juvenile and narrow-minded one), large softdrinks should be banned. If arsenic salts tasted really good, and they were not already banned, would you oppose efforts to get restaurants to stop serving that?

Just because a paternalistic state is usually bad doesn't mean that government shouldn't intervene in anything.

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by natrius on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:02AM (#5373326)
Mandated warning labels would be a better idea. Banning things is rarely necessary to achieve policy goals.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by nulagrithom on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @04:54PM (#5371049)
Ethanol is poison as well.
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by crististm on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @03:22PM (#5370523)
and on incandescent lamps...
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by JagMicker on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:00PM (#5369996)
So, by that logic, the "state" is obligated to provide security to homeowners who can not be bothered to lock their homes?
Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by ncallaway on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @02:13PM (#5370088)
The state is generally obligated to provide security to homeowners who can not be bothered to lock their homes.

If someone enters your house without your permission and refuses to leave you may call the police. If there are any immediate threats to person or property the police response will usually be swift (though, of course, this depends on your local P.D.).

Re:Google Ordered To Teach America How To Put Passwords On W... by jessaustin on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @04:15PM (#5370847)
You have a security problem. You call the police. Now you have two security problems.

I'll stipulate that this isn't what we were taught in junior high civics, but it is the experience of many communities in the USA that security problems are best handled without the intervention of police.