News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Interview with the man who built Google's V8 engine from ... by larrykubin on Saturday March 28, 2009 @02:55PM (#536641)
I'd say both.
Re:Interview with the man who built Google's V8 engine from ... by ankhmoop on Saturday March 28, 2009 @06:38PM (#536861)
I haven't seen any evidence that DHH is a genius programmer, especially when his work is compared to that of someone like Lars Bak. Do you have a particular work of DHH's in mind as demonstrative of truly exceptional intellect and programming ability?

I reviewed Rail's ORM implementation extensively when researching the field, and I found DHH's implementation to be remarkably naive, with most advances provided by third party developers, and absolutely no demonstrative knowledge (theoretical or otherwise) of the underlying relational algebra, security concerns, etc.

A very simple example of implementation naivety: As of 2004, ActiveRecord implementation failed to even use parametrized SQL statements and was open to a variety of SQL injection attacks:

http://article.gmane.org/gmane.comp.lang.ruby.rails/623

http://article.gmane.org/gmane.comp.lang.ruby.rails/749

In my reviews of DHH's work, I've not found code that I would consider 'genius', but note that this is not an argument that his work is without value.

Re:Interview with the man who built Google's V8 engine from ... by hello_moto on Sunday March 29, 2009 @12:25AM (#537104)
He simplifies web-development.

Can you say the same thing in regards to the developers that work for the following companies?

SUN (Java), Microsoft (ASP/ASP.NET), Macromedia (ColdFusion).

(and don't forget developers who use PHP, Perl and Python).

Yes, he's sloppy/have no knowledge in certain areas... and I assume that's where people like you, ankhmoop, come into play and contribute. Just like Lars Bak with his soldiers.

Re:Interview with the man who built Google's V8 engine from ... by ankhmoop on Sunday March 29, 2009 @12:41AM (#537112)
You don't need to be a genius to produce value.

In my early 20s, I wrote a piece of widely popular software that's still in very active use today. I didn't solve the problem well, and I wouldn't call the implementation genius by any stretch of the imagination, but I made something useful and quite a few people use it every day -- probably more than use Rails, but I must admit I'm guessing.

For all the value I've produced, I'm still embarrassed by the software, and all the more so when I see other developers emulating my design and approaches that I've since learned to be sub-optimal. The work wasn't genius, but yes, it simplified something important.

The lesson I take away is this: value doesn't require genius, and it's foolish to conflate the two. I try to appreciate the value produced by others without making assumptions regarding their genius.