News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by dualogy on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:34AM (#5355229)
> Hunters and gatherers weren't obese. We are. By irrefutable inference, some lifestyle difference explains this

Yeah and that difference is the sheer abundance of cheap calories. People can and did get fat when eating too many calories of Paleo (easily possible if you overemphasize the fatty meats and sweeter fruits), people can and did lean out on breads and junk-food by simply consuming fewer calories than they expended over a prolonged period.

I have no axe to grind here, I'd say I myself eat 99% Paleo 99% of the time, save for the occasional brownie. Otherwise it's meats, vegs, fruits for me. But that's just my personal taste, and for body-fat storage or lack of it, consuming in excess of your energy expenditure surely must account for most of the most of it.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by olefoo on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:04AM (#5355278)
It's not even the Paleolithic that had a 'better' diet; sugar production in industrial quantities didn't happen until the 19th century and High Fructose Corn Syrup [1] didn't become a staple of the human diet until the second half of the 20th century.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_fructose_corn_syrup

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by riffraff on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:40AM (#5355382)
> High Fructose Corn Syrup [1] didn't become a staple of the human die until

AFAICT HFCS didn't become a staple of human diet, it just became important in the US, the rest of the world still uses _way_ more sugar than HFCS (e.g. a 60:1 rate of production in the EU).

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by olefoo on Monday March 11, 2013 @05:03AM (#5355606)
Well. I am an American and we are the world, right....?

// I jest. But if your colas are still made from sugar you are having the last laugh.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by conradfr on Monday March 11, 2013 @06:35AM (#5355877)
Are colas supposed to be a staple of the human diet ? :)
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by edu on Monday March 11, 2013 @06:22AM (#5355844)
Yes, here colas are still made of sugar :) Even though... better to drink just water!
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by s_baby on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:11AM (#5355295)
Not really. There's a pretty clear connection between insulin levels and weight gain. Spiking your insulin levels by eating carbohydrates will effect how calories are used for many if not all people.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by dualogy on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:20AM (#5355319)
I'm not denying that there certainly are such factors at play at some level, but not sure how decisive they are: I'd wager they won't make a dent if you consume 4500 calories of Paleo a day, and likewise won't if you consume 1200 calories of junk-food a day -- say for the average non-athlete rather-sedentary adult.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by s_baby on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:31AM (#5355351)
There's a reason Atkin's diet is so popular. It's because it's extremely effective at shedding weight. Sure there might be a point at which you're gaining weight due to the fact that it's an astronomical amount of calories and there are going to be differences in biology but over-all people find eliminating carbs will cut the weight even if they don't cut calories.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by dalke on Monday March 11, 2013 @07:03AM (#5355957)
Lots of things are popular. However, I thought the rough consensus was more like what's outlined in (pulling up a recent relevant paper) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2949959/

"Successful weight loss can be achieved with either a low-fat or low-carbohydrate diet when coupled with behavioral treatment. A low-carbohydrate diet is associated with favorable changes in cardiovascular disease risk factors at 2 years."

"Data from several randomized trials over the past 6 years have demonstrated that low-carbohydrate diets produced greater short-term (6 months) weight loss than low-fat, calorie-restricted diets (1-5). The longer-term (1 to 2 years) results are mixed."

"Implication: Overweight persons can achieve substantial weight loss at 2 years if they participate in a behavioral intervention combined with a low-fat or a low-carbohydrate diet."

Also, attrition rates were about the same between the two.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Monday March 11, 2013 @05:08AM (#5355621)
The same argument could be, and often is used, to prove the existence of god.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by dlytle on Monday March 11, 2013 @04:21AM (#5355490)
One of the primary arguments of a keto/paleo diet is that the different diets affect how many calories your body thinks it needs, how it uses them, and how it influences behavior as a result. (Disclaimer: using imaginary numbers below to illustrate the theory.)

Let's say your body typically wants 1000 calories at breakfast, and you eat 1000 calories with a heavy load of carbs. Carbohydrates with a high glycemic index cause your insulin to spike. That signals fat cells that they should start storing energy, and they do so, tucking away 300 of the 1000 calories you ate.

This means your body only gets to spend 700 of the 1000 calories you ate, and as such, it says "hey, I'm still hungry". You eat 300 calories worth of food. But your fat cells are still sucking up (X%) of what you eat into storage, due to the insulin reaction. So, your body gets 200 of those 300 it wants, and it stays a little bit hungry. (Or, more likely, your body wants 300, but you eat 500 to make it shut up.)

Carbs have the unfortunate habit of converting useful calories into fat storage prior to processing them for the purposes of nutrition. This means carb-heavy diets tend to cause unconscious overeating, and also constant feelings of hunger/cravings/etc.

One of the advantages of a paleo/keto diet is that they often avoid the type of carbohydrates that cause this problem, namely ones with a high glycemic index. This means when you eat 1000 calories, your fat cells don't skim any off the top before your metabolism gets to them, and you get the full 1000; this means you don't end up hungry after a meal, and don't suffer from the urge to snack/eat more. Because your body got all the energy it wanted, it doesn't start saying it's hungry again until it actually does need the nutrition, and you're more likely to eat closer to the correct amount for your body's needs.

The difference between the examples you give, 4500 of Paleo and 1200 of junk food, is primarily how they'd make your body react. 1200 of junk food would certainly be a caloric deficit, but you'd be ravenously hungry at that level. (I've done 1000 calories a day for 6 months straight - it's pretty awful for the first few months.) But with keto, you could eat 4500 calories in a day, but you won't want to. When I'm done eating a keto-style meal, I am completely uninterested in food until the next. Those meals, for me, are typically 1-2 small/medium brats with no bun. But if I go out and cheat, and grab a burger and fries, I've got to fight the urge to follow it up with some ice cream, even though the fries and burger combined are drastically more calories than the brats I was satisfied with the meal before.

It's really interesting stuff. The "calories-in, calories-out" model is completely right from a completely energy-based perspective, but it doesn't account for the side effects produced by the energy source, and how people react to them.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Monday March 11, 2013 @05:07AM (#5355617)
This is pseudo science, there are droves of scientific literature that shows that meal timing is irrelevant and that as long as macronutrient content is similar, a calorie is a calorie.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by sgift on Monday March 11, 2013 @06:01AM (#5355776)
And there are droves of scientific literature that show that meal timing is important and even if macronutrient content is similar, a calorie is not a calorie.

The simple fact is: No one was able to prove anything beyond shallow platitudes ("If you eat three tons of flesh each day you will get fat too!" "If you eat nothing for month you will get lean!").

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by dalke on Monday March 11, 2013 @06:40AM (#5355891)
A quick search of PubMed finds some recent (within the last year) papers like:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23357955 - "Timing of food intake predicts weight loss effectiveness" It starts "Background: There is emerging literature demonstrating a relationship between the timing of feeding and weight regulation in animals. However, whether the timing of food intake influences the success of a weight-loss diet in humans is unknown."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23167985 - "Effects of exercise before or after meal ingestion on fat balance and postprandial metabolism in overweight men."; "It is unclear how timing of exercise relative to meal ingestion influences substrate balance and metabolic responses."

These make me think that there isn't "droves of scientific literature" which show the importance of meal timing in humans, much less characterize the magnitude of the importance. (Eg, if there's a measurable 1% difference in overall effect on weight then it's statistically significant finding, but almost certainly not enough for most people to care about.)

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by anthonyb on Monday March 11, 2013 @07:06AM (#5355969)
Where is the parent saying anything about meal timing? It's about the effect on your body of a particular meal. Carbs and sugars spike insulin much more than fats or protein.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Monday March 11, 2013 @07:35AM (#5356053)
That is an issue of meal timing. Individual meals doesn't matter. Transient insulin spikes are irrelevant, what matters is your overall expenditure vs intake.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by anthonyb on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:15PM (#5359867)
Insulin spikes are completely relevant, since insulin signals your fat cells to take up energy from your blood stream. Now you have no energy and feel hungry again.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @05:11AM (#5360900)
It doesn't work that way. Show me a study that concludes that blood glucose levels have not been meaningfully increased after a meal due to it all going straight to adipose tissue -- in humans -- and I'll show you the next Nobel Prize winner.

Insulin spikes are irrelevant in so far as you will lose weight at a calorie deficit, insulin spikes or not. Also, fat can be synthesized in the absence of insulin spikes. http://www.jlr.org/content/30/11/1727

Physiologically, what matters is a caloric deficit. Execution wise, some foods make this easier than others, but that is highly individual.

"Reduced-calorie diets result in clinically meaningful weight loss regardless of which macronutrients they emphasize" http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa0804748

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by anthonyb on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @07:15PM (#5365657)
Yes it does work that way.

Steady levels of insulin make it much easier to maintain a caloric deficit. If your blood sugar is yo-yoing all over the place, you're going to get cravings, increase your risk of bingeing, etc.

While it's easy to fall back on 'calories in, calories out', weight loss has much more to do with psychology, physiology and compliance than physics.

edit: Here's a nice review article from Nature, which tells you all you need to know: http://141.213.232.243/bitstream/2027.42/62568/1/414799a.pdf

It starts:

  Despite periods of feeding and fasting, plasma
  glucose remains in a narrow range between 4
  and 7 mM in normal individuals.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @03:22AM (#5367265)
You're absolutely right that losing weight has a lot to do with psychology, and that the execution of it depends on finding a method, a diet tailored to the individual's needs, to succeed.

But that diet will only result in weight loss if there is a caloric deficit, completely independent of insulin spikes. Now, the trick to achieving and maintaining that caloric deficit over a period of time is an effort that is psychologically demanding, absolutely. But the weight loss itself is pure thermodynamics.

If your interest lies in designing diets or meal plans that help people achieve their weight loss goals, your focus should rightly be the psychological aspect of it. That's the battle. But at the end of the day, a caloric deficit is necessary, whether you choose to ignore that or not.

IMHO, diet and nutrition is confusing as hell to the average person, and hiding the necessity of a caloric deficit and instead talking about "good" and "bad" foods or macronutrients, is a poor approach in the long run. But that's just my opinion. The necessity of a caloric deficit is not opinion though, it's cold hard scientifically proven fact.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by anthonyb on Wednesday March 13, 2013 @08:31PM (#5372277)
> The necessity of a caloric deficit is not opinion though, it's cold hard scientifically proven fact.

It is not that simple. If you have a calorie deficit but aren't getting enough nutrients you will get cravings but won't be able to sustain your diet. If you're addicted to sugar you will get cravings/constant hunger and won't be able to sustain your diet.

Focusing on calories ignores all of the other things (nutrients, insulin, blood sugar, motivation) that need to happen for a diet to be successful.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by tjogin on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:38AM (#5373632)
> It is not that simple. If you have a calorie deficit but aren't getting enough nutrients you will get cravings but won't be able to sustain your diet.

That makes no sense. In that case, you aren't on a caloric deficit. If you aren't able to achieve a caloric deficit, then you are not on a caloric deficit.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by s_baby on Monday March 11, 2013 @09:19AM (#5356469)
Don't feed the trolls.
Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by maxerickson on Monday March 11, 2013 @09:00AM (#5356373)
There's a pretty good chance this is an over-analysis.

A daily 50 Calorie excess stacked up over 5 years amounts to a gain of about 25 pounds.

So it is certainly possible that a diet could be subtly tipping metabolism in the wrong direction, but between a complex explanation of more calories being stored as fat and a simple explanation of slightly too much consumption, I like the second one.

I guess that it is easy to consume large amounts of carbs makes them a frequent component of weight gain.

Re:“Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions by hmbg on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:26AM (#5355335)
Without having done much research I also find it easy to imagine that the sedentariness of the paleo-people where, on average, a lot less than of people nowadays.