News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by mtgx on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:01AM (#5351546)
The only reasonable apology is to end the always-on connection DRM, and update the game to work without it. Anything less than that I see an insult to their customers.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by georgespencer on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:10AM (#5351572)
This isn't to do with the always-on DRM. EA drastically underestimated the number of players who would want to play the game, and they don't have sufficient server capacity. (This has happened in the past at peak times with games like World of Warcraft, EVE, etc.)

A proportional response would be to allow users to refund the game, since this is a quality issue and is clearly out of the players' control; and to rapidly expand their server capacity until they have enough for everyone.

(I'm not an advocate for DRM, just proportionality.)

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by kaonashi on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:40AM (#5351641)
Of course it's to do with it. If it had a traditional single-player architecture, there would be no issues at all.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by georgespencer on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:32AM (#5351803)
You're failing to draw a distinction between always-on DRM and multiplayer server capacity. Look at what you just said:

> Of course it's to do with [DRM]. If it [was a single player game], there would be no issues at all.

The two are unrelated. If it was a single player game we wouldn't be having these issues... because it wouldn't need server capacity to play, which is nothing to do with DRM. It could still have always-on DRM.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by alberich on Sunday March 10, 2013 @11:00AM (#5352155)
> If it was a single player game we wouldn't be having these issues... because it wouldn't need server capacity to play, which is nothing to do with DRM. It could still have always-on DRM.

Well, if the players still had to be connected to the servers (always-on) to play, maybe the same problems would arise even though the players wouldn't be interacting.

The strange aspect of this is that their infrastructure seems to be static. In this modern age of cloud computing, why not make the number of game servers elastic? That would bring safety to them and savings by reducing the number of idling servers when demand is low.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by efdee on Sunday March 10, 2013 @10:05AM (#5351952)
Fact is that DRM is the real reason why the game is heavily multiplayer. Older versions were always single player and there is no reason they couldn't at least have implemented this mode in the new game other than having an excuse to put some of the logic on a server to thwart piracy. And that is what is causing the current problems.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by shadowfox on Sunday March 10, 2013 @10:45AM (#5352093)
> Fact is that DRM is the real reason why the game is heavily multiplayer

Perhaps. I had be interested in your sources for this fact though. Otherwise it feels like opinion being stated as fact.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by blaabjerg on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:56AM (#5351916)
Could you play single player games while they were having server issues?
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by baak on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:16AM (#5351739)
Are you suggesting it has to do with the technical implications of always-on DRM or the ethical considerations?
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by fennecfoxen on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:36AM (#5351820)
"(This has happened in the past at peak times with games like World of Warcraft, EVE, etc.)"

More saliently, it happened with the launch of Cities XL... which did more or less exactly the same things in the cloud that this new SimCity is trying to do.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by hawleyal on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:37AM (#5351828)
This is not an online game like WOW or EVE.

It's DRM.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by georgespencer on Sunday March 10, 2013 @10:18AM (#5352008)
You can repeat this until you're blue in the face, but it simply isn't true.

The game is intended to be played online. You share resources with neighbouring cities. Crime spills over into your city from others. You can work together on collaborative projects (international airports etc.). It's not MMO but it's not single player either.

I believe in some early interviews Maxis also referred to some computational work being offloaded to EA servers but I can't find these now. They might not have gone through with it, but it was certainly in the original plan.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by GhotiFish on Sunday March 10, 2013 @10:30AM (#5352047)
sim city 4 had exactly the same mechanics in single player.

There really is nothing to say in their defense, even if they DID design the game to be multiplayer, they could of done it in a decentralized way and let peers inter-connect. They did it this way for control. Do not defend them.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by philo23 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:08AM (#5351562)
They've also said this is never going to happen. The game was designed from the start to be always online. Also apparently most of the simulation happens on their servers rather than your computer which is why it's also never going to happen.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by VexXtreme on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:31AM (#5351617)
This is so wrong it's ridiculous. I don't know who keeps perpetuating these false claims about a part of the simulation being done server side.

ALL simulation is done on the client, EXCEPT for interactions with neighboring cities when they are run by human players. But in the single player mode even that is not an issue. The only thing the servers are needed for is persisting (saving) game state and that's the end of it. People have been able to play the game without internet connection for hours on end before their game crashed, clearly proving that the game DOES NOT rely on the cloud for simulation.

Besides, an average gaming computer with Core i5 and 4 gigs of RAM is far more powerful than some virtualized EC2 instance with limited and shared CPU/memory. Offloading computation/simulation to the cloud for "performance reasons" is a ridiculous notion.

This is about DRM and everyone knows it.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by mcintyre1994 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:47AM (#5351657)
I'm not disagreeing, it seems you should be right, but I'm wondering why they would have reduced the fastest game speed if there was no simulation on the server? That doesn't really make sense if all they're doing is saving the game on the server. I guess they might save more often on a faster speed, but why not just slow saves in that case? Why remove the fastest speed if there's no simulation?

Other than that though, your explanation makes the most sense.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by zanny on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:20AM (#5351756)
> why they would have reduced the fastest game speed if there was no simulation on the server?

Saved games and inter-city communication is done against the game clock, not the wall clock, so they could reduce server load (on the only two things servers were doing, saving games and providing intercity communication when multiple people were on in the same region) by disabling the fastest speed of game time.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by mcintyre1994 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:48PM (#5352709)
Fair enough. Sounds like that fast mode was essentially DDOSing them then, I'd be interested to know whether they have a plan to put it back.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by crististm on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:44AM (#5351653)
"People played [...] for hours on end before their game crashed" - aaa, what?

And you conclude from that that the game does not need the servers (explicit DRM or not)?

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by lucian1900 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:12AM (#5351722)
It would support the idea that their servers are only used occasionally, probably for saving.
Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by crististm on Sunday March 10, 2013 @04:24PM (#5353304)
Yes, totally clear. Except that when the server is not available your game crashes. How is that any different from the game depending entirely on the servers being ON?

The game depends on the servers, either for DRM or for game saves. But when they are off-line, it doesn't matter the true reason for game crash.

The fact is - the game needs the servers being ON.

Re:EA Apologizes For SimCity Disaster, Says It Was “Dumb”.. by Gigablah on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:16AM (#5351589)
Considering that many players have reported being able to continue their games for ~30 minutes while disconnected, it's safe to say that the portion of the simulation that's offloaded to their servers is miniscule at best.