If you think Elon Musk is 100% correct that the reporter was a liar, or that the reporter was 100% in the right for publishing a big picture of a Tesla Model S being towed, you're going to be disappointed.
Both sides are upset, extremely opinionated, and have their own slant on the matter. Both sides made mistakes, and probably could have held back on a few things they claimed.
Elon Musk should have focused just on the obvious faults of the reporter -- like how the reporter probably should have more clearly highlighted that he literally began a trip for X miles with Y miles range displayed on the dash, where X > Y by a considerable amount (rather than burying this fact in noise). Not little details like air conditioning and driving in circles to find the supercharger.
And similarly, although there's disagreement over what certain Tesla reps may have recommended over the phone, it seems at last slightly disingenuous to post a big photo of a Tesla Model S being towed given the fact that he started and forced a trip of length X when the car showed range Y on the screen, where X > Y by a considerable amount.
Saying that you lost respect for Elon Musk is your right. However I personally haven't lost much if any. He was defending a cause he felt strongly about. What was the reporter's motivations?
The article was clearly slanted. So was Elon's rebuttal, but with every force, expect an equal and opposite reaction.
I'm not condoning the rebuttal, but I would put it this way: I understand and sympathize with Elon's overreaction far more than I do with the reporter's initial motivations to slant the story. And he very clearly did slant it.
> Just fix the car.
That's not really the issue, even if he could fix it. Which is easier said than done; we're dealing with advanced material science here. You can bet his team is hard at work on it, but this is the kind of thing that takes many years of deep research. Let's deal with the issue at hand (slanted articles vs slanted rebuttals), for now.
I don't think the OP went into it thinking that Musk or Broder were right.
" just don't respect him anymore, not like I used to. I mean, I do, just not like I used to."
I interpreted that statement to refer to how Tesla reacted to the review. Musk could have taken the opportunity to clearly explain the extenuating circumstances and extended a new opportunity for Broder to take a test drive, but instead opted for this reality-TV-like drama to play out (which, btw, other media sources like CNBC and CNN really enjoyed).
His numbers, which he took pains to make appear exact, simply do not match the data. So where did he get the numbers? To me it seems extremely likely that he made them up to add veracity to his story. "Yeah, that sounds about right." This would not be the first time a journalist had done such a thing. He would have been fine if he had given approximate numbers, or if he had taken better notes, like a good journalist should. He clearly did neither of those things.
Having said that, the theme of the story, that Tesla has problems in cold weather, seems likely to be true. That seems like a worthy story to tell. With real data, from a test under realistic conditions.
Musk is harming his personal brand now, and he should stop for his own sake. But neither the Times nor Broder are in the clear, nor should they be.
The important point from the article is that, even with professional help, it's still difficult to fit an electric car in a gas car world. That's a reality.
That doesn't mean we don't keep moving forward.
What isn't fine is reporting precision that doesn't exist.
The point of such is to strengthen his reporting in ways it doesn't deserve. That's dishonest.
Giving a reporter a pass on that kind of thing is not the way we should go. He's not some casual person casually telling a story to a friend. He's reporting, in "the newspaper of record", and as facts, details that he doesn't have.
I honestly don't care one way or the other about Tesla. It's a long way from ready for mass use.
But I do care that reporters make up facts they don't have. That matters.
"Why are Elon's defenders hung up on this? It's a red herring."
I don't see how it's fine to just push blatant dishonesty to the side..yea it's understandable for people not to remember with precision - which is why journalists/reviewers take notes. We as the reader accept that when a journalist presents (and later defends) precise numbers that are put toward their argument that there is some basis of accuracy to it. When logs show up refuting these claimed accuracies then you start to wonder where else have similar things been 'skewed'.
I highly doubt he can fix it. At least, not on his own.
1) There needs to be more accessible infrastructure. Having superchargers 200mi apart isn't sufficient. They need to be < 50 miles apart, ideally more concentrated in urban areas, and FTLOG why isn't there a charger in manhattan? The car may be able to reach the full range under ideal conditions, but in any non-ideal circumstance like the NYT trip the range will be diminished.
2) They need more realistic marketing. It's not a panacea, and to sell it as such is a misrepresentation. There are issues, the car must be coddled, and until that is explicitly admitted by Tesla marketing material people should not be expected to treat the car gently
This gets back to the marketing issue. If they made those issues clear, then Broder would have expected the effect.
I still question the claim made on http://www.teslamotors.com/models/facts
"The Model S battery will not lose a significant amount of charge when parked for long periods of time. For example, Model S owners can park at the airport without plugging in."
"Model S is engineered to perform in both hot and cold climates."
I'm sure if those types of claims were dialed down then the expectations would be more reasonable
I looked at the chart. I read his response. I read the original. The Times journalist was clearly being honest. He had a really hard time with the car. I had the feeling he wanted the car to be great. He didn't want the disappointment.
Musk is painting him as a villain beset on destroying the future of electric propulsion. It's just not true.
Just fix the car. Make it better. Just make it better, Elon. You can make it better. It's a little broken right now, but you can do it. I still believe in you. I'm a little broken up about your personal issues here, but please, rise above it and make the car better and change the world. I mean, keep changing the world.
This is just a small distraction.