News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by jrajav on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:29AM (#5343047)
Let's see how long that lasts. It sounds like this time around is different from being unable to cancel subscriptions, or a multiplayer server going down - people who bought the game at release actually cannot play it, or encounter major functionality breaks while doing so.

I know that it may be unlikely, but I do hope that this affects their bottom line. EA is a toxic company inside and out.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by seferphier on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:44AM (#5343088)
It could last quite a while. Look at the COD franchise. I was a big fan of COD4. They ignored their community for a long time and each new edition is still selling like hotcakes.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by hsmyers on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:01AM (#5343157)
Regarding your comment of toxicity inside---when was this? Is this from personnel experience? Reason I ask is that 'toxic' is counter to my experience while working for them. Had a great time working with an equally great team. No pointy hairs in sight. That however was in 93 and things may well have changed.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by speeder on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:13AM (#5343479)
I never worked for EA, but I know people.

1993 EA has nothing to do with EA from 1996 onwards...

EA screwed Origin (that then they already owned, just read stuff about development of Ultima 8 and 9... there are lots of documents about how executive meddling made U8 a meh game, and U9 a totally ruined game), then bought and ruined Westwood, and so on.

Also as the time passed they got more and more problems with employees. Then we had crazy shit, like when EA closed a studio in LA, and people found out that the studio had more middle managers than grunts, and this is why the studio could not decide what to do, it simply had so much people giving orders and so few people doing, that doing stuff was impossible.

The EA that wrote this: http://chrishecker.com/Can_a_Computer_Make_You_Cry%3F doesn't exist anymore.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by anonymous on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:33AM (#5343934)
Can you elaborate on what happened in '96? EA have been on my "pirate their games if you really MUST see them yourself" list for a decade at least. However, I wasn't really a gamer back in '93-'96, so I don't know how they used to be and how they changed.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by speeder on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:50PM (#5344717)
I never tried to track what happened exactly, or why.

But their games back then start to suffer from lots of executive meddling, with EA interfering more and more on the artistry of their game authors.

My best guess it is related to the launch of Playstation in late 1995, spurring a race for 3D games and FMV games, requiring much more money than before, and thus requiring more "risk management."

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by benparsons on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:23AM (#5343254)
1993? Probably fair to say a lot has changed in the last 20 years! I don't really follow EA closely, but even so they have a poor image (of what it's like internally.) Google "EA spouse" for a start, the resulting material presents them in a very poor light, even in the (poor) context of the games industry.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by jrajav on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:09AM (#5343459)
I have no personal experience, so I'll defer to yours, but my impression comes from stories like this one: http://ea-spouse.livejournal.com/274.html
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by JackpotDen on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:25AM (#5343887)
"That however was in 93 and things may well have changed."

There's your problem. At some point EA started buying up studios to take the IP and fire the employees. Then they went on a micro purchase bender and got rid of any idea of respecting the customer.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by zipdog on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:39AM (#5343634)
I've been with an EA studio for the last five months and met with people from a dozen other EA studios and like you toxic is not a word I would use to describe the EA I have seen. Quite the opposite
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by waps on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:51AM (#5343391)
So pay with credit card, then if someone pulls this crap call your bank and file a "product not as advertised/doesn't work" complaint ?

That will effectively make business impossible for them if even 0.1% of buyers do this, and it doesn't cost any customer anything.

Plus the banks have incentive to side with the customer, not EA. EA absolutely needs them, but customers can easily run to a different bank.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by Deestan on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:25AM (#5343558)
> So pay with credit card, then if someone pulls this crap call your bank and file a "product not as advertised/doesn't work" complaint ?

If you try this with Steam, they flag you for fraud and shut down your without recourse. All previously bought games are lost.

If you try this with Amazon, they flag you for fraud and shut down your account without recourse. Your previously bought e-books are automatically deleted from all your devices.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by jellicle on Friday March 08, 2013 @09:38AM (#5343632)
At which point you should sue them in small claims court.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by res0nat0r on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:19AM (#5343846)
Or do what most tech savvy people on this forum who know about all of these standard launch day problems should be doing IMO. Wait a few weeks until after launch for things to calm down, monitor the status updates on the website and when the scalability issues are resolved then buy the game and happily play with minor problems for the next 5 years.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by sukuriant on Friday March 08, 2013 @02:11PM (#5345113)
That said, it's going to be kinda funny if this was simply a minor bug that was discovered when scale went up to a few hundred BETA-testers to a couple million players. Maybe whatever load-testing code they had written that said they were good-to-go missed a single (or few) "insignificant" functions that ended up, because of this bug, over-running the server.

I certainly don't like EA's DRM practices and some of their other practices, but now that I'm another day into the future, I could easily see this happening to any company as well-used as them.

Addendum: Startups that claim they don't/wouldn't have these sorts of problems are probably because their load comes slowly, steadily, and these problems are caught early, or refactored out for efficiency, and the developers miss the potentially catastrophic results. When you get hit by a LOAD of traffic all at once, or other similar thing, bad things happen.

See: Diablo 3, Starcraft 2, Half Life 2: Deathmatch

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by Deestan on Friday March 08, 2013 @02:18PM (#5345155)
This is not a realistic option. I'm not going to abandon my quite large collection of games - some of which I play weekly to say in touch with distant family - and then start the lengthy, costly and time-consuming process of suing a company that lives on the other side of the Earth.

The cost of Sim City is literally half an hour of consultancy work. This means the lawsuit would cost me more than I could hope to gain from it, and I would only be doing it to spite the publisher.

If that is my goal, it is a more efficient use of my time to accept the sunken cost, give some negative reviews, and badmouth the publisher.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by waps on Saturday March 09, 2013 @07:24AM (#5348190)
You know if you make 1 account = 1 game policy, you gain something else - ability to resell games.

Think about it.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by steve-howard on Friday March 08, 2013 @01:06PM (#5344811)
Which is something that anybody can do, many will threaten to do, some will intend to do, and very few will actually do.