It seems to me they're for the legislature in the first instance. Only when the legislature fails so egregiously as to be in violation of the constitution would the courts have the power to strike down a law, and I have to hope we want to draw the line somewhere prior to "violates constitutionally guaranteed human rights" and nearer to the point of having some resemblance to proportionality and reason.
In cases like this there is also the issue that a major part of the problem itself is the cost of access to the courts. How do you argue to the court that it costs you an unreasonably large amount of time and money to make your arguments to the court? By the time you make the argument it's moot. It needs to be addressed in the legislature before we ever get to the courts.
And I'll give you that it isn't the executive's purpose to stop things like this from happening, but they can most certainly make things better or worse by making differently the decisions that are within their discretion.
The legislature created the law in question and has no so far seen fit to amend it.
How do you argue to the court that it costs you an unreasonably large amount of time and money to make your arguments to the court?
You would make a selective prosecution argument under the equal protection clause, but you would likely lose as other defendants with fewer resources seem able to navigate the trial process even with public defenders rather than counsel of their choice.
I think access to the courts is sadly lacking in many respects, and would be quite happy to see Congress give the courts more money even at the price of higher taxes.
The point is we could encourage them to do so.
>You would make a selective prosecution argument under the equal protection clause, but you would likely lose as other defendants with fewer resources seem able to navigate the trial process even with public defenders rather than counsel of their choice.
It's not even necessarily selective prosecution. All defendants face the same calculus. The trouble is that paying for and living through years of trials and appeals is arguably a greater penalty than going to jail for a few months. Even if you're totally innocent you can rationally be better off pleading guilty than proving it in court. Even if you win you don't get a free ride in a time machine to undo all the hours and years you had to spend to do it.
>I think access to the courts is sadly lacking in many respects, and would be quite happy to see Congress give the courts more money even at the price of higher taxes.
I don't think it's a money problem. It's a scale problem. We prosecute way too many people. Throwing money at it might provide a certain level of improvement, but it does nothing to address the root issue that so many people are committing crimes and have to be prosecuted. In cases where the crimes are legitimately nefarious, the money would be better spent improving social and educational institutions to the point that future would-be perpetrators are better able to find work or other satisfaction in their lives and don't turn to criminality. In cases where the "crimes" are violations of existing law that cause no real harm to anyone, they should be made trivial offenses or taken off the books entirely so that resources wasted on prosecuting them can be used for some better purpose. If we can significantly reduce the number of people being prosecuted, the amount of resources spent on each side of a trial can be increased and it will still cost less money overall than it does today.
However, this is slow going; there are conflicting theories on the role of criminal law (consequentialist, deontological and so on) and no clear answer on the purpose of sanctions (deterrent, penal, and rehabilitative) that don't yield to simple analysis. Changing this will take a generation, or two.
OK, so one foot in front of the other. Change the debate. Present irrational and disproportionate "tough on crime" rhetoric with strong public opposition and make sure the demagogues fighting progress have to face the scorn and ridicule they deserve.
>There are certainly attempts (mostly at the state level) to downgrade victimless or harmless crimes, and to divert petty or juvenile criminals into non-penal programs or extrajudicial fora.
Which is well and good, though I think most of the problem lies at the federal level, so it would be nice to see more progress there.
>However, this is slow going; there are conflicting theories on the role of criminal law (consequentialist, deontological and so on) and no clear answer on the purpose of sanctions (deterrent, penal, and rehabilitative) that don't yield to simple analysis.
I think the key to this is to realize that the existing system doesn't adequately serve any of those goals. Consequentialists should be dissatisfied by the number of victimless crimes being prosecuted. Deontologically there are a great many "criminals" going unpunished because they violated the letter but not the spirit of the law, while those who violate the spirit but not the letter (or otherwise raise the ire of a prosecutor) are often prosecuted on the basis of "he seems like a bad guy, let's find something we can nail him with." Anyone interested in deterrence or rehabilitation can't be satisfied with the recidivism rate, and anyone interested in punishment (as distinguished from revenge) should be extremely concerned about the lack of proportionality.
Moreover, solutions that work in practice tend to satisfy everybody. Nobody who isn't being intentionally disingenuous is going to be dissatisfied by a reduction in the crime rate or the recidivism rate.
>Changing this will take a generation, or two.
Possibly. It depends how bad we want it and what we're willing to do about it.
This is exactly the problem actually. In the United States, the expensive nature of the legal processes make them tools the powerful use to intimidate, manipulate and disenfranchise the weak. And the real sad part is that if this wasn't the case, large parts of the system would simply crumble.
Heck, forget about federal cases. Think about something as simple as traffic tickets. If you get a ticket for $100, and it was wrongfully given, how much would it cost you to contest it? Well, not only do you have to figure out how to appeal it, but you also have to go through the official process (which in most cases traveling to a courthouse). In most cases, it will be much more costly to have the ticket thrown out than to actually pay it, which is what most people end up doing.
But what if this wasn't the case? What if the contest process was incredibly easy and efficient? Suddenly you would have a ton more tickets invalidated, which would cause police department revenues to plummet. Imagine the (beautiful) chaos that would produce.
The process can't get any easier or cheaper without inviting significant amounts of abuse. It also can't get any easier without denying people their constitutional right to a hearing before a judge/judicial officer.
Suddenly you would have a ton more tickets invalidated, which would cause police department revenues to plummet.
Ticket fines do not go into police department budgets, nor are they used as a revenue source for police departments. Ticket fines go into the local city/county general fund, and only go into police department budgets if allocated to the police department by the appropriate legislative body.
So basically, at least two hours taken out of your workday, plus however long it takes to drive to the courthouse. If you have other work-related appointments at that day and time, you need to figure out another day and time, which in itself is a process.
The process should be made online. If the only thing the judge is doing is listening to five-minute long arguments, create a secure online forum and have the respondents type out their arguments there. The judge can then read them when they have the time and issue a ruling online.
And yet they choose to not prosecute some times. The judicial oversight in plea bargains is to minimize abusive coercion.
Those determinations are for the judicial branch to make, not the executive. Under article II of the Constitution, the executive 'shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.' Under article III, the judicial power rests with the Supreme Court (and such lower courts as it has created). Prosecutors do not have the power to set aside the law, and even where plea bargains are made, they must be approved by a judge first.
I think there are severe flaws with the adversarial legal model that obtains in the US, but the Constitution is extremely clear and explicit about this.