However, the idea that the CFAA is the best we can do in the way of legislation is just laughable. I really can't stand this futile notion that because the law can't be totally perfect, we might as well just give up and allow it to be catastrophically bad. No to that. We can't make it perfect but we can make it a lot better than it is.
You're exactly right but careful about what you're arguing against. I don't think anyone is actually claiming that CFAA is the best achievable law we could have, or that we shouldn't try to improve it (even if we accept that the law will be mostly written and almost completely enforced by those without technical training in computers and networking).
OK, I'll bite. It's overreach because they charged him with a felony for doing something that shouldn't be a felony, and there is reason to suspect that they charged him and not any of the very large number of other people who violate that statute on a regular basis in significant part as a result of his political views.
It's quite possible Ortiz was overzealous. It's quite possible (in fact to some extent almost certain) that the system is broken and defines computer crimes poorly, and Ortiz was doing her job well in a very tough spot. It's possible we're better off with laws aimed to stop computer fraud, and that prosecuting those who commit it (even if they happen to be people we generally like) is a necessity in the 21st century.
At the end of the day we have to remember, we need laws to prevent computer fraud, hacking, etc. Those laws will, almost by necessity, be written and enforced by non-programmers.
Which is not to say Aaron deserved 17 felony charges. But it's overly simple to vilify Ortiz or the AG's office.