http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/jul/29/republican-s...
Virginia, Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, Minnesota?
Subsidies are what they are. Crappy accounting practices at the State and Federal level are what they are.
The fact that states makes an effort to balance their budget says something about the greater accountability at the more local levels. Our Federal representatives don't even appear to have a modicum of shame over the fact that they don't even budget anymore. They just keep raising the debt ceiling, passing continuing resolutions, and printing money. It's astonishing that there are people who defend a centralized system that is completely unaccountable and destroying the country.
Virginia, Louisiana, and Missouri receive more federal dollars than they pay in taxes. For Missouri, the net amount is 2.8% of GDP, Louisiana gets 4.4% of GDP, and Virginia gets a staggering 11.2% of GDP.
North Carolina and Minnesota look pretty good, but they were up there with New York and Illinois in terms of budget deficits a couple of years ago: http://www.wral.com/news/local/politics/story/8049206/
You don't see the irony in this context of asking for a state that pays more in federal taxes than it receives in federal dollars but still manages to have good finances? The reason New York (87%) and Illinois (111%) have such difficulties to begin with is that the federal government extracts so much more from their tax base than they get back in federal money. Minnesota (199%!) pays a higher percentage than Virginia (-145%) receives.
( Numbers are 1990-2009 federal taxes minus spending as percent of state GDP, from here: http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/08/americas-f... )
It's about the discipline of balancing a budget, not the exact amount of money you get to balance.
Huh? My family balances its budget. My Homeowners' Association balances its budget. My city balances its budget. My county? Well, it doesn't balance its budget well, but it's part of an urban area run by liberals... go figure. My state balances its budget. My Federal government does NOT balance its budget or even make an attempt to. What fantasy cherry picked stats would you use to show how the Federal government is run better than the states.
For most things, local control is better than centralized control. We've swung way too far in the centralized direction as a result of the Civil War. Rather than having 50 states that provide different solutions and environments, we mostly have to suffer under the failures of the Federal government.
Additionally, the point is that SOME STATES DO MANAGE AFFAIRS BETTER THAN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. If I agree with how those states manage, then I can move to them. Unless I want to relinquish my citizenship in the USA, I am trapped with one Federal government that sucks.