News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @01:26AM (#5323244)
> The federal government underwent a massive expansion over the course of the 20th century. You're limiting yourself to the period following its expansion and then claiming it hasn't expanded very much since then.

I'm using the period since 1960-1970 because the character of the economy hasn't changed very much since then. Yes, the federal government was a lot smaller in say 1900, but at that time 40% of the population lived on a farm, versus almost nobody today. The appropriate size and scope of government for an agrarian society is not the same as for a burgeoning industrial society is not the same as for a mature service-oriented society.

> Privatizing the inefficiency doesn't make it go away.

Complaining that the government is big and that the government has inefficient policies are two separate complaints. The fact is that once you take out parts of the government budget that are simply taking in checks from one group of people and getting them to another group of people, government expenditures have actually been shrinking relative to GDP. Now, income redistribution may be a problem, but I'd argue it's a separate problem to "government is too big."

> Local programs have greater accountability and can be better tailored to the different needs of local populations.

This is a theoretical trope that is almost wholly not bourne out by actual facts. In practice what happens is that there is far less attention paid to local politics, which means that local government programs can get extremely dysfunctional before anybody starts paying attention. There is pretty much not a single state government that's as well-run as the federal government (except e.g. VA and MD, but its easy to be well-run when you're massively subsidized by the defense budget). A lot of that is due to the fact that state governments get far less scrutiny.

> the cost of such things is born by a more concentrated set of taxpayers who are consequently more likely to demand accountability and shut down wasteful programs

C.f. San Francisco.

> "It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country." -Louis Brandeis

Yet the history of federalism has been that the only experiments states are interested in running are how to suppress minority groups and women.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @10:48AM (#5325114)
>The appropriate size and scope of government for an agrarian society is not the same as for a burgeoning industrial society is not the same as for a mature service-oriented society.

That may be true; it still doesn't tell you what the appropriate size is for each of those. Moreover, I'm talking about the size of the federal government, not the size of all government. I want government to make housing and education more affordable and provide for the care of the elderly etc., I just want it to happen at the state rather than the national level.

>Complaining that the government is big and that the government has inefficient policies are two separate complaints.

One is related to the other. The bigger you make something, the more surface area you create for corruption and waste. Look at the F-35 -- the estimated lifetime cost of that program is a trillion dollars. And most Americans don't even know it exists, because the national attention is focused on medicare and how to raise the tax revenue necessary to continue funding all of the programs that need not exist at the federal level.

>The fact is that once you take out parts of the government budget that are simply taking in checks from one group of people and getting them to another group of people, government expenditures have actually been shrinking relative to GDP.

The parts of the budget "that are simply taking checks from one group of people and getting them to another group of people" are the programs that I'm arguing shouldn't exist at the federal level.

>In practice what happens is that there is far less attention paid to local politics, which means that local government programs can get extremely dysfunctional before anybody starts paying attention.

I can see how this would be true in 1985 when a citizen's connection to the state capitol was almost entirely made up of the local newspaper's capitol reporter writing a weekly column on zoning regulations that almost nobody reads, but that was before the internet.

And a big part of the reason people don't pay attention to local politics today is that the federal government is doing the things the states should be doing. People aren't going to pay attention to things they don't care about. They care a lot about spending programs and taxes.

>C.f. San Francisco.

I'm not going to argue that there has never been an example of state-level waste or a mismanaged state or local government. The point is that when there is a mistake, the scope is limited to that area and we get a baseline in what the other states are doing to compare it against to determine how well it's working.

>Yet the history of federalism has been that the only experiments states are interested in running are how to suppress minority groups and women.

I'm not talking about repealing the Civil Rights Act. Things like that don't cost a lot of money.

And your statement is clearly false. California has been running a profoundly different public university system than, say, Texas. The services offered by New York are better tuned to the needs of citizens in a thriving metropolis. The services offered by Wyoming are better tuned to the needs of citizens living in rural areas. Why should we be so keen to crush local diversity and choice in spending programs?

Federal laws are terrible at things like that. Here's one important example: Most federal programs and taxes don't account for regional cost of living. So someone living in San Francisco making $70,000/year is paying a much higher federal tax rate, and is eligible for a much smaller subset of need-based federal programs, than someone living just outside Kansas City doing the same job who makes half as much money but also pays half as much for products and services and thereby achieves the same standard of living.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by crusso on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @09:16AM (#5324542)
not a single state government that's as well-run as the federal government

Huh? My family balances its budget. My Homeowners' Association balances its budget. My city balances its budget. My county? Well, it doesn't balance its budget well, but it's part of an urban area run by liberals... go figure. My state balances its budget. My Federal government does NOT balance its budget or even make an attempt to. What fantasy cherry picked stats would you use to show how the Federal government is run better than the states.

For most things, local control is better than centralized control. We've swung way too far in the centralized direction as a result of the Civil War. Rather than having 50 states that provide different solutions and environments, we mostly have to suffer under the failures of the Federal government.

Additionally, the point is that SOME STATES DO MANAGE AFFAIRS BETTER THAN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. If I agree with how those states manage, then I can move to them. Unless I want to relinquish my citizenship in the USA, I am trapped with one Federal government that sucks.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by tptacek on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @09:45AM (#5324704)
Those states have small populations, low density, and large extractive industry revenues, and still receive large amounts of assistance from the federal government (Alaska being a good example).
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @11:05AM (#5325228)
What state of any substantial size is run better than the federal government, when you take out federal subsidies or massive oil/gas revenues (Saudi Arabia doesn't have a budget deficit---that doesn't mean it's well run).
Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by crusso on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @11:39AM (#5325479)
Let me Google that for you:

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/jul/29/republican-s...

Virginia, Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, Minnesota?

Subsidies are what they are. Crappy accounting practices at the State and Federal level are what they are.

The fact that states makes an effort to balance their budget says something about the greater accountability at the more local levels. Our Federal representatives don't even appear to have a modicum of shame over the fact that they don't even budget anymore. They just keep raising the debt ceiling, passing continuing resolutions, and printing money. It's astonishing that there are people who defend a centralized system that is completely unaccountable and destroying the country.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @11:56AM (#5325596)
> Virginia, Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, Minnesota?

Virginia, Louisiana, and Missouri receive more federal dollars than they pay in taxes. For Missouri, the net amount is 2.8% of GDP, Louisiana gets 4.4% of GDP, and Virginia gets a staggering 11.2% of GDP.

North Carolina and Minnesota look pretty good, but they were up there with New York and Illinois in terms of budget deficits a couple of years ago: http://www.wral.com/news/local/politics/story/8049206/

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @02:57PM (#5326924)
>Virginia, Louisiana, and Missouri receive more federal dollars than they pay in taxes.

You don't see the irony in this context of asking for a state that pays more in federal taxes than it receives in federal dollars but still manages to have good finances? The reason New York (87%) and Illinois (111%) have such difficulties to begin with is that the federal government extracts so much more from their tax base than they get back in federal money. Minnesota (199%!) pays a higher percentage than Virginia (-145%) receives.

( Numbers are 1990-2009 federal taxes minus spending as percent of state GDP, from here: http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/08/americas-f... )

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by crusso on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @02:03PM (#5326564)
Why do subsidies matter all that much? If they balance the budget with subsidies or without, they are BALANCING A BUDGET. If I get a bonus one year, I spend a little more. If I don't, I don't spend more. I balance the budget.

It's about the discipline of balancing a budget, not the exact amount of money you get to balance.

Re:Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone? by rayiner on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:49PM (#5327253)
> Why do subsidies matter all that much?

Because balancing a budget is easier when you have more money?