News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by confluence on Sunday March 03, 2013 @03:20AM (#5312961)
If I were a governmental entity - I'd go ahead and set up my very own honeypot VPN provider. I'd then log everything - whilst providing exceptional service - and play the long game - collect as much data from people who self-select themselves as requiring large amounts of anonymity (the paranoid/people who can't access Hulu overseas/criminals/terrorists).

I'd wait a few years and then use said data to slowly infiltrate various groups - looking to grab the big fish that are hopefully well separated from the VPN service and then take them down quietly.

Hell - I might even turn a nice little profit on the side.

Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous.

Note: I don't actually believe the above to actually be the case in reality - but one must remember that stuff like Room 641A weren't that long ago (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A).

This is an example of where worst case thinking, despite its negative reputation, can help protect oneself from falling prey to the faulty assumptions that bring down complex systems (Will the generators kick in on time? What if the VPN provider is already compromised? Did we double check that after cleaning the safety valves - we didn't block any of them?).

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by skriticos2 on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:37AM (#5313123)
>> Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous.

I totally agree. Luckily more and more VPN providers accept Bitcoin payment, so that problem is solved (if you don't connect your wallet to your ID, that is) [1]. I think the more challenging part is not sending personally identifiable information through your VPN or encrypt it properly. Much of the Web is architected to identify you based on the most mundane technical information, like your browser string, cookies, the way you type or those little data leeks that happen here and there.

[1] http://www.bestvpnservice.com/blog/vpn-providers-with-bitcoi...

ps. No, I don't use a VPN. But I like to stay informed.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tjoff on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:59AM (#5313159)
>> (if you don't connect your wallet to your ID, that is)

Which is not easy.

Either you have to mine your bitcoins or you have to trust a third party to exchange your bitcoins in order to disconnect the transaction history from you. But you do have to trust that third party.

Those are the only solutions that I know of.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by skriticos2 on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:16AM (#5313205)
Well, you could just by them on the street with paper money [1]. Or you could use one of the shuffling services around [2].

[1] https://localbitcoins.com/ [2] https://www.google.com/#hl=en&q=bitcoin+laundry

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by PeterisP on Sunday March 03, 2013 @06:57AM (#5313438)
Any government entity interested in setting up honeypot VPN services would also set up honeypot bitcoin laundering services - which would do everything efficiently, properly and cheaply (you can subsidize costs), while keeping logs that can be used when/if really needed.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by chrismsnz on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:14PM (#5315456)
> which would do everything efficiently, properly and cheaply

Doesn't really sound like government to me...

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tedks on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:30PM (#5315816)
What government entity cares this much about bittorrent vpns?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tjoff on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:18AM (#5313211)
Both requiring you to trust a third party.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by chaostheory on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:57PM (#5314543)
Almost everything in modern society, especially most things related to technology, requires trusting a 3rd party at one point or another.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tjoff on Sunday March 03, 2013 @03:36PM (#5315146)
Yes, but the general perception of bitcoin is that it is completely anonymous. Where it in practice probably is, if you don't take any precautions, the least anonymous currency in the world, where everyone can inspect the transaction history of coins and anyone with decent turn-over can map out a lot. Trivially (these databases will, of course, be sold and leaked). And since most services at some point require you to reveal yourself mapping out individuals from bitcoin transactions isn't exactly difficult.

The sad part is that since the history is public, if you goof up and reveal your identity sometime in 2015 your actions of today might also get revealed. To any third party. Potentially way worse than any sort of currency ever used; but the only thing people talk about is how bitcoin is this anonymous currency...

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by rdl on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:49AM (#5313307)
Even if you use magic to pay for the VPN, there's still lots of linkability just based on time of use, source-IP, etc. Add to that all the traffic which goes over the VPN, and you're probably screwed.

Tor is the right solution here, not a VPN.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by e12e on Sunday March 03, 2013 @11:58AM (#5314321)
I wonder how large percentage of tor exit nodes (and nodes in general) are operated by intelligence agencies? I remember reading that the various agencies across Europe were active in setting up and running mixmaster remailers -- and the (stated) purpose of TOR is to be a viable covert communication channel for spies.

Remember that a "node run by the CIA", can just mean that the ph.d. student that required some resources from the IT department has a handler. Said student might even think the thing isn't monitored -- although I suspect it would be easier to to involve the admin, then keep him/her in the dark.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by robinh on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:16PM (#5314383)
I think the solution to this problem probably doesn't involve trying to track down these bad nodes. Rather, more people should host Tor nodes, so as to reduce the chance of someone connecting to a bad one. As big as intelligence agencies are, they cannot operate too many nodes easily - the more nodes they operate, the bigger the chance that someone notices suspicious activity going on. On the other hand, there are a lot more civilians who can host Tor nodes without it being suspicious, thus dealing with the threat of intelligence agencies.

I'm curious about what the exact ratios would be, if there were a way to find this out (probably not).

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by johnsoft on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:35PM (#5314452)
How would you go about hosting a Tor node, without exposing yourself to problems like this? http://raided4tor.cryto.net/

I've thought about running an exit node, but I'm not willing to sacrifice my own safety and freedom to do it. The only solution seems to be buying hosting anonymously (bitcoins?), and making sure you only log in to the server over Tor.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by wfn on Sunday March 03, 2013 @01:04PM (#5314566)
FWIW I think one is helping the Tor network even if they decide to only run an internal Tor node (not an exit). I believe Tor hidden services might become more popular in the months to come, and a lot of resources that the users were initially trying to access anonymously are / will be reachable as hidden services (e.g. wikileaks).
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by IgorPartola on Sunday March 03, 2013 @01:12PM (#5314596)
I run an exit node in Egypt on a server from CityNet Host [1], that I got on a promo. Pumping 400 Gb/m through it for $2.50 a month. I would not host one at home but Egypt seems far enough.

[1] http://citynethost.com/vps.asp

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by pyre on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:06PM (#5319472)
Note: You link to the VPS page, but looks like the "Shared Hosting" is where the $2.95/mo package is, and it says it only comes w/ 50GB of bandwidth.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by IgorPartola on Monday March 04, 2013 @02:07PM (#5320010)
I got my VPS on a promotion, so it really is $2.50 though it looks like you can't get the same deal anymore. http://lowendbox.com has plenty of these, including $15/year deals from BuyVM.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tedks on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:32PM (#5315823)
A sybill attack on Tor is probably the least efficient attack. It'd be far easier to perform a correlation attack if you know the probable endpoints, or compromise the target's computer (if you only know the source).

I'm sure government agencies run Tor exits, which means they'll see the middleman node's IP addresses and whatever traffic the originator sent (usually HTTPS). They can't do much with that.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by robinh on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:12PM (#5314369)
Unfortunately, even Tor is not perfect. It obviously cannot prevent end-to-end correlation, and it also turns out to be very hard to do Tor right (e.g. not leaking information in the data streams).
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by jacquesm on Sunday March 03, 2013 @03:23AM (#5312970)
I'd set up a forum where I'd review these things to make sure that new entrants to the game would flock to my bugged services. I'd give articles there titles that suggest that the competition does not take your privacy seriously.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by benologist on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:59AM (#5313163)
Why use a forum? It'd be much easier to just set up a blog and anonymously write heavily baited articles for other site's communities.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by antihero on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:08AM (#5313455)
I'd write an article on TorrentFreak and post it on Hacker News...
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by sfx on Sunday March 03, 2013 @11:00AM (#5314128)
It's worse than Room 641A. All US communications are currently being mined and stored by our gov. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center)

I'm not really sure how much good a VPN will do with this much surveillance. I feel it's only going to get worse. CCTVs feeding into said datacenters? Web, traffic, and dash cams? As long as the common man "has nothing to hide" they don't seem to care.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by GoodIntentions on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:06PM (#5314346)
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by lenazegher on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:13AM (#5313465)
>Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous.

In the UK and US, it's easy to buy pre-paid credit cards with cash.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by alive-or-not on Sunday March 03, 2013 @10:34AM (#5314036)
Most shops have CCTV, systems like TrapWire can automatically link your identity to the credit card.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by jliptzin on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:47PM (#5315549)
Only buy them on halloween?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by frio on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:52PM (#5315878)
> Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous.

After attending a local security conference last year (Kiwicon), I briefly tried to see how anonymous I could make myself online. In NZ, we're lucky to have anonymous prepaid credit cards -- "Prezzy Cards" -- which our postal service sells.

Turns out that several VPN services (I ended up using hidemyass.com) will accept them. Alongside an anonymous mail service for the actual account, it's pretty straightforward to head to an internet cafe, boot your laptop into something like Tails, and then create a completely anonymous VPN connection.

Not that I'd personally go to that extent, but it's nice to know that you can achieve a reasonable degree of anonymity online.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by joshschreuder on Monday March 04, 2013 @05:26PM (#5321442)
I'm not sure how viable it would be in NZ, but in the strip search prank call case (as seen recently in the film Compliance), the perpetrator bought calling cards from a couple of Walmarts. They were able to trace the serial number of the card back to the stores, and comparing video from both, found the guy on film walking out of both stores. So even these prepaid credit cards might not be completely infallible.

More information here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strip_search_prank_call_scam#In...

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by frio on Wednesday March 06, 2013 @04:28PM (#5334102)
For sure -- the physical aspect is definitely something worth mitigating too (in both the case of the Prezzy Card store, and the Net Cafes having video). If I was going full paranoid, I'd probably find some way of altering my appearance too -- but that seemed like it involved overly much effort at the time :).

I was just surprised that, with a little effort, it wasn't actually that hard to gain a markedly greater degree of anonyminity than you'd usually have.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by Zirro on Sunday March 03, 2013 @03:52AM (#5313042)
"If I were a governmental entity..."

In that case, you would be a governmental entity which does not care much for the rights of your citizens. Instead, pick a service in a country with a transparent, low corruption-government. I suggest the Scandinavian countries.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by ptaipale on Sunday March 03, 2013 @05:45AM (#5313297)
As a resident of said countries, I'd propose that you should not trust Scandinavian governments either. The officials are not that corrupt but the politicians are politicians. Moreover, in these countries there's a widespread belief that the state can do no wrong, that restricting freedom of speech is okay if done for a good cause, that censoring the net is a good thing for the government to do. Even the rule of law can simply be dismissed (it started with preventing child pornography, of course).
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by fulafel on Sunday March 03, 2013 @10:17AM (#5313985)
I think the point was that scandinavian countries are less bad than the alternatives.

There are restrictions on freedom of speech in just about every country btw.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by ptaipale on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:08PM (#5314353)
Sure there are. But we could apply Dilbert's management theory to this and split governments to types on axis good/evil (G/E) and on axis competent/incompetent (C/E). The worst thing you can have is an evil competent (EC) government.

Therefore I'd say it's more important to have an I government than a G government, because it is easier for a government to go from G to E than it is to go from I to C.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by fulafel on Sunday March 03, 2013 @12:49PM (#5314513)
So which government(s) have a more favourable equation of agenda+capabilities towards net freedom? Taken literally, the most "I" countries would be bad bets: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Failed_state#2012

Remember that it was US pressure that drove the recent unpleaseantness in .se and TPB were able to succesfully defend themselves there for many years - and most countries currently willing to stare down threats of US trade sanctions aren't exactly havens of privacy and net freedom.

The pro net freedom countries currently correlate with G&C governments, it seems.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by ptaipale on Sunday March 03, 2013 @02:48PM (#5314990)
Yes, extreme incompetence is not good. BTW I haven't seen much evidence about US pressure regarding unpleasantness in .se (I assume you mean Assange).

Anyway, I sort of like the incompetence level in Greece. They haven't been able to set up a land registry, so that the government could collect property taxes. That sounds promising from the point of view of setting up a privacy-respecting net service. There is a mostly reliable supply of electricity and communications, and it's not a very bad a place to live.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tjoff on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:53AM (#5313141)
No government understands IT the slightest, because of that I don't know of a single governmental entity that cares the slightest of the rights of its citizens when it comes to computer and internet stuff. They don't even understand it so how can they be respectful of it?

As a Swede, I certainly wouldn't trust the Scandinavian countries for this. It's not uncommon to hear politicians claim that internet anonymity and encryption altogether should be completely abandoned.

Also, ISPs typically have numerous laws that forbid eavesdropping, VPNs don't. And seeing as how the government can always ask to get any information they want from any VPN provider (and that the VPN provider is, supposedly, legally obligated to keep records of their customers (in many countries, including Sweden)) using a VPN might be the worst thing you could possibly do, if you want anonymity or integrity. I'm guessing that most VPNs in Sweden straight up Lie about this, when this issue was hot a few years ago you either couldn't get a straight answer or you got one that admitted to record keeping - many (including many of those on torrentfreaks list) just stated that they had to, by law, keep records and that they had to hand them over if asked (with a court order). The law hasn't changed what I know, the PR department of VPN providers probably has though...

And even if they don't have any records to share, who is to say they can't, by request, eavesdrop on current traffic.

For it to have any real effect I'd choose a VPN that is in another country than the one you are in. Although this will probably not have any real effect either if you attract some serious attention, especially considering that unlike an ISP, a VPN provider could legally betray it's customers without an court order (in exchange for being quiet about it).

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by sneak on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:40AM (#5313524)
> No government understands IT the slightest

uhh, stuxnet.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by tjoff on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:28AM (#5313645)
They just listened to their advisors. When it comes to creating laws the media industry is the advisors.

No, they don't understand IT.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by moe on Sunday March 03, 2013 @09:47AM (#5313881)
But politicians die, too.

In a few years the political caste will consist of people from the facebook generation and beyond. And some of them will understand IT.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by natar on Sunday March 03, 2013 @06:30AM (#5313397)
„I suggest the Scandinavian countries.“ Read up about The Pirate Bay trial and Julian Assange and you'll be thinking differently.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by rahimnathwani on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:05AM (#5313066)
The legal jurisdiction and/or technical location of the service might be a country with a transparent government, but how would you know that the service isn't owned or operated by a government entity from some other country?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by Xylakant on Sunday March 03, 2013 @04:07AM (#5313069)
Why can't any interested entity set up a company in the Scandinavian states? So how would that really help?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by PeterisP on Sunday March 03, 2013 @06:53AM (#5313431)
In order to be safe from unreasonable government "requests", it is not enough to set up a limited liability company located in a 'safe' country - you need to have everything (including yourself) in 'safe' countries.

As a blunt example, if you want to properly run a data-sensitive company and be imune to (for example) USA requests to violate anonymity of your customers, you need to ensure at least the following:

(a) the company itself is beyond reach of USA - as in examples of UK, Sweden and others caving in to USA requests for things that would/should be legal in these countries but illegal in USA;

(b) you and any personell are beyond reach of USA - again, there are examples such as Kim Dotcom, McKinnon, Assange;

(c) the company internet resources are beyond reach of USA - examples such as revoking DNS names of spanish companies for transmitting internet-TV in compliance with spanish laws, or some of Mega's non-US domain names revoked before even starting operations;

(d) the company money flow is beyond reach of USA - examples of Visa&Mastercard or Paypal blocking payments to sources such as Wikileaks or, IIRC, distributors of (locally legal) console modchips.

Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by mikeratcliffe on Sunday March 03, 2013 @11:04AM (#5314140)
That would be entrapment.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by otterley on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:06AM (#5316744)
That's an interesting legal conclusion. Can you cite any cases that support this assertion?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by kmkemp on Sunday March 03, 2013 @02:24PM (#5314902)
Being a customer to a VPN service isn't a crime. Why are people paranoid about paying for a legal service?
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by chc on Sunday March 03, 2013 @02:49PM (#5314996)
I can't tell if you're being obtuse or naive, but the implication here is that you're going to use them to less-than-legal ends. The link at the beginning of the article is to a guy facing 15 years for hacking Sony. For another example that would be familiar to readers of the OP site, many US ISPs are now inspecting their customers' traffic to look out for media piracy, and a VPN is the obvious way to circumvent that.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by kmkemp on Sunday March 03, 2013 @07:45PM (#5315861)
No, I'm being completely serious. VPN's are a legitimate service with legitimate uses. Anonymity has merit even if you are 100% legal. I can't imagine someone being convicted of a crime based on only their participation with a VPN service. Sure, you are still trusting a 3rd party to do what it is they say that they will, but I don't see why people care if the government or whoever knows that they use a VPN service. Hell, I use one for work and I don't expect that the government will be knocking on my door because of it.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by chc on Sunday March 03, 2013 @08:20PM (#5315952)
You're arguing with something nobody ever said. The point isn't that using an anonymous VPN is a crime, but that people who use an anonymous/private VPN are more likely to have something to hide, which means you'll find a lot of people committing crime there.
Re:VPN Services That Take Your Anonymity Seriously by kmkemp on Sunday March 03, 2013 @10:30PM (#5316412)
There is ample discussion on this page regarding the anonymous subscription option of bitcoins. The post I responded to claims:

"Reality check: if your credit card details are visible to a third party - you're not anonymous."

But that's missing the point since keeping the users' activity anonymous is what matters... not that they are customers.