The lightning connector doesn't have enough bandwidth to drive a HDMI connexion directly
Of course, compressing (inside the iPad) for streaming, sending this through a limited bandwidth channel and then decompressing is complicated, but looks like it's the easiest solution (because all components - especially sw ones - are off the shelf)
It's like a mini Raspberry-pi in that adaptor, amazing! (if not slightly overpriced)
What a wonderful age we live in. How long ago was it that people doubted the Rasberry-Pi could be delivered at such a low price?
One of those rare moments where movement to the future is evidently palpable.
I'm gung-ho for Lightning but if it turns out to be nothing more than a fancy way to make USB expensive and proprietary I'll be having another think. If it guarantees accessory compatibility for 6-10 years it's worth a couple compromises but I do expect 1080P output as advertised.
It makes sense...
That said, the design for this AV adapter is puzzling. I wonder what the hardware limitation was that prevented straight digital video out. (# of pins?)
However, MHL-through-Lightning might have prevented the AV adaptor having a daisy chained lightning socket of it's own. Maybe that's why Apple jumped through these hoops.
The cynic in me says this is an end-run around any DRM issues giving access to that 1080p bitstream could introduce: instead let's just output a degraded, upscaled stream and call it HD.
This allows them to support different formats in the future, for instance, say when HDMI isn't popular.
The 30 pin connector didn't have HDMI on it at the time it was created and they have repurposed pins over the years regularly.
Here they can have a much less complicated solution-- a standardised serial bus over which they can stream any future protocol they want to support.
It's a lot more future proof.
It would have been just as easy to use micro-usb 3.0, which had plenty of bandwidth, and do the exact same pin or format conversions.
Standardized serial buses that are less complicated already existed. What exactly do you think USB 3.0 is?
If the only reason for lighting was "a general purpose next generation serial format", then it is definitely a horrible idea.
Of course, none of this (except DRM concerns) answers why they'd not bitstream the format and convert it to HDMI signaling instead of doing the weird crap they did here.
And people have answered this convincingly. From comments on TFA:
= = = = =
The reason behind this stupid expensive solution: It seems that the lightning connector is similar to the thunderbolt connector idea.
With USB you have Power/USB/MHL output. Each method requires a specific combination of pins. Updating to a different protocol, support for other devices requires difficult pin sharing (thus hardware modification), support for currently unknown future connections is impossible. If in the future something new appears it won’t work with older USB devices.
With lightning you can connect anything. Similar to thunderbolt it does not use a specific protocol to handle a specific task. It uses a general method to communicate between adapter and iOS device. That way Apple can send anything through this lightning adapter. The adapter itself gets updated automatically because it loads its firmware from the used device. So Apple can send USB2.0, USB3.0, Analog audio, Digital Audio, HDMI and any new standard through it, in theory.
The idea is great: The lightning adapter will be Apples only port and it will remain future proof.
In reality however, the lightning connector also has a limited bandwidth thus they have to compress their data, the conversion to and from the Apple lightning protocol requires lots of processing power, on both sides, and reduces quality. And finally it’s expensive.
Apple should have tried to use thunderbolt instead of their own propietary technology, but then they would have used a common technology which other manufacturers could use and benefit from, too, that’s not the way Apple likes it, so they introduced their own thing, which is crap right now.
AND:
Just remember, this is v1 hardware for a tough future proofing problem. I genuinely appreciate the lengths Apple went through to create A) a reversible plug, so you can stop mashing and flipping. B) handled all the connector options. The built in decoder module could take a compatible 1080p video stream and push that to the TV at full resolution, the screen mirroring is a separate protocol. Now I’m curious if the Lightning-SVGA adapter has the same rig!
So, v1 of the Lightning connector is probably (assuming) going at USB2 speeds. In v2 of the connector we could see USB3 (5Gbit/s) or thunderbolt (10Gbit/s) speeds, but all the accessories still work.
Assuming the faster speeds come, it’ll support 4K TV output video streams, same plug. Yay future.
I first heard about Lightning just 2 days ago. I'm now confused between Thunderbolt and Lightning, and frustrated that I'll have to go learn about their differences.
And Thunderbolt is still the all-in-one replacement for all wired connections. So apparently the purpose behind the Thunderbolt connector subsumes the purpose behind the Lightning connector, yet the existence of Thunderbolt does not obviate Lightning's existence.
Sorry for the slow uptake, Galileo ;)
Because once you accept Lighting as the connector, there is no "dumb". You have USB and this is where you have to start. You don't get DVI/HDMI signals, analog audio, or anything else.
Maybe I'm missing something, but I feel like Lightning is just the next Firewire without all the usefulness that FW had (low latency, dedicated bus that wasn't USB, lots of pro audio gear that worked with it, ability to daisy-chain, faster real-world speeds than USB, near-ubiquity before FW800 came out, super small form factor (the 4pin is tiny; not much bigger than a lightning)).