This is the tricky part. I don't remember exact figures, but wasn't Truman's dilemma a choice between invading Japan or dropping the bombs? I don't really see a viable third option, and I don't remember reading about one either. The tragedy is that the Japanese were not given enough time to surrender after the first bomb was dropped.
Also, the United States has also done some terrible things "in the name of democracy," but I still think there is a difference in magnitude between installing a dictator in a foreign country and encouraging the systematic murder and rape of civilians.
The problem is that these things are on a spectrum - is it not possible to condemn both while admitting that one alternative was better? I obviously don't want anyone to use nuclear weapons, but how should we react when it is the option that results in the least amount of suffering?
And as far as saying "them" -- this was out of convenience. It is a pronoun, after all, and I was merely trying to say that elegant solutions are quite hard to find when you're dealing with ugly problems. Sometimes "less ugly" is all you can find.
Suffice to say, your moral high ground is not as clear cut to me, especially when you talk about justifying the atom bomb.
And I'm not justifying use of the atomic bomb in every scenario, or even saying that it was the best possible outcome, but out of the options available to Truman, it appears to be the one that would have resulted in the least amount of suffering.
There has been a strong correlation between US-trained South American dictators and death squads.
http://www.laprogressive.com/school-of-the-americas-grads-be...
The US CIA and special forces supervised these kinds of tactics in the Vietnam war, with rape used for interrogation and the killing of tens of thousands of civilians.
You can't actually be serious?
The firebombing of Tokyo caused more deaths, not less, than either of the atomic bombs. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo :
"The Operation Meetinghouse firebombing of Tokyo on the night of 9/10 March 1945 was the single deadliest air raid of World War II;[2] greater than Dresden,[13] Hiroshima, or Nagasaki as single events."
> As an aside, do you really think that in a country that was in complete shambles, that any word of a bomb that had killed everyone around it, or that word of the real damage would have gotten to the emperor in the time it took them to surrender?
The Emperor knew the same day. However much of a "shambles" the Home Islands may have been in, the Japanese at least had telegraph cables, and when they stopped responding from Hiroshima, and when the outskirts of Hiroshima wired news of a horrific bomb detonation they actually sent planes over to investigate and confirm.
> The most likely reason that they surrendered was that they knew they were hooped once the Soviets finally joined the war against them on August 8th.
The U.S.S.R. declaration of war certainly caught them by surprise; but the Japanese were certainly not stupid. They knew the war was not winnable by 1943 when they lost the strategic initiative in the Pacific to the U.S.
The U.S. had the men, the Navy, and the equipment already in-theatre for the invasion. The U.S.S.R. had the men but not the naval or air forces needed to cover an amphibious invasion before the U.S. could start, so their entering the war only had a strategic impact for Manchukuo (and later, North Korea).
The real concern was probably the Soviets. They had already invaded Manchuria and some say they had their eye on Japan.
Seems pretty evil to drop an A-bomb as a warning to someone else, but the next few decades of Soviet occupation would have sucked for the Japanese, too.
Also, it was probably a good idea to confront the morality of nuclear warfare by dropping a 20 kT bomb. Would Truman have stopped MacArthur from deploying a hundred times that much firepower in Korea, if he hadn't seen the effects of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs for himself?
Heck go hear the hardcore history podcast on the matter, then you will understand that it is just not that simple.
Personal revenge and punishment has already an interesting amount of counter arguments. But when we begin to lift this issue up to whole populations/ethnic groups, the thing starts to get out of control.
Collective guilt and responsibility and punishment were the same actors behind the very atrocities we were condemning and fighting.
In the hearts of many people, the Jews deserved what happened to them because they were the alleged cause of their problems and misery (and they needed an enemy, someone to blame). And it was way easier for German people to not feel empathy for all the Jewish neighbors disappearing once they thought of them as "them", as carrying a collective guilt, regardless of individuals.
So, I'm not here to discuss who is worse. But sometimes, as I struggle to understand how it's possible have had so many millions of complacent people, assisting, giving power to cruel dictators, sometimes I have a glimpse of how is this feeling, each time I happen to think "well, they deserve it".
http://www.sho.com/sho/oliver-stones-untold-history-of-the-u...
the japanese tried several times after the russians invased to surrender (before the drop)
You already mentioned the US and Japanese military deaths had we had to invade the island. It's also likely that more than 250,000 civilians would have died during that invasion. Largely different people would have died, and Truman had to "play God" but I believe that millions of lives were saved. His options sucked.
Truman's options sucked? That's just official US propaganda. Actual history says that the Japanese were in dire condition, have had pretty much surrendered and only asked for some very inconsequential counter-demands in order to officiallly sign their surrender [1].
The US dropped the bomb anyway, and then another, because they were eager to test in on real conditions, and wanted to sent a message to the USSR as the war was coming to an end and the new era of "cold war" began.
[1] Not to mention that they were literally forced to attack the US (in Pearl Harbor) in the first place, by very careful manoeuvring of the US part, that wanted an excuse to enter the war.
I see, even Pearl Harbor wasn't really their aggression. Was the brutal torture of POW their fault or did we force them to do it?
Their brutal torture of POW and the unbelievable atrocities they did against the Chinese were THEIR (the Japanese's) fault. Their imperialistic ambitions and their treatment of Korea was also THEIR fault.
Why would you expect me to say otherwise?
I guess because then I would just be a pro-Japanese US-hater crazy guy to be easily dismissed.
Only I don't take sides, I just call it as it is (well, at least to my knowledge).
So, yes, the Japanese did awful things in the war. But dropping A-bombs on civilians was also awful, and it was not even justified because of any "he had to do it to end the war" situation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_D._Leahy#Atomic_bomb
The nukes were used not to beat the Japanese, but to intimidate the Russians, who had advanced as an industrial force as part of their fight against Germany.
They refused to surrender after Hiroshima. They refused to surrender after the U.S.S.R. declared war. Finally after Nagasaki their cabinet deadlocked 2-2 on the decision to surrender. The Emperor himself broke the tie by deciding for peace (a decision which brought a minor coup of its own).
Adm. Leahy was correct if he was using Western logic and ideals. In fact it was clear since 1943 that Japan would be defeated and had to surrender or eventually lose the war.
He's also correct that it was of no material assistance compared to conventional weaponry. There were only so many atomic bombs available and the B-17s rampaging across Japan were certainly doing a fine job as well.
The part I don't understand is why he thought atomic bombing a city was barbarous, but firebombing Tokyo was how gentlemen conducted warfare. More Japanese died in a single firebombing raid than died in Dresden, Hiroshima, or Nagasaki.
This raid I mention occurred in March 1945 by the way, not August. In light of that it's hard to claim with a straight face that conventional weapons were forcing Japan to surrender before invasion of the Home Islands. They had every reason to surrender in March if that was their only tripwire to decide to do so.
But the Japanese had the chance to surrender and they didn't. Lots of second guessing now, maybe they gambled on getting better terms...
I can understand the argument that dropping the bombs made japan surrender more quickly, and thus saved a lot of american soldier's lives.
Most of the people who died in the hiroshima and nagasaki were only responsible of being victims of an oppressing government and state ideology.
Furthermore there were a lot of prisoners who died as well, for example 20000 korean prisoners.
Not sure though if most of the people would find ethically acceptable to actively murder 250000 random people in order save some from cruelties.
I'm sure there can be an endless discussion about this. However, I just wanted to note how easy is overlook completely this when you think in terms of "them".
The bomb wasn't dropped on the torturers, the rapists, which in many cases were not held responsible for the crimes they committed.
I know that it sounds obvious, but this way of thinking, is the one of the reasons all this atrocities are allowed to start in the first place. By thinking of other people as inherently different from you, they can be thought of as inferior and thus you feel exempted of feeling wrong about the stuff that's being done to them.
Humanity has very long history of this behavior, actually it was more common than not (slavery etc). The thing that's peculiar about the WWII is the systematic way, the unstoppable industrial approach and the way that cold heartless "science" gave apparent purpose for nightmares to come true.
WWII helped shape the very notion of evil in our age, it's style and motivation.