Re:How We Treat Pets in America
by nsns on Thursday February 28, 2013 @02:28PM
(#5300395)
Somewhat ironic to find this post two links above the one about lab rats getting tortured for "science". I guess rats are uglier.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I for one find this kind of cognitive dissonance extremely upsetting and a bit perplexing. People are easily able to compartmentalize their feelings about various animals. This leads to neat little groups - food, pet, science experiment. It's very frustrating to me.
If it's purely the compartmentalization that upsets you, then you'd be happier if people were totally cool about tossing the Frisbee around with their dog Spot on Saturday, then cooking him up for Sunday dinner. Is that the case?
Anyway, people are a mix of rationality and emotions. We build up emotional attachments to the animals we keep as pets, and get uneasy thinking about using them in meals or experiments.
I'd prefer some consistency. If people think it's horrific to eat a dog, there's no reason they should be perfectly cool eating a pig.
> It's very frustrating to me.
Why? We're human beings--all we do is categorize...
Yes, I'm aware of the natural proclivity. That's part of what leads to to racism and stereotyping. We don't shrug those off as just being natural.
Re:How We Treat Pets in America
by youngerdryas on Thursday February 28, 2013 @03:15PM
(#5300678)
>This leads to neat little groups
Not so neat. Some people eat dog and some have pet rats.
I didn't say they were universally accepted groups. Those people who have pet rats likely do not want rats being experimented on. And those people who eat dogs probably don't keep them as beloved pets.
Worse, rats are at least as capable of training and intelligent behavior as dogs, making the differential treatment even harder to understand.
One significant difference though, is the rate at which rats breed and how much more of a negative load they can place on the environment (and humans) when released into the wild.
In this case, it might extend beyond rats being uglier. There is research supporting the idea that the human/dog relationship is a case of coevalution [1]