News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by dkulchenko on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:33AM (#5291010)
I assure you, it has not.

Sometimes it's hard to look past TechCrunch and the endless SaaS/CRUD apps, but we're in the middle of a technological revolution right now. Platforms like Kickstarter are driving innovation like never before, pushing forward ideas that would have never seen the light of day otherwise. The new tech coming out of the machine is awe-inspiring.

Even as a tiny, tiny sample of what's happening out there: Google's making self-driving cars, healthcare is advancing by leaps and bounds, and portable electronics have changed the way we live our lives over the course of but 5 years.

Google Glass? Oculus Rift? Leap Motion? MYO? All tech that would simply blow your mind just 10 years ago, but we're practically taking it for granted today. I'm typing this on a thin glass slab, for Christ's sake, this is something out of Star Trek.

If you're struggling to see innovation, you aren't looking hard enough.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by tomjen3 on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:48AM (#5291046)
There is no inovation in health care. We can't grow organs, we are still dying of hearth diease and diabetes.

Doctors know how important exercise is but keep turning out study after study on the subject instead of figuring out how to get the same effects in a pill. They don't even want to cure cancer, prefering ever more expensive treatments.

You talk Star Trek, at this point I would be impressed with a goddamm hypospray. Tech companies have made it possible to get live video from the other side of the planet, it is about time the rest of the sectors step up.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by krapp on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:08AM (#5291086)
we are still dying of hearth diease and diabetes. We're dying of everything it's possible to die from. Nevertheless far fewer people are dying of heart disease and diabetes than ever.

Doctors know how important exercise is but keep turning out study after study on the subject instead of figuring out how to get the same effects in a pill. Human biology is not subject to Moore's Law. There will never be a pill which encapsulates the effect of getting some exercise.

They don't even want to cure cancer, prefering ever more expensive treatments. Or maybe cancer is complex and those ever more expensive treatments are as close to a cure as we can come right now, providing the very idea of 'a cure for cancer' isn't a misunderstanding of the nature of the problem.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by spikels on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:36AM (#5291164)
I certainly do get the sense that medical progress has stalled. Perhaps all the "low hanging fruit" has been picked and future progress will be much harder.

As the article mentions antibiotics were both a lot easier to develop and had a much bigger impact than genomic research - at least so far. It sure seems like we have made very little overall progress even on targeted diseases, such as cancer, despite vastly increased spending. Spending on both healthcare and healthcare research have roughly doubled in nominal dollars since 2000 with little overall impact.

I understand that, at least in the US, healthcare is fundamentally broken - results have little connection to costs. But is this enough to be holding back the entire economy? Is tech's impact really just smaller than we think? And are other sectors, especially government activites, also lagging behind and thus dragging down overall performance?

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by krapp on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:06AM (#5291240)
Perhaps all the "low hanging fruit" had been picked and future progress will be much harder.

I think that might have something to do with it. Maybe there's only so far you can go in reducing the cost or complexity of some of the problems medicine has to solve now, or maybe the money in research goes first to the treatments which turn the biggest profit for hospitals?

Also I wonder whether the progress in the tech sector isn't just more visible than progress in medicine. It's a lot easier to see the way the iPod has iterated over a decade than, say, to see the way genetic screening has. Though of course medicine and tech are inextricably linked, maybe it would be better to say 'medical tech' versus 'consumer tech.'

And of course there's the issues of religion and politics. If we could say, clone ready-made human organs for transplant, just handwaving away the 'growing them' part, how long would the technology be held back by public and political squeamishness about the process itself? If it requires something akin to industrial, mass-production of living human tissues and stem cells? Even if it saved a million lives tomorrow, it might take decades to pass into a level of public tolerance that makes it politically acceptable to fund the research.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by tsotha on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:40AM (#5291490)
>I certainly do get the sense that medical progress has stalled.

I think that's a mistaken impression. There are hundreds of new drugs you've never heard of because you don't need them. I'm on the other end - I'd be dead already but for a drug invented in the '90s.

The fact that we haven't cured cancer is more because cancer is a really, really tough problem than because there's anything fundamentally wrong with the way we're going about attacking it. We understand cancer at the genetic and biochemical level much better than we did even ten years ago. Understand it well enough, that is, to realize we completely underestimated the depth of the problem. But understanding is progress, even if it doesn't mean cures are imminent.

You can't take what was probably the most productive period in medical history and say "See, everything is broken because the hits aren't coming as fast as they did when sulphas and antibiotics were discovered."

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by nnq on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:27AM (#5291297)
> Perhaps all the "low hanging fruit" had been picked and future progress will be much harder.

Yes, it will be, but "much harder" doesn't have to mean that it will "take more time". Most problems in medicine are starting to look like engineering problems, though at the nano-scale. This is bad, because you can't just "pick fruits", ie. make serendipitous discoveries that have great impact, but it's also good, because in an "engineering field", once you get past a certain point, let's call it the "transistor point", things can start moving very fast result-wise. Unfortunately medicine is very much somewhere at the "steam-engine point", maybe even below it, in a grey zone of slow progress and we don't really know how much this "grey zone" will last. Maybe it's just waiting for the physicists and chemists to come up with cool nanothech, maybe not...

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by TeMPOraL on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:59AM (#5291219)
> There will never be a pill which encapsulates the effect of getting some exercise.

Barring nanotech. Or some offshoot of future muscle regeneration methods. I know it's a nitpick, but I'd personally avoid saying never with regard to technology, especially if we can already imagine how it might work and it doesn't seem to break any laws of physics.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by krapp on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:08AM (#5291241)
Fair enough.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by nnq on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:15AM (#5291264)
> They don't even want to cure cancer

Spread this fud somewhere else, please! Yes, the "cure for cancer" will most likely come in the form of treatments that will more or less "tame" it and manage it like a chronical disease, so you will be able to live decades with it just like you could live with heart disease - and yeas, this will mean shitloads of money for pharmaceutical companies that will sell tons of expensive drugs, but they work better and better and they will keep you alive some day.

And trust me, everyone wants a cure for cancer (I mean a "real" cure, not just something that for 70% of cancers will prolong your life enough so you can still die at 70).

That's because solving the cancer problem is not only about cancer itself! It's actually a door, that once we open we'll be able to stare at the road to "the fountain of life" itself - yeah, it might take a few generations after opening the door to actually reach there, but it will be within reach. Le me explain you: cancer is one big thing, the biggest imho, that prevents advances in areas like genetic therapies and lots of areas of what we call regenerative medicine (because, to put it in simpler terms, nobody will research a therapy that will make you live longer but has 10% chances of giving you a killer cancer - that will mean that statistically, the therapy will not make you live longer). At the same time, understanding cellular regulation at the level needed to actually solve cancer is the same type of understanding needed to slow aging, regenerate organs etc.. Imagine cancer as the dragon guarding the "fountain of youth": once you kill it, sooner or later someone will figure out a way to get to it and use it's water. Everyone wants it killed! After solving cancer, with heart disease remaining the main killer in the developing world, all resources could be dedicated to "growing hearts" for example, or "repairing clogged vessels" and these problems will be solved sooner or later because, at a level, they are actually engineering problems, they don't really require that much new science to solve, just tons of data about cellular regulatory pathways and such - and we'll already have lots of it from the cancer research.

Yeah, the medical professionals or researchers like to keep their feet on the ground and not talk about such "lofty" scify-like ideas - but everybody with some understanding of science and medicine knows things are along these lines...

TL;DR "Solving cancer" is not only about cancer - it's about immor-fucking-tality! (and everyone wants this!)

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by gazrogers on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:21AM (#5291445)
I don't want immortality. And I'd suggest that anyone that does has not properly considered the consequences.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by nnq on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:40AM (#5291491)
That's a pretty "square headed" way to put it :) Ok, some do, some don't. The "has not properly considered the consequences" is a bad argument for anything. You can say that people shouldn't have developed the atom bomb or chemical or bio warfare agents because "they haven't properly considered the consequences". I for one am glad that the atom bomb and other "horrible things" have been invented, weird as this may seem. Your perspective on life and everything really changes when you stop thinking in terms of "right" or "wrong" or of there being a difference between them, and just think in terms of "going further, no matter where this takes you" - I think that even the darkest corners of whatever "hell" you imagine are worth exploring. Just try thinking like this and see what you can see from this pov. - you'll never be the same again, trust me :) Death just limits the possibility of what one can explore and I believe all limits should be destroyed - but if you want the limit, you can have it for yourself, nobody will force you to live forever. The argument would be that one should have a choice of when it happens.

I like Nitzsche's take on immortality: "One has to pay dearly for immortality; one has to die several times while one is still alive." - I would actually love to be able to have this experience, no matter how terrible it seems to some (think about it: your self now is no longer your self from 20 years ago, this older self of you has, in a way, already died... If I'd live to be 1000 years old, an infinity of my older selfs would be already dead and maybe I won't really have any "real memory" of them anymore, except in an "archive" stored somewhere, that I could choose to "browse" if I ever wished to do so. In a way it would be like dying forever, but I would choose this over anything else, at least over "anything" that I've thought of so far.) ...I can't believe I've bothered to answer to this ...no back to work, back to trying to blow up some other "limits" :)

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by gazrogers on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:54AM (#5291531)
If people's lifespan was no longer determined by their body succumbing to the ageing process, they would still be able to die by other means. The population would explode (even more than it currently is) because far fewer people were dying and most people were still having sex and creating more immortals. At some future point (probably not too far away) there would not be enough food on the planet to sustain the lives of all the people living on it. This would lead to mass starvation and/or world wars over land to grow food.

Unless our research into creating immortals also throws up a way for us to photosynthesize, it's really not worth it. Far better, I think, to accept that our time on this earth is limited, and to make the most of what time we have. :-)

[deleted]
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by yesbabyyes on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:52AM (#5291699)
Here you are again! These "barbarians", "they" don't get that choice? Again, have you ever traveled?

From my vantage point, you look like the barbarian.

What's your end game? Feeling powerful?

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sergiosgc on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @07:20AM (#5291961)
Tackle one problem at a time. For one, we may be able to photosynthetise, we just need to create tools for that, and that's what humanity is good at. If not, there are other venues for dealing with overpopulation: population control, out of planet migration... Sci Fi novels have approached this problem for ages.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by gazrogers on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @08:00AM (#5292090)
Even assuming infinite ingenuity in humankind, our lifespan will still be limited by the lifespan of the universe. The second law of thermodynamics is not going to be broken no matter how clever we are. :-)
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by nnq on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @08:56AM (#5292334)
...not resisting the temptation (deleted my other com because it pushed things in a whole wrong direction...): second law of thermodynamics applies to a finite closed system. We know incredibly little about the universe, it may very well be infinite (not just as "time and space" but also as matter and also as complexity of matter - yep I even accept the fact that there may be no fundamental particles, just infinite complexity somehow "simulating" order at our level, and this leads to the fact that we don't really know how little energy do you need to sustain human-type intelligence and it may be very, very little actually) and the "universe" may very well contain "gateways" that inject or subtract energy from our own to other infinite or finite universes - our primitive astronomy neither proves nor disproves anything. Oh, then there's the complicated problem with mathematics and logic - you can't really use the latter as a sound base to explain all of the former according to some so you might have all sorts of interesting consequences like "infinity of logic" or "mathematics" itself - the kind of problems that you can't even dream to tackle when limited to a human lifespan and a human body or brain... The fact is we are incredibly small and stupid at the scale of the universe! The point in living more is the pleasure of discovering more, always more - the pure and beautiful greed and hunger for more and more life, knowledge and power, the hunger that fuels everything.

And the second law of thermodynamics itself... well, we don't have "general" definitions for neither lifer nor consciousness so the truth is we have no freaking idea how something like the second law connects to anything about us. Then again the universe is so big that by the time we think our offspring will have to ask themselves these question in order to survive, they will probably even laugh at our primitive minds and the stupid questions they asked.

EDIT: some intellectual hard drugs for those that find it hard to "believe in the future": http://thisisjasonsilva.com/ - nobody expresses my view better than this kid.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sergiosgc on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @08:24AM (#5292183)
But then the timescale and physical extent of the universe are conditions of such magnitude that tackling the problem is the poster child of premature optimization.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by yesbabyyes on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @05:51AM (#5291692)
Your reasoning is quite weird to me. First you mention the atom bomb as something good, that you are happy with. Then you say that you "should" have a choice of when to die, almost like that's a moral imperative?

Who says you should be able to choose when to die, while not wanting to extend that choice to the inhabitants of Hiroshima?

I'm guessing that you haven't experienced much of a hell. Have you even traveled to places outside of the Western world? I've met Hiroshima survivors, let them tell you about hell.

Yeah, I tried to see things from your POV. I didn't like it -- I felt too much like a Sith lord.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sergiosgc on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @07:16AM (#5291949)
The atom bomb had large positive effects on world conflicts. Suddenly, the threat of mutual annihilation made large wars unattractive. You may thank the atom bomb for the absence of world War III.

If WW3 comes to pass, then WW4 will be fought with sticks and stones (Einstein said it, in different words)

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by yesbabyyes on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @12:06PM (#5293384)
That's definitely one side of it. There are also enormous amounts of bombs which were not too sure what to do with, which worries me.

Btw, I don't interpret Einstein's quote as support of the atom bomb (I'm not saying that you are. Just wanted to make that clear).

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sergiosgc on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:36AM (#5297910)
The Einstein reference was actually to preserve the notion that atom bombs have a hugely negative side, even if they had positive effects so far.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by yesbabyyes on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:53AM (#5297967)
Thanks for the clarification. Yeah, the thing is that it's seventy years since the last time, but there is so much longer time left.

We need to change our ways.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by tomjen3 on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @11:13AM (#5293062)
If it is about immortalitiy then it is even more important that the pharmacutical companies start getting their asses together and start to produce things.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by kiba on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:00AM (#5291066)
They don't even want to cure cancer, prefering ever more expensive treatments.

CEOs and doctors die of cancer each year. You want to tell me that they don't want to cure cancer?

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by scythe on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:57AM (#5291211)
Stop being so pessimistic about cancer. Death rates are dropping across the board. Even truly nasty things like lung cancer are improving:

http://seer.cancer.gov/csr/1975_2009_pops09/browse_csr.php?s... (statistics for all cancers are here)

The way people tell it these days, you'd think we weren't making any progress. But we are -- every year. The path forward looks less like penicillin and more like imatinib.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by chillax on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:37AM (#5291165)
There is good progress into growing organs at least:

http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/science/2013/02/growing-new-...

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:53AM (#5291056)
They don't even want to cure cancer

If it's so easy to cure cancer, why haven't you done it yet?

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by artsrc on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:00AM (#5291069)
Certainly information technology products are advancing faster than some others.

But in terms of health care, life expectancy is still increasing.

For diabetes, I think that blood glucose monitors are more easily available than they were in the past, and I suspect that an implant that regulates glucose better can't be far away.

2 members of my family both had cancer and don't have it anymore due to medical intervention.

I think transport is the one to pick on more.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by danhodgins on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:21AM (#5291443)
The biggest innovation health care needs is not technology. It's psychology - persuading people to incorporate vastly healthier diet and exercise habits into their daily lives.

The first 'innovator' to beat the junk food industrial complex at its own marketing game will change the world.

No CRUD or SAAS app for health care can manipulate people's psychology. What health care really needs is a habit-changing algorithm.

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:19AM (#5291114)
I'm typing this on a thin glass slab, for Christ's sake

It is certainly futuristic. You couldn't have done that twenty years ago. But the point of the article is, as whiz-bangy as posting to the internet from a thin glass slab is, it doesn't appear to have driven real growth (at least not yet).

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by robryan on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:48AM (#5291191)
I would be very surprised if portable access to online anywhere you go hasn't driven growth. At very least we now have the app economy.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:43AM (#5291033)
Not just innovation, things like kickstarter are a part of a fundamental sea change in our economy. Away from the model of the "worker" manning an assembly line in a factory for life and towards a model of individual artists, craftsmen, makers, developers, etc. working independently as freelancers and in very small "indie" outfits. I think that the model of mega-corporations serving as the backbone of the economy is going to transition increasingly toward smaller, more autonomous organizations and individuals which typically work in a cooperative / collaborative fashion on major projects. We're already seeing that pattern play out in the arts, with more and more musicians, comedians, graphic artists, game makers, etc. working on their own.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by victoro on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:02AM (#5291073)
Mentioning "endless SaaS/CRUD" apps in a derogatory fashion and then singing the praises of Kickstarter a sentence later seems a bit hypocritical given that, aside from its large audience, Kickstarter is just a slightly more advanced CRUD app.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by robryan on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @02:49AM (#5291196)
If it enables a new class of innovation and investment who cares how simple or complicated it is.
Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by simonh on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:41AM (#5291331)
I think that was the point.

We're still in the early days of taking full advantage of basic internet technologies, at a whole population/full economy scale. Smartphones and tablets are still a novelty. Major media industries like TV, Cinema and big publishing are still locked up in business models that are becoming painfully outmoded, and have barely begun the painful process of reform that the music industry is only now emerging from.

If simple technologies like basic web apps that have been around for well over a decade are still enabling revolutionary businesses that would previously have been impossible, how can anyone claim that innovation is dead?

Re:Has the ideas machine broken down? by cpressey on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:33AM (#5291478)
I'm struggling to see much innovation that directly addresses fundamental problems. Mostly I see gadgets. Your examples are mostly gadgets.