It's fair insofar as Debian still ships with 2.2 (2.4 in experimental)
I wouldn't call Debian Sta(b)le fair testing. Ubuntu is a slightly better but to be truly fair you should use the latest stable production branch of each program. Or dev if that's what you're testing.
The parent argued that the comparison is unfair, but those are the versions you would get from Debian (apt-get install nginx-light apache2)
Well, the title is "Nginx Vs Apache in AWS", not "Nginx from apt-get Vs Apache from apt-get in AWS". If you can't install the latest stable releases, then don't write a comparison about them.
I don't know what versions are provided by the "amazon Linux AMI" (which the article cites as the image) but I would venture to guess that those are probably the standard (which would make the title apt)
Both are available in the Amazon Linux AMI:
httpd.x86_64 : Apache HTTP Server
httpd24.x86_64 : Apache HTTP Server
Btw, there is also specially tuned Nginx AMI: https://aws.amazon.com/marketplace/pp/B00A04GAG4/
And what version of nginx does Debian ship with? I suspect it classes nginx entirely as experimental!
1.2.6, which incidentally is what was used in the test.
Using Apache 2.2 in worker mode is like comparing 8 year old tech to modern code.
hint: Apache is still about 15-20% slower than nginx even in it's fastest mpm-event mode, but it has many more years of features and modules available - it all depends what your needs are - single site services vs multi-site webhosting
You can always do the best of both worlds by proxying apache with nginx if you need both. Takes one evening to figure out.