News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by mikeash on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:48PM (#5282735)
It all requires inference, though. The legal system just pretends that some inference comes "for free", and some doesn't. You never have "the victim's blood on the defendant's shoe", you have blood which you have reason to believe belongs to the victim on shoes you have reason to believe belong to the defendant. The only actual difference between your two examples is that of degree, i.e. the evidence linking the blood to the victim is much stronger than the evidence linking the fiber to the defendant.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by Dylan16807 on Monday February 25, 2013 @06:53PM (#5282752)
What about when the defense agrees that it is in fact the victim's blood? Many things in a trial are stipulated to be true.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by dllthomas on Monday February 25, 2013 @08:15PM (#5283193)
Interesting question, but doesn't quite seem to be the difference between hard and circumstantial evidence.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by Dylan16807 on Monday February 25, 2013 @09:39PM (#5283557)
Not by itself, but if you use it to discount negligible uncertainty then you can use it as a method to reach 'direct' aka non-circumstantial evidence.
Re:Court of Appeal bans Bayesian probability by dllthomas on Monday February 25, 2013 @11:57PM (#5284072)
I don't know. It seems like the defense can stipulate things that are nonetheless circumstantial evidence. Like, if the defendant acknowledges being in the area at the time, the prosecution no longer needs to deal much with evidence that establishes that, but that's still not "direct evidence" of the crime.

However, the main point of this thread of discussion I think was that even things that legally are considered "direct evidence" - say, testimony of an witness to the crime - do nonetheless involve some inference...