Also:
"Our entire team knew they were doing very little work"
New management cannot simply take the incumbent on-site team members' word for it that it's all the fault of the remote guys. Which is probably part of what's happening at Yahoo.
Also, the words "the entire team knew" are a big red flag. Any team of responsible adults would have confronted the issue already. The fact that they haven't indicates that there is much more going on than just a two rogue remote workers.
You're saying people having a household with kids can't be productive employees?
When at home, if I feel the a distraction looming, it's easy to shut the door. Problem (mostly) solved.
However, I was specifically replying to the context of having distractions (kids, in this case) in gcp's and alistairSH's comments.
For all we know, said employee was paying alimony for them.
Often the companies that do this are the ones with the most liberal work-from-home policies, IMO.
Is this to suggest that he'd been there from the beginning of the project and yet hadn't even checked out the code, let alone committed any work?
Also, if he hadn't been committing any changes at all from the beginning, I would think the manager would be calling him up asking what in the world is going on.
To make things fair, we really wish this blanket policy at Yahoo was put in effect, axed all remote arrangements, and reevaluate their remote arrangements on a case-by-case basis and bring fairness back without individually discriminating.
The reports of 'Yahoo is all against telecommuting' do not tell the entire story and are taking advantage of sensationalist headlining. Telecommuting works when everyone has a certain level of discipline, as it's far too easy to take advantage of and end up being complacent. Places do exist that essentially issue paychecks just because you're an employee in the system. I wouldn't be surprised to know far too many Miltons from Office Space are out there.