Even on HN you'll find people making simple mistakes.
Someone confidant presenting a mathematical argument would be persuasive to a jury, even if their numbers are totally bogus.
> In both case an expert made a mistake or did their job poorly leading to a potentially unfortunate outcome. Why should one be banned and not the other?
People doing the job poorly should be banned. But the nurse case is interesting because poor statistics became self-fulfilling.
"We have some deaths, and this nurse is present when they happen, and so they are all suspicious", becomes "all the deaths that happen when this nurse is working are suspicious, and the deaths that don't happen when this nurse is working are not suspicious". And that sloppy thinking gets turned into "probability is 1 in a gajillion that these happen normally by chance."
>"We have some deaths, and this nurse is present when they happen, and so they are all suspicious", becomes "all the deaths that happen when this nurse is working are suspicious, and the deaths that don't happen when this nurse is working are not suspicious". And that sloppy thinking gets turned into "probability is 1 in a gajillion that these happen normally by chance."
Investigators have been known to be unduly influenced by pretty much any kind of evidence imaginable and then all further evidence is construed to support the original assumption/assertion. I need a more concrete difference or divider to promote other methods above statistics.
A different way of phrasing this is that investigators have been known to incorrectly apply even standard tools that they've been explicitly trained in.
> I need a more concrete difference or divider to promote other methods above statistics.
If by "promote" you mean that we should try to increase the statistical literacy of lawyers, police, judges, and the general public, than hells yeah. But encouraging armchair statisticians to try to determine causality and guilt from badly-collected observational data that's analyzed by financially-invested parties...? In the highest stakes setting we have? Really?
That is why both the defense and the prosecutor can bring forth their own expert witnesses.
How is this case different?
Additionally I'd guess most times if you make a significant error during an autopsy, you are aware of it. Whereas it's much more difficult to know whether you made an error in your statistical analysis or not.
That was impressions from remember articles where expertise in the above three fields was tested independently and experts were found to lack predictive power. I would have to search for that articles again if I wanted to provide a reference however I am working from memory.
Why should I trust them less for stats? Math does hold a honorary position in society while also being often being disliked(USA here) I will have to think about weather that is enough to single stats out from the others.
For non-experts in forensics vs statistics can an average jury member make better decisions about expert level results in forensics compared to statistics/math? It is possible that statistics and math are just less common knowledge and most jury members would then be able to discerne finner differences in forensics then compared to statistics. If this is the case though there is nothing incorrect about the tool, statistis which seems to be implied in the original article, and it is just a lack of common understand that in theory if correct would allow for a new tool to be used.
How is this different then an expert on autopsies incorrectly does the job which leads to a potential false conclusion.
In both case an expert made a mistake or did their job poorly leading to a potentially unfortunate outcome. Why should one be banned and not the other?