News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to start working on side projects by smoyer on Sunday February 24, 2013 @04:41PM (#5276031)
The last time I interviewed a candidate for a web development position, he could only list the projects he completed for his master's degree (one might have been for his BSCS). I'm almost 50 and know far more about current technologies than he did, plus I have a family (to spend time with) and several of my own side projects (not to mention a start-up).

If you're not passionate enough about programming to have a side project (or six), please just get out of the profession. Or maybe become a mediocre manager (if you think you're done learning when you leave school behind, you'll have no choice).

I agree that high-technology businesses were the only organizations that maintained (or even grew) employment during the recession but ... that doesn't mean you deserve one of those jobs. If you love it enough to make it your hobby, you can earn a good living at software development without being a flash-in-the-pan.

Re:How to start working on side projects by snogglethorpe on Sunday February 24, 2013 @05:45PM (#5276257)
While I think programmers for whom programming is a "passion" (and often have lots of side projects and involvement in programming generally outside their work) can be among the best, I've also met tons of excellent programmers who approached it mostly as a profession and weren't really involved much outside of that. I've also met some really awful programmers who were "passionate" about it as a hobby.

Passion outside of work is neither necessary nor sufficient.

[I, personally, am of the "passion" sort. I find that this attribute can be both an (obvious) help but oddly, also sometimes a hindrance, as I can get too personally involved in things, and sometimes that clouds my judgment.]

Re:How to start working on side projects by jmspring on Sunday February 24, 2013 @07:17PM (#5276610)
Passion doesn't need to be about programming. Passion and curiosity can be targeted at other areas.

The one type of candidate that I will almost always turn down when interviewing is the one that can't answer the simple question of "Tell me a story about something you enjoy and why. It could be a project you worked on, an outside hobby, anything." We all have our different strengths and interests, but the people I've found that I work with the best can talk about something they enjoy.

As for myself, I've spent many years working in the industry. Sometimes I take on side projects just to noodle around, sometimes I take on consulting projects to learn something new (or help out a friend). Given my drothers, I lean towards non-programming pursuits these days -- cooking, gardening, mountain biking. In their own way, all stimulating and, at the same time, allow my mind to relax away from the computer.

Re:How to start working on side projects by snogglethorpe on Sunday February 24, 2013 @08:31PM (#5276817)
> Passion doesn't need to be about programming. Passion and curiosity can be targeted at other areas.

Of course. However I think this particular thread is about programmers who are passionate about programming, and how that relates to their ability as programmers... :]

[AFAICT, passion in general is good for mental health, and I'd even wager it's correlated with intelligence. It's indeed a good thing to have, but passion in general won't have quite the same effect on one's profession as passion about that thing in particular will have...]

Re:How to start working on side projects by MakeUsersWant on Monday February 25, 2013 @05:14AM (#5278166)
<it>programmers for whom programming is a "passion"</it>

Beware of turning your passionate hobby into your job. It will become a chore. Also, you won't have a hobby anymore that keeps you from burning out.

(Source: Personal experience. I am an academic.)

Re:How to start working on side projects by snogglethorpe on Monday February 25, 2013 @05:17PM (#5282246)
> Beware of turning your passionate hobby into your job. It will become a chore

YMMV... :]

This often doesn't seem to happen with programming, perhaps simply because it's a fairly broad field.

Re:How to start working on side projects by slurgfest on Sunday February 24, 2013 @06:20PM (#5276405)
What made the passionate programmers awful?
Re:How to start working on side projects by damoncali on Sunday February 24, 2013 @09:42PM (#5277022)
Lack of focus and addiction to mastery the new and shiny can really hamper a passionate programmer's ability to produce.
Re:How to start working on side projects by kamaal on Sunday February 24, 2013 @11:49PM (#5277367)
Because for many people, they are confused between their least area of incompetence and passion. This happens with 99.99% of the people, truly passionate people are exceedingly rare.
Re:How to start working on side projects by snogglethorpe on Sunday February 24, 2013 @08:44PM (#5276839)
No one particular thing... the only point is that passion isn't enough to make you a good programmer (or good anything I suppose).
Re:How to start working on side projects by rdouble on Sunday February 24, 2013 @04:46PM (#5276051)
This is a common refrain, but the best programmers I've worked with do not have any evidence that they work on side projects.
Re:How to start working on side projects by jaegerpicker on Sunday February 24, 2013 @05:19PM (#5276175)
That is exactly the opposite of my experience in every case I can think of all of the very best that I've worked with had many side projects. In fact some of the most exciting Main Projects have started as side projects of the Great programmers I've worked with.
Re:How to start working on side projects by chimi on Sunday February 24, 2013 @05:37PM (#5276242)
And you have provided no evidence that the best programmers you've worked with aren't actually below average programmers.
Re:How to start working on side projects by wam on Sunday February 24, 2013 @06:07PM (#5276342)
Why does that matter?
Re:How to start working on side projects by rhizome on Sunday February 24, 2013 @10:21PM (#5277150)
Because the inverse would also have to be true: programmers with open source projects are worse than the programmers rdouble is describing.
Re:How to start working on side projects by wam on Monday February 25, 2013 @12:18AM (#5277425)
Is that the inverse? Would all programmers with side projects necessarily be worse than the programmers rdouble knows who don't have side projects?
Re:How to start working on side projects by twmb on Sunday February 24, 2013 @06:39PM (#5276475)
No, please. I have many issues with this, coming from the applicant's perspective.

He could have taken his masters program as his full time hobby. There is a reason he went to masters. He loved what he was studying. It only makes sense for all projects for him to work on are ones that are for the masters program. caveat: I believe this holds more-so for Ph.D. people than masters, as masters is still half class based. However, masters students have research projects that take up the other half of their time.

Or, he could have had consistently heavy course loads. The reason that many famous entrepreneurs drop out is because they do not have enough time to do both school and their amazing side project (note, their one amazing side project). This is rare.

Have you considered that >90% of CS graduates are not going to be superstar programmers? At my University, I do not know of any other students doing their own side projects, outside of research projects with professors (this isn't to say I'm the only one, but given what I know, I'd be willing to bet there are fewer than 5 doing something cool).

One of my master theories is that I do need an online presence codewise and blogwise to demonstrate my competence and my passion for building cool stuff. However, to start building projects on GitHub or fixing bugs, you need a pretty descent level of competence. Universities such as mine first immerse you in Java, teach some theoretical CS (algorithms, ...), then have a class on various programming languages then have the upper division courses on C or C++. If you notice, most super cool open source projects these days revolve around C++ at a level that we don't learn, JavaScript, a language that is booming on popularity now but is only touched on in Universities, and Python, which is used in some Universities (those fortunate people) instead of Java. I doubt JavaScript will be seriously taught in Universities for many years. Maybe the Ivy's will have it down, but not everybody goes there. From this we can draw the conclusion that most students wont have the competence to commit to open source projects unless they go off and seriously learn on their own time. Students like that may only build simple projects for themselves and not put it up for show (it's so simple, surely somebody has better functionality somewhere, right?). Why blog? Students like that have nothing profound to talk about.

One of my issues with the frequenters of hacker news is that every programmer expects everybody else to be at least as competent as they are. Not everybody has as high of a drive to code nonstop. I don't. After classes, after oodles of homework and self-teaching the 90% they didn't teach me in class, I want to read books. I enjoy reading. I enjoy hanging out with my friends.

I, unlike most of my fellow students, have realized that dream jobs have ridiculous expectations. I can see why, too: if everybody wants the job, and they are doing something legitimately cool, then it's only reasonable they should have the pick of the litter. However, is your job a dream job? I hate seeing every single application say "two years of experience required" or five. I've been fortunate enough to get internships for the past two summers. Is every graduate expected to take some bullshit big biz job for 2 years, learning very little and becoming embittered by the industry? This is worthless. Some enjoy it, I don't. It'd be better for small companies to take on a promising looking graduate at a slightly less pay and have them expand their knowledge at the company.

Yes, I deserve your job. I'm more than competent enough for it. If I don't have the knowledge you need now, I would be able to learn it in depth within two weeks (give me the full days to learn it). I love what I'm doing, but I love other things too. Having other hobbies besides coding is healthy. Just because you know all the current buzzwords (node, django, backbone, Go, ?) does not mean you are a better coder and does not mean another person without this knowledge is worthless.

Re:How to start working on side projects by smoyer on Sunday February 24, 2013 @09:04PM (#5276896)
Touche (pretend it's got an accent) ... and somehow I suspect we wouldn't have to drag your capabilities out of you during an interview. You felt strongly enough to write a short essay, but the line that caught my eye is "self-teaching the 90% they didn't teach me in class". That's exactly why I look for side projects - because most of us use them (in part) as a means to learn something we think might be of value. And we aren't always right, but sometimes learning what's not worthwhile is also worthwhile.

So when do you graduate? Where do you want to live when you're done with college? What kind of position do you want? So how about zero years of experience for someone that's proven to be intellectually curious? What do you want your life to look like in ten years? You've piqued my interest ... care to talk?

Re:How to start working on side projects by city41 on Sunday February 24, 2013 @10:01PM (#5277086)
I have to admit I cringe a little when I see a recent college grad who is literally only aware of what he learned in his classes. I've been a developer now for 12 years and have interacted with college grads frequently. I can honestly say, the grads who never programmed until CS 101, and only ever programmed for their classes are almost always inferior to their counterparts who explored, experimented and maintained a genuine curiosity of what's out there. Software changes so rapidly, and it always will. You simply must keep abreast of it, at least a little bit. For sure maintain other hobbies and balance your life, but this industry does demand a bit more just by its nature.
Re:How to start working on side projects by pseut on Sunday February 24, 2013 @10:10PM (#5277114)
> Have you considered that >90% of CS graduates are not going to be superstar programmers? At my University, I do not know of any other students doing their own side projects, outside of research projects with professors (this isn't to say I'm the only one, but given what I know, I'd be willing to bet there are fewer than 5 doing something cool).

Surely you realize that the point of these questions is to try to weed out that 90% as much as possible. A potential superstar coming out of college doesn't cost that much more in salary, so you want to get one if you can (another way to put it: hiring mediocre programmers won't save you money overall). You may see a bias on hacker news because people here are disproportionately working on (subjectively) interesting projects, so they think they can get potential superstars on board.

You may like this pg essay if you haven't read it: http://www.paulgraham.com/mit.html

Btw, I'd encourage you to apply to those jobs anyway with a candid cover letter. You made a good impression here. But your concerns here are also a reason to take networking seriously and go to conferences, departmental seminars, local user groups etc. You have to know people before they can know you're good (and yes, I'm aware of the inappropriatness of replying to your comment with "immerse yourself EVEN MORE!" The trick is to do it strategically so it's not any more time overall).

Edit: "these questions" = asking about side projects