News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by _delirium on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:23PM (#5272079)
As an internet user, retargeting is honestly one of my #1 targets. I find it super-creepy that some websites show me things based on other websites I visit, and I want a way to stop it.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by chewxy on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:27PM (#5272093)
Why? You visit say... kogan.com.au, they know what fridges you look at. That's intent to buy. You're cookied as #12412214. In the backend, that cookie ID is labeled as FridgeLover.

The next website you go to that has an ad slot, when the ad call is made, your anonymized information is submitted, and if the advertiser wins the bid, the advertiser shows you ads of fridges, because the advertiser remembers that cookie ID 12412214 is a FridgeLover.

It's anonymous (though significant efforts can be expended for less anonymity). And most importantly, it helps users recall products they've seen.

It is relevant to the user (fun bits: buy retargeted ads on competitor sites!)

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by ricardobeat on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:34PM (#5272119)
"It's relevant" is not a good excuse. Using pieces of my email (like google) or my own friends (like facebook) is the result of that line of thought and extremely invasive and creepy.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by melvinram on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:51PM (#5272172)
"It's relevant" is the ultimate "excuse" to show an ad.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by brokenrecord on Sunday February 24, 2013 @05:45AM (#5273763)
You seem like that lobbyist from Thank you for smoking... Sorry it's just the feeling I got.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by melvinram on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:25PM (#5272083)
Would you rather see ads for things that are completely irrelevant? Relevance requires data.

Edit: I do believe the user should have more control over what companies are allowed to retarget with an easy opt out mechanism implemented by every ad network as well as a way to limit the frequency. I've experience companies going WAY overboard on their retargeting and it feels stalker-ish.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by _delirium on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:26PM (#5272087)
I'd like things relevant to the site I'm currently visiting, not based on an attempt to construct a personalized profile of me specifically. The former is reasonable contextual advertising (you visit a sci-fi site, you get ads for sci-fi books), while the latter starts feeling like someone compiling an FBI file on my preferences.

Apart from the creepiness, it also helps me mentally compartmentalize and context-switch better, when the ads on a site are relevant to the site, rather than to some other site I may have visited in the past which is not what I'm currently trying to concentrate on. Now maybe that's the point: to throw me off my current train of thought by reminding me of some previous train of thought. I was previously planning a trip, but now I'm trying to research something else and trying not to think about that trip I have to plan, so I can get something else done in the next hour. But the advertiser thinks maybe reminding me of that trip would be a good idea, which is maybe even statistically justified, because I do have to plan it in the next week, and a significant amount of money will be spent. But that's so mentally invasive that it's what will probably drive me to finally install AdBlock.

It's like having your own personal Troll Clippy following you around whispering "oh interesting research, but remember that trip you have to plan? LOL I knew you would!" To get things done in a modern workplace that has pervasive use of the internet and pervasive distractions, you have to block out things that are relevant to your interests but not to the current task. And retargeting does not help with that.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by melvinram on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:48PM (#5272165)
I see your point but it's hardly an effective usage of resources.

In my experience, retargeting ads produce higher CTRs than generic ads. This means that a publisher is able to derive 2-10x more revenue from the same ad space if they used retargeting ads instead of contextual ads.

I agree that some level of self-regulation is in order. Users should have a way to control the level of retargeting they experience and from whom, but to remove the entire mechanism that enables retargeting will only hurt the web because ROI on ad dollars will be lower. Lower ROI = less being spent on online advertising. Less spent on ads = less revenue for publishers. Less revenue for publishers = less investment from publisher to drive more revenue, which will likely mean lower quantity and quality of content created.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by alan_cx on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:48PM (#5272162)
In short, yes. It never bothered me that TV didnt target me. Same on the web.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by melvinram on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:57PM (#5272197)
It may not bother you but it does bother most of America. They use DVRs and skips ads whenever possible.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by ajdecon on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:33PM (#5272313)
The lack of relevance isn't what bothers them. It's the fact that the ads are not the show they intended to watch. And in fact interrupts it.

If you could make all the ads I saw on TV perfectly relevant, I would still fast forward. Because I would like to get back to the show, OK?

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by majormajor on Saturday February 23, 2013 @09:51PM (#5272553)
DVR usage isn't actually that prevalent, even after a decade. Generally the preference is to watch stuff live, and live with the ads. Which is a big part of why the ground hasn't fallen out from under broadcasters like it did with newspapers, and TV ads are still the priciest (and arguably most effective, commanding your attention in a way that banner ads cannot) form of ads.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by RobAtticus on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:21PM (#5272280)
Or, people prefer to see no ads at all because they are more interested in the show they are watching than any ad, relevant or not.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by zxtang on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:16PM (#5272266)
Many ad networks[1] do already provide an opt out mechanism. You look for a blue icon[2] in the corner of the ad, which if you click it should take you to an opt out page.

I dug a bit further, and also found this: http://www.aboutads.info/choices/ which purports to allow you to opt out from any or all of the participating companies from that page.

[1]: http://www.aboutads.info/participating [2]: http://www.aboutads.info/sites/default/files/page_img/icon_e...

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by cpeterso on Saturday February 23, 2013 @11:44PM (#5272875)
There is a Firefox addon called "Beef Taco" that inserts 450+ known opt-out cookies into Firefox's cookie jar:

https://github.com/jmhobbs/beef-taco

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by splicer on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:18PM (#5272274)
> Would you rather see ads for things that are completely irrelevant?

Yes. For instance, I don't mind seeing pizza commercials because I don't like cheese.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by brugidou on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:32PM (#5272110)
why is that creepy? Both websites are related through a retargeter. One sends the data over to the other. It's just like they were the same websites or same corporation. If you don't like this then you can avoid theses websites that sell/buy your information. Although that's a good chunk of the Internet. Just make sure you send private information to trusted sites only.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by ricardobeat on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:36PM (#5272125)
If you don't like being filmed in public and face-tracked everywhere you go, just don't ever leave home. Can you picture yourself saying that in 10 years?
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by brugidou on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:53PM (#5272183)
You are not identifiable from an ad cookie AFAIK and the country I live in has laws preventing companies to abuse in collecting personal data (like IP address)

This is far from being on video. And a lot of places have cameras now in addition to people with phones and maybe Google Glass in the future?

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by ricardobeat on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:07PM (#5272231)
The face tracking could work anonymously too, and we'd have laws "preventing abuse". When you enter a shop the sales girl already knows exactly what you want because you looked at it on a competitor's store. Video is just a means. It's exactly like retargeting, just using different data sources; we can't let this become acceptable.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by ihsw on Saturday February 23, 2013 @07:36PM (#5272122)
Because it's not opt-in and there's no way to opt-out.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by maxerickson on Saturday February 23, 2013 @08:11PM (#5272246)
It's more correct to say that the ways to opt out are esoteric.

Something like RequestPolicy allows the user to opt out of everything.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by eksith on Saturday February 23, 2013 @09:37PM (#5272506)

  It's more correct to say that the ways to opt out are esoteric.
And it's also disingenuous. If the default is opt-in (and that's never OK, regardless of your rationalisations) and opt-out is hidden somewhere on the 8th subpage of a company you've never heard of or will likely never know about without view-source. I can count on one finger the number of times I've seen the source of a targetted ad... the middle one.

Self-governance does not work when the power of technology is asymmetric. Whether it's cookies, spam or nuclear weapons, deterrence is the only effective solution.

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by maxerickson on Saturday February 23, 2013 @10:31PM (#5272655)
You are incorrectly pigeonholing me here.
Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by majormajor on Saturday February 23, 2013 @09:53PM (#5272562)
One big creepy part is that people share computers. Used to be that someone could try to dig through your history if they wanted to (but most people didn't), but now some of your history gets pushed right to them.

I'm looking at you, Amazon banner ads that feature products I browsed recently. (This is lots of fun because I often use Amazon solely to get info on a product that I may have no intention at all of purchasing.)

Re:Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies by X-Istence on Sunday February 24, 2013 @01:13AM (#5273105)
No Amazon I am not interesting a my little pony book, a vibrating pink dildo or a 55 gallon drum of lube.

I was visiting those items because I was linked to them due to people posting funny comments on the items, I have absolutely no interest in them.

Although, at some level I do find the way that Amazon does their targeting can be fairly accurate.