I have to confess: my initial reaction was "isn't this kind of self-explanatory" and "dude, if you want to know what rethinkdb is, look at their damned website" or even the dreaded, and admittedly elitist "if you have to ask, its not targeted at you." However, reading your response, I am reminded that I can be a smug asshole, and I'm going to remember how you responded for the day I release something to the public.
Your response, on top of the fact that I've already examined, installed, and liked your product, adds even more to my confidence that you guys are creating a great longer term product.
In studying a philosopher, the right attitude is neither reverence nor contempt, but first a kind of hypothetical sympathy, until it is possible to know what it feels like to believe in his theories, and only then a revival of the critical attitude, which should resemble, as far as possible, the state of mind of a person abandoning opinions which he hitherto held. Contempt interferes with the first part of this process, and reverence with the second.
This helped me a lot, hope it helps you too!
I'd recommend checking out TryRuby from Code School to get a better feel for interactivity in a tutorial. It takes you all the way from "That thing over there is an interactive prompt you are going to type things into."
Writing the code out yourself is extremely helpful for learning. Folks learn better by writing down what they are trying to understand while absorbing the information; the same is true for programming.
Edit: I totally see the value of the "hack it out yourself" flow he discusses though, and agree that making people do it themselves would be a more likely to be useful learning experience.
That said, it is also my opinion that the ORM syntax needs a bit of love, for all the reasons stated above. Especially .run() feels a bit weird, can you make queries lazy (like Django's QuerySets, which only run when evaluated)?
P.S. If the rest of the RethinkDB team are as good at DOTA 2 as Marc is, I want to play with you too!
In a way queries are lazy. You can write a query and without calling `run` on it nothing happens. The whole chained ops are executed at once when `run` is called.
> That said, it is also my opinion that the ORM syntax needs a bit of love, for all the reasons stated above.
This is not an "ORM" per se. It's a query API or data manipulation language. The next version will bring a few improvements to it.
That's not lazy, though, that's just doing nothing :P Lazy would be not running anything until you evaluated the last link in the chain, so, in Django:
model = User.objects
model = model.filter(name="Alex")
model = model.filter(hero="Dazzle")
model = model.filter(abandons<2)
list(model)
and the query would only be executed when wanting to turn the QuerySet into a list.I think your examples would also be a bit clearer if you forewent the r.db("test") step and just did:
db = r.db("test")
db.query("foo").bar().run()
which is more explicit.thanks,
alex @ rethinkdb
I actually think strict is better here, but that's a different discussion altogether :)
I don't see how it wouldn't be optimal, since lazy evaluation is a superset of eager evaluation (you can invoke it whenever you want).
To answer your questions here:
> what is r?
It's a module where all the RethinkDB operations are defined. The tutorial is running the same JavaScript driver code as you'd run if you connected to C++ RethinkDB server from node.js, which is why you have to start with `r`.
> What does db() do?
It refers to a database named 'test'. This is where you're creating the table
> Is there a test database somewhere?
Yes. It's set up by default at the beginning.
> Why do I have to call run() when there's a button saying "Run this query" do you sometimes not run() things?
Because you can type multiple queries in the text box. Every time you end a query with `.run()`, that's when it goes to the server and gets executed there. We've been talking about not having people type `.run` for a single query, but it's a bit difficult to solve.
> What happened to r.db('test') that I needed to use? Is r now that database?
If you omit r.db() at the beginning of the query, it picks a default one (which is 'test'). It's the same as you'd do in MySQL.
> Why didn't I just do r.tableCreate('tv_shows') before?
We thought allowing tableCreate in a default database allows people to make mistakes too easily, so we disallowed it. It confuses people, so we'll add it back. Sorry for confusion.