Re:The babies who nap in sub-zero temperatures
by ycombobreaker on Friday February 22, 2013 @02:48PM
(#5266306)
I used to go on camping trips regularly. I always found that I woke up exceptionally well-rested in a tent. I attribute that to a combination of the fresh air, the possibility of a gentle breeze, and the difference of outdoor sounds vs. a 60Hz hum in the house. And it's not about sleep length, either; I would always wake up earlier in a tent than in my bed.
I think the phenomenon is worthy of more in-depth scientific experimentation, but I wouldn't ignore my own experience; even with no control group and a sample size of one.
Re:The babies who nap in sub-zero temperatures
by andreer on Friday February 22, 2013 @02:29PM
(#5266196)
Both my kids have slept outside, also in temperatures down to -10C. I don't know whether they slept better, but they certainly slept for longer - giving me more time to get other things done. I suspect thats probably the real reason for it!
The article cites a survey of parents who say their kids nap better outdoors, (with a broken link), but surveys are far less convincing than experiments. In this case, parents should not use this survey as a reason to have their kids nap outside, because the survey is just a reflection of their own opinions. Following it would be like eating their own dog food.
As for more scientific evidence, according to the article "Paediatrician Margareta Blennow says reports from the Swedish Environmental protection agency show conflicting results."
So from the article, it doesn't appear that there is substantial scientific evidence that sleeping outdoors is any better for the children. Why do parents continue to do so anyway? I think it's just a cultural thing. I think many cultures have basically random opinions along the lines of "Doing X is better for your health". As long as X isn't actually very bad for you, people will continue to do X despite the lack of evidence that it's actually good for you.