News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by lucb1e on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:22AM (#5256166)
A slightly extended version of my comment on the accepted answer:

I disagree on almost everything. On mobile phones you don't have a >17" screen to place a power button in an often-used menu somewhere, and the power button is like 5cm away. On a desktop this is usually not the case. As you said, you need to power a device on in a physical way because software is not running, but when powering off you can use either software or hardware buttons. You've been using that mouse and keyboard the whole time that you were working with it, why turn back to other hardware to turn it off?

For tablets, and even laptops to an extent, Windows 8 makes a lot of sense. The power button is close, or you can close the lid. For desktop PCs, not so much.

Lastly, I think of my phone or mobile device as always-on because it needs to be always on. I don't turn my ears off when I'm not using them either. My 500 Watt pc does not always need to be on or sleeping (hibernate at most). Nor does my family's tablet; we always power it off entirely. Conserves a lot of battery power and lifespan.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:09AM (#5256346)
>My 500 Watt pc does not always need to be on or sleeping (hibernate at most).

I question how much that will actually save you. A turned-off PC drains somewhere under a watt, and a PC in sleep mode also drains... somewhere under a watt. Sure, you might not want to spend the 20-50 watts it takes to keep a PC fully powered and idling, but sleep mode is very efficient.

For a tablet it makes sense, since those tend to use a 'sleep' mode that's more of a deep idle, where wifi and background processes are still powered.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by acqq on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:18AM (#5256380)
You're wrong when you say "a PC in sleep mode also drains somewhere under a watt." Unless you consider as the only "desktop" to be Mac mini, you've never tried to measure the power consumption of the desktop yourself. Otherwise, you'd know that a lot of desktops take a lot of power when sleeping, on average 20 Watts, but even up to 80:

http://standby.lbl.gov/summary-table.html

The above table used 52 computers to make the statistics: the average was 21 Watts.

Do you have a desktop? Plug it in a power meter, you'd be surprised. My desktop draws more than 10 Watts when powered off. That's why I use the hard power switch on the back and prefer a notebook.

When we're there, look at the "off power" of the set-top boxes. Horrible.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:42AM (#5256471)
I dunno, I used this source http://www.upenn.edu/computing/provider/docs/hardware/poweru...

Something is wrong with a computer using 20 watts in sleep mode. Is there a list of the actual models there? I would want to see how old they are.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by acqq on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:56AM (#5256528)
You are quoting the extreme, a table with iMacs and the new very low power Dells. Measure yourself something that's not a Mac or a latest low power desktop. And make sure you're really measuring the sleep mode, not the hibernation.

I also once believed what you believe, but then I took the meter and measured the devices around me. It fits the table I quote -- my set-top box also draws 30 Watts when "off."

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @05:04AM (#5256560)
I'm looking for data that actually names models. I found some for bog-standard pentium 4 dells, and they use 3 watts.

Honestly it probably comes down to having a not-terrible power supply.

Edit: how about a random HP, 1.65 watts http://reviews.cnet.com/desktops/hp-pavilion-p7-1070t/4505-3...

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by stinos on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:36AM (#5256203)
that last part where you make a coparision with your ears makes it sound like you consider a phone as some sort of extension of your body :] well, it's clearly about personal preference. I for instance have no desire to leave my phone always on, not only because it "Conserves a lot of battery power and lifespan" but also becasue sometimes I like to not being bothered at all.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by RyanZAG on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:13AM (#5256366)
you consider a phone as some sort of extension of your body

I'm not the OP, but I'd say I pretty much do! It's only going to get even worse with things like Google Glass. Can't wait.