Moving to electric makes you reliant on current means of energy production, but to move to cleaner tech you replace 100 power plants instead of 10,000,000 cars.
Not to mention, solar is rapidly approaching the point where it will be cheaper than coal, so it's only a matter of time before coal will start getting phased out anyway.
I'm pretty sure it's the opposite. Do you have a particular study/calculation in mind?
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/15/automobiles/how-green-are-...
Secondly, the electrical grid acts like a technology buffer. In the future, those coal plants can be replaced by water, wind, solar or something else, without changing the grid or the vehicle charging network.
There's no environmental case for EV-only cars, unless you are powering the grid with solar, wind, or hydro.
Sure, but that's a different metric than the OP was asking about and talks about one particular method of mining. On the specific question of system efficiency -- mechanical output divided by heat content input ("well to wheels") -- it is indeed generally right that coal electricity + transmission/battery losses still has a higher efficiency than everyone burning gas in their own poorly-maintained vehicle.
>There's no environmental case for EV-only cars, unless you are powering the grid with solar, wind, or hydro.
If you make the question black-and-white, perhaps. But hopefully we can recognize that e.g. oil-derived electricity powering cars is a step up from millions of aging ICEs using that oil in refined form;
- and that natural gas-generated electricity is a step up from that
- and that it's easier to change the (ultimate) power source on an electric car than a gas-powered one, which has a very "picky" engine.
Trucking hydrocarbons around to thousands of endpoints doesn't actually compare favorably to line loss.
Plus the electric cars can only buy renewable energy, it would nullify the point of selling CO2 quotas if they used fossil fuel to produce that energy ;)
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/estonia/electricity-producti...