News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Estonia becomes the first to open a nationwide electric v... by SilasX on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @04:04PM (#5253352)
>Not even close. First of all, mining and burning coal is far worse for the environment than oil. Mining is destructive, impacts water tables, ...

Sure, but that's a different metric than the OP was asking about and talks about one particular method of mining. On the specific question of system efficiency -- mechanical output divided by heat content input ("well to wheels") -- it is indeed generally right that coal electricity + transmission/battery losses still has a higher efficiency than everyone burning gas in their own poorly-maintained vehicle.

>There's no environmental case for EV-only cars, unless you are powering the grid with solar, wind, or hydro.

If you make the question black-and-white, perhaps. But hopefully we can recognize that e.g. oil-derived electricity powering cars is a step up from millions of aging ICEs using that oil in refined form;

- and that natural gas-generated electricity is a step up from that

- and that it's easier to change the (ultimate) power source on an electric car than a gas-powered one, which has a very "picky" engine.

There are no comments on this comment yet.