Saying nice, comforting things to them (while they fail and people lose their jobs) would be a greater injustice than being honest and frank. I bet no one else has ever spoken that directly about the matter. Sometimes, that's precisely what is needed.
Another thing that bugs me is the hypocritical stance of suing Chinese tire manufacturers and then turning around and manufacturing in China.
If you do something like this - it's a pretty drastic departure from good form - there ought to be a reason for it, some kind of upside to balance the obvious downsides.
Workers in France work for three hours, eat for two and talk for another three? Really?
Producing in France is only expensive because of the labour costs? Or is there maybe also that pesky environmental controls issue?
Europe has very low restrictions on imports, because it tries to implement free market as purely as possible. Many voices in France say we must be more aggressive on importation taxes, and that even US has a more protected market than us. After all, no west country can beat China in production costs.
Problem is, those voices are mostly from nationalist and xenophobic parties. Even current left wing french government would not touch total free market.
Now, there is the insult. Saying french workers work 3 hours a day is totally stupid. Normal work day is 8 hours for private sector, and 7 hours for public sector (but most public sector workers work 8 hours and then take a day off to compensate over worked days). The reason because average hours per day is low (see other comments) is because unemployment is high, so many people accept part time jobs and short term jobs.
Now, combine the cynical stance "we can produce cheap products in China and sell them to you with no penalties" and the insult, and you've got perfect food for nationalist parties. Once again.
He didn't say workers came to the factory for 3 hours then left. What he said was that out of the 7 hours of a work day, 1 is lost in breaks and lunch, 3 are spent chatting instead of working and there's only 3 ours of actual work being done.
If you read the comments on the article the vast majority actually support what that CEO says and disapprove the actions of the CGT.
I could see why you'd viscerally feel that way, but if the tariffs that are being applied in the US aren't also being applied in other countries (Europe, for example) then he is unable to compete with Chinese tires without creating a factory there to get the same subsidies.
>Wow, what a total jerk. [...] >When you don't have to insult someone it is probably better not to. //
Also is there any basis for this:
>I'd better move my money out before his loud mouth causes him to lose business. //
He sounds like a no nonsense kinda guy that is getting annoyed that people keep asking him to intervene and save tire plants without letting him address the issues that would allow the plants to be saved?
He's been given an opportunity, if he sees any bread in it he should take it, if not politely refuse. Just so the next time there is an opportunity he's still on the 'call' list.
I can see 0 upside to acting like this, and I'm known as pretty direct myself. I'd never insult a government official - in writing, no less - unless it served a purpose and I can't find any purpose here, just insults for insults sake and direct proof of acting on incorrect information. Keep in mind that France has a huge domestic tire manufacturer that negates pretty much everything mr. Titan says here. If he's not happy with the factory operation, it's equipment or its workforce then it's time to either negotiate or to bow out with some grace.
Shooting yourself in the foot like this is not the way business is done, especially not in France where they value propriety in business as much as anywhere else on the planet. Sure there may be insurmountable downsides but given an opportunity you can simply say 'pass', no need to spit the person giving you the opportunity in the face.
Hello dear French Person,
We have taken your offer under consideration and have decided we are not interested.
Experience has taught us that we can produce cheaper in Asia which is why we are not going to set up a manufacturing base in Europe.
best regards,
x
No fake smile, not an ass.Je vous prie de bien vouloir agréer, Monsieur, l'expression de mes honnêtes et respectueuses salutations.
When you've been insulted you can insult back by throwing rotten fish or you can insult back by being very explicitly correct and I sense this is some slight variation of that. Maybe someone who is more experienced in French can confirm or deny that.
That's actually what the minister did in his reply.
When you don't have to insult someone it is probably better not to. Because those pesky French just might publish your less than elegant letters, your stockholders might read those letters and could very well think: "This guy runs the company I invest in? I'd better move my money out before his loud mouth causes him to lose business.".
Stockholders are fickle, and some stockholders actually care about more than just the numbers (of course, that is a minority).
Also, if you communicate you negative interest when a foreign representative has thought to offer you a chance at some deal you may want to think of the future. Effectively you are saying 'if you are so kind as to think of me I will repay you with trash'. That will likely not be repeated again and likely the effect will be much further spread than just this one country and just this one official.
That bulk deal for Tires for all the vehicles of the French armed forces (Michelin?), the police force or their connections with the ministry of labour and their counterparts in other countries. Piss off politicians in enough places and it will backfire.
Maybe there is some hidden upside but I don't see any.
Finally, you are also representing your country when you do business abroad. Every other American CEO lost a little bit of respect today by re-inforcing certain stereo types that we could all do without.
If you are ever in a position like this, please say 'no' with some grace.