News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by bpatrianakos on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:31AM (#5250577)
"Overall it was important to me that the page be dynamic, that it feel very fresh, and that it be very intuitive, and that it really tries to embody beautiful design"

Is that really supposed to mean anything? It sounds like buzzword soup. It should kind of go without saying that she wants the site to be fresh, intuitive, and beautiful. I don't think anyone wants a stale, frustrating and ugly website. That said, news feeds, AJAX, and oAuth don't necessarily make the site all 3 of those things.

I'm really rooting for Mayer but I couldn't let that quote go.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by wmeredith on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:46AM (#5250657)
She's not going to rattle off jargon from the technical requirements document. If she did, the Business Week audience would respond with, "What's that supposed to mean? It just a bunch of acronyms and industry jargon."

This is a marketing and PR piece.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by dfxm12 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:30AM (#5250919)
Aren't buzzwords like this just as alienating as tech jargon? I know everyone does it, but why does she have to speak in marketing/design jargon, and not plain English?
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by seunosewa on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:40AM (#5250990)
Agreed. Apple executives speak in perfectly plain English and they are the most valuable tech company in the world.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by eqreqeq on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:22AM (#5251298)
correlation is not causation.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by rhizome on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @01:55PM (#5252430)
...not necessarily causation.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by BCM43 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:40AM (#5250994)
How would you put it in "plain English"?
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by recuter on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:47AM (#5251040)
"We made it less crap."

Or, actually usable: "We gave it a makeover."

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by jrockway on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:16AM (#5251246)
"We cleaned up the design, made the pictures bigger and the text easier to read. And we added gadgets to the side so you can stay up to date on your stocks."

(As though the average Yahoo reader owns individual stocks?)

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by specialp on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:38AM (#5251393)
Yahoo finance is the biggest finance site on the internet. Sure we like to look at Yahoo as the old internet site that consists of former AOL users, but they do have massive traffic . I think it is a bit pretentious say that many people do not own stocks that visit there, it is an older demographic and older people are more likely to own stock.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by taligent on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:14PM (#5252554)
Seriously ? I mean exactly how dull and boring do you want this to be. Given how many people worked on it, are impacted by it and what is represents surely a bit of excitement isn't asking too much.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by jrockway on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:47PM (#5252810)
Aren't "bigger pictures" and "gadgets" more exciting than "dynamic" and "intuitive" layout?
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Evbn on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:37PM (#5255208)
Tons of people like to play with stocks. The educated elite buy mutual funds.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Evbn on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:36PM (#5255204)
The same crap gets blasted around internally by the disconnected execs, "magical" systems, etc.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by obstacle1 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:46AM (#5250654)
This is a fluff piece aimed entirely at nontechnical readers. "Beautiful", "intuitive", "dynamic", "personalizable", and so on are exactly the words this audience wants to hear. They wouldn't understand anything more jargon-y and don't care how the site was built, they just want to know how they're going to feel while using it.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by jrockway on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:19AM (#5251268)
How can someone tell me what I will find beautiful or intuitive?

It's buzzwords, not a meaningful reflection on the changes. People that aren't professional writers think that stringing positive-sounding words together in a way that is grammatically correct will result in a good sentence. The result is corporate speak.

"The synergy of the positive verbiage results in a dynamic reading experience." No, it makes me want to hit my head on the desk until my eyes get too watery to read the text anymore. Or post an angry comment on HN. One of those.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by obstacle1 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @01:39PM (#5252312)
>How can someone tell me what I will find beautiful or intuitive?

Nobody can. But when a press release says a product is beautiful and intuitive, it at least invites you to go use the product and judge for yourself.

>It's buzzwords, not a meaningful reflection on the changes.

Beautiful, fresh, and intuitive aren't buzzwords in the same sense that synergistic, disruptive, etc. are. Beauty, freshness, and intuition are ancient aesthetic concepts that speak to instincts in, dare I say, all humans. When I hear that something is beautiful, that is an invitation for me to go judge said thing's beauty. As such, I'd argue that describing a new product as beautiful, intuitive, or something similar is an equally meaningful description as listing technical specs driving a change.

>People that aren't professional writers think that stringing positive-sounding words together in a way that is grammatically correct will result in a good sentence. The result is corporate speak.

As someone who has written copy professionally (and still sometimes does) I disagree with you on a number of levels. Strings of positive-sounding but effectively meaningless words absolutely are effective for selling and persuading. On the other hand strings of meaningful and unambiguous words often don't convert. Note that we don't sell consumer products by using instruction manuals as ads, and we don't drive massive traffic by describing the mechanics behind a site.

Even Rails, a technical "product", advertises itself by claiming to facilitate the writing of "beautiful" code.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by taligent on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:27PM (#5252646)

  > How can someone tell me what I will find beautiful or intuitive?
Let's be honest here. Yahoo doesn't really care what you think. Clearly if you are someone who gets worked up because a company calls a new product, "beautiful" or "intuitive" then you really aren't their desired demographic.

Especially since you know. You are a Google employee and all.

The fact is that Yahoo is simply trying to make this launch sound exciting. Like companies have been doing for hundreds of years. And the language they are using is far less hyperbolic than most.

  > The result is corporate speak.
Might want to check a dictionary because I don't think you understand what that term means.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by jrockway on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @03:08PM (#5252958)
Let's be honest here. Yahoo doesn't really care what you think.

I was under the impression that I was replying to an HN comment, not to Yahoo. I know they don't care what I think, nor do I expect them to care. I don't even think there's value in them caring what I think. The point of this particular HN thread was to analyze the language used in the article, and I added my thoughts to the thread for others to read. (I didn't even start the thread; someone else submitted the article and someone else pointed out the sentence in question.)

Why are you following me around on HN and making everything into a personal attack, anyway? Disagree with the idea, not with the person.

Might want to check a dictionary because I don't think you understand what that term means.

If we're going by Wikipedia, it seems I meant to say "marketing speak", which is defined in the "Corporate jargon" article. I think the idea is clear: talk about what you did in objective terms, not whatever beautiful and dynamic words happen to be nearby while you're preparing a statement. (Wait, that was kind of fun. Maybe I'm wrong.)

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Terretta on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @03:54PM (#5253269)
Generally I'd agree with you. And generally I think these releases are PR. But the sentence in question "feels" more sincere than that to me:

She said it's "important that the page be dynamic, that it feel very fresh, and that it be very intuitive, and that it really tries to embody beautiful design".

In context, I don't think the first word, "dynamic", means AJAX, I think it means conveying energy or excitement. Putting the "Yaa-hoo!!!" back in Yahoo, if you will. The hero images change out. The weather, stocks and scores are up to date. On the iPad, you have an edge to edge (full bleed) hero image and thumbs you can scroll to. On the iPad, it does "feel" dynamic without being annoying.

The next word, "fresh", is the opposite of what Yahoo's been for a decade. The Yahoo look until not long ago still hearkened back to its curated directory days. When visited from an iPad, her new design does feel up to date, without feeling like it came from Bootstrap Template Monster Ville. You can recognize at a glance that this is not MSN, AOL, et. al. (However, when visited on a desktop, I think it feels more like a shuffled iGoogle, so not so fresh.)

There is a risk in "intuitive" in that it's crucial for the Yahoo audience which is a little older and more change averse. In this case, the word needs to mean approachable and immediately grokked by their majority. Grandpa needs to be able to find his scores and grandma her horoscope. I suspect this word used here signals why this page isn't singing and dancing with undiscoverable swipe style affordances.

The "beautiful design" is the hardest to accept, if visiting from the desktop. On the iPad, I was struck how nice it looked. On the desktop, I think she might be bringing too much Google to her aesthetic. "Clean" is not equal to "beautiful", and I'm not even sure it's clean given the use of grey hairlines and shaded boxes to delineate content areas. A more "beautiful" design might, for example, convey the content area boundaries aesthetically, and have the grey hairlines and shading show up only when the gear (settings) and X (close) icons are needed. With a decade of Google behind her, she probably does consider this presentation more "beautiful" than any of the section home pages you reach from this page.

Word by word, I think she used the best words she had on hand for what she was directing her redesign team to come up with. I like that she talked about how it "felt" rather than just metrics.

If you spitball a bunch of terms you want your home page to convey, this isn't a bad list. Perhaps these particular words sound overused because, well, a home page like Yahoo's needs these words as priorities.

I didn't read her comment as insincere or corporate speak or even marketing speak. I think it's honestly what she was going for.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Evbn on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:41PM (#5255221)
Yes, you have captured the essence of the consultant who wrote Marissa's speech. That is exactly what this thread is complaining about. The corporatespeak BS. "Dynamic" is 1990s codeword for "good", before "rock star" took over as the tech buzzword.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Terretta on Thursday February 21, 2013 @12:32PM (#5258691)
> The corporatespeak BS. "Dynamic" is 1990s codeword for "good"

Sometimes the best word for a thing is, well, the best word.

dynamic (adj) 2a. marked by usually continuous and productive activity or change <a dynamic city>; 2b. energetic, forceful <a dynamic personality>

She did not use the term as a code word for "good". The page is continuously updated with productive changing information. She used the most concise word for that available.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by bpatrianakos on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @12:24PM (#5251752)
I wasn't looking for an explanation of how the site was built at all. I really think she could have came up with an explanation of the goals of the redesign that actually meant something. For example:

"We wanted the site to feel fresh, intuitive, and beautiful which why we put a lot of work into the new real-time news feed, gave the homepage a simpler, less cluttered design, and took inspiration from designs that are both modern and timeless".

What was really lacking in the original quote was substance. She could have used the very same first half the quote then pointed at one thing that qualified the redesign as being each of those adjectives and it would have went from buzzword soup to a meaningful statement.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by jlarocco on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @01:01PM (#5252028)
It's not her personal blog. For all we know, she went into detail about the whole thing and the reporter snipped it all.

I'm not saying it happened here, but it does happen.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by bpatrianakos on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:23PM (#5252612)
Okay, fair points. I had no idea my one little comment would get so much attention. I'm really not trying to be as critical of Mayer as everything seems to have taken it. I saw a quote, it stood out as being supremely hollow and so I pointed it out. I'm not the typical HN cynic that picks things apart where there's no need. I understand the context. I just thought that quote was funny enough to point out.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by obstacle1 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @01:18PM (#5252160)
You're right that the quote lacks substance but again, this is basically a press release aimed at Joe and Jill Schmoe. They do not care about all the work that went into the site; they only care about the experience of using the site. With this in mind, take your revised sentence:

>"We wanted the site to feel fresh, intuitive, and beautiful which why we put a lot of work into the new real-time news feed, gave the homepage a simpler, less cluttered design, and took inspiration from designs that are both modern and timeless"

And chop it up as such:

>"We wanted the site to feel fresh, intuitive, and beautiful."

Absolutely no relevant facts lost (given the audience) and a much clearer read.

The shorter sentence is also more effective from a marketing perspective because it plants the seed of curiosity in the reader's mind. "How is the site fresh, intuitive, and beautiful? Better visit yahoo.com and find out".

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Evbn on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:41PM (#5255226)
Jill Schmoe doesn't read Yahoo press releases.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by obstacle1 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @11:30PM (#5255375)
The content of Yahoo press releases makes it into Business Week and other MSM, which Jill Schmoe reads daily.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by ed209 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:36AM (#5250968)
Actually, you should always define some "buzzword soup" as you put it, or as others put it "define the tone".

Picking out opposites to words she says is a cheap shot. Of course no one would ask for "stale, frustrating and ugly" websites.

However, she could just as easily have said "robust, bold and permanent" which would have resulted in a site better suited for obituaries.

I often encounter people who put these very high level definitions down to project management fluff, but the truth is the stuff makes a difference on it's way down the development chain.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by bpatrianakos on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @12:29PM (#5251788)
Everyone seems to be misunderstanding what I meant. I understand that those words have meaning in some contexts and I get that this is a Business Week interview and they're playing to the audience. All I'm saying is that if she would have added in just a couple of specifics in there the quote would have had meaning. What she said would have made sense if she were saying it to her design department but in this context it still stands as meaningless.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by ed209 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @01:00PM (#5252020)
fair enough, my comments were directed more towards these terms used in a project management context rather than where she actually used them.

I would still argue that using them as part of marketing speak is doing something towards setting the tone though.

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by untog on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:42AM (#5250638)
It's an interview with BusinessWeek. There is such a thing as playing to your audience. She's a techie, we know she is, BusinessWeek's average reader doesn't know or care.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by pacomerh on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:44PM (#5252779)
Here we are at HN, a community of "smart" people, and yet you still don't understand that those words are for targeted for everyone, not just you, the nerd. Of course it's fine if she says the "obvious", it's not obvious for everyone.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by prezjordan on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:32AM (#5250584)
She's the face of a large corporation, is that really unexpected? I figure anyone in her position would throw around marketing lingo - seems like it's part of the job.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by bpatrianakos on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @09:35AM (#5250597)
I know that. I'm being a little harsh and I am kidding a bit too. I usually don't go out of my way to say anything about these sorts of things because of exactly what you said but this one just struck me so hard I could not let it go.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by lotso on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:11PM (#5252528)
The page is dynamic and fresh = the content is changing and up-to-date.

Intuitive = easy to use, especially important for Yahoo's demographic

Beautiful design = nice to look at.

I think that sentence covers the redesign pretty well and isn't just "buzzword soup."

Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by biot on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @02:10PM (#5252525)
The page used to be relatively static, a bit outdated, not as intuitive as it could be, and with a design that was aging. Her explanation is perfect for conveying what they've focused on changing without dwelling on the old status.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by tn13 on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @05:22PM (#5253777)
She clearly missed the following words. "leveraging the cloud, mobile optimized, touch friendly"
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by Evbn on Wednesday February 20, 2013 @10:44PM (#5255234)
She is trying to slowly step away from her "just be Google" strategy of 2012.
Re:Marissa Mayer Rolls Out a New Yahoo.com by tn13 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @06:07PM (#5261243)
I was only pointing out that she is only using the buzzwords that the wall street likes to hear.