286mi/85kwh / .12 (dollar per kilowatt hour) = 28 miles per dollar or .03 per mile.
Gasoline on the other hand is:
30 mpg / 3.50 (dollar per gallon) = 8.5 miles per dollar or .11 per mile
Electricity comes out far better. Cars are much less efficient than heaters at capturing the stored energy from it's fuel. With a heater you have the benefit of insulation and none of the losses associated with moving a hunk of metal through air.
Using that cost in your calculation would yield 8.2 miles per dollar, or .12 dollars per mile. -
... huh, so I'd be saving nearly about $850 $/yr with an electric car, even though I only drive about 6500 mi/yr (though half of that is the cross country trip to visit my folks). That said, my car only cost $5500, so it would take longer than the life of the car to pay off the difference to a Tesla.
Lots of people in NYC have cars. NYC isn't just Manhattan, and much of the area in the outer boroughs is more suburban than urban and not accessible via subway.
Though electric cars are much more efficient [1]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_car#Energy_efficiency