News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by erikpukinskis on Friday February 15, 2013 @12:59PM (#5227404)
No, meteor defense can get in line behind heart disease, automobiles, suicide, gun violence, war, police, and all the other things astronomically (heh) more likely to kill people, therefore more deserving of our attention.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by wdr1 on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:31PM (#5227598)
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by T-hawk on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:48PM (#5227703)
Well, not directly; any single impact certainly didn't hit and kill life forms all over the globe. They induced environmental changes that gradually caused species to fail to survive. "Sudden" in geologic terms means at least hundreds or up to tens of thousands of years. An intelligent species like humans can and will react and adapt in that kind of time frame. We're already on that path; we can already at least detect and predict any object big enough to significantly disrupt the planetary ecosystem.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by cryptoz on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:57PM (#5227764)
> An intelligent species like humans can and will react and adapt in that kind of time frame. We're already on that path; we can already at least detect and predict any object big enough to significantly disrupt the planetary ecosystem.

We've detected such a series of objects and have willingly not tried to prevent them from dramatically altering our ecosystem, but are encouraging and quickening the damage they do. Detecting and predicting is not nearly enough. Action is required and there is absolutely no evidence to suggest that humans will take that action. I strongly disagree that a species such as humans 'can and will react and adapt'. So far we have shown that we are the exact opposite: we are the ones causing global environmental catastrophe.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by 3minus1 on Friday February 15, 2013 @05:51PM (#5229184)
This is a really bad comparison imo. The difficulty of sustainability and non-pollution is that it requires everyone to work together to not consume. If even a few parties decide to not cooperate they can consume everything that's left and the other people will lose out on their "share." In the case of an asteroid it's in everyone's interest to prepare as best as he/she can and cooperation actually helps. There's really no downside to preparing as much you as can.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by wheels on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:16PM (#5227500)
Heart disease and car crashes don't have the ability to derail significant economies in short shrift. There's pretty obviously a huge difference between singular, concentrated disasters and amortized "normal" human death.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jholman on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:46PM (#5227696)
I think that as long as we're talking about sub-extinction levels, I disagree with you.

WP estimates roughly one million car accident deaths per year (worldwide est for 2007). Heart disease numbers are more like 30M/year, although lots of those people were very old, so it's hard to estimate what's preventable. Compare that with a hypothetical meteor that kills one hundred million people, in a confined geographic area (that's 1/7 of Europe, or 1/5 of N America, or just half a dozen large Asia cities). What're the odds of that meteor? Even the once-per-millenium Tunguska event wasn't large enough to do that much damage. But suppose once-per-millenium meteors WERE deadly enough to kill 100M people, that's still 1/10 the deaths per year. If it's more spending-efficient to prevent the deaths from heart disease, do that. If it's more spending-efficient to prevent the deaths from meteor impact, do that.

On the other hand, extinction events are worth treating with extra care. Which in fact is exactly what meteor watches do, which is why they only look for entry diameters over 100m. Seems reasonable! Extinction events have happened 5 times in the last 540 million years. They're pretty rare. Maybe we should just roll the dice.

Off-topic: That's not what "shrift" means. Maybe you'd like "short order" or just the clearly "in a short time".

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by wheels on Friday February 15, 2013 @03:01PM (#5228189)
To be clear, I'm not actually saying that a meteor defense system is a reasonable idea. I don't know enough about the topic to say anything interesting.

My point was rather that you can't compare a catastrophe with disease / accidents simply in deaths-over-time. Catastrophes have dramatic economic consequences as well.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jholman on Friday February 15, 2013 @03:20PM (#5228339)
Okay, fair enough. I like the "I don't know enough to speak" attitude, and I don't know enough either. (What do you mean, five minutes on Wikipedia doesn't make me an expert?!?! :P )

My reply to your core point is that you can so compare (not least because deaths-over-time have dramatic economic consequences too). Maybe we're just gonna disagree about this one. :)

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by ANH on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:33PM (#5228811)
I believe that from a bang-for-the-buck perspective, Near-Earth Object monitoring is one of the better values. In the scheme of national budgets, it is CHEEEEEP to deploy a ground-based observatory capable of detecting threatening objects. To wit: http://www.planetary.org/explore/projects/neo-grants/2012da1...

If we have the observatories in place, we should have enough time to come up with a reasonable defense.

I believe if we're wiped out by one of these rocks, it'll be due to our own negligence.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by chakalakasp on Friday February 15, 2013 @09:45PM (#5230113)
Unless we knew about it literally decades in advance, there is little mankind could do (with today's technology) to stop a miles-wide inbound asteroid from hitting the earth.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by sehugg on Friday February 15, 2013 @05:03PM (#5228954)
Though there is a tradeoff in resources vs. other human concerns, I think the math is a bit more complicated. We're not only trying to guard individual human lives but the health of civilization. Just the knowledge that a major asteroid impact was imminent, with no way to address it in time, would be severely destabilizing to global society.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jug6ernaut on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:04PM (#5227434)
Always love how people throw out "gun violence" as if "gun violence"(as if there is such a thing) is so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence".
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by miles on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:33PM (#5227611)
Indeed. The fact that guns save lives around the country on a regular basis is almost completely ignored by the media:

Guns Save Lives http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/02/guns_save_...

"If someone gets into your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone? You can call the police if you want, and they'll get there, and they'll take a picture of your dead body. But they can't get there in time to save your life. The first line of defense is you."

http://gunssavelives.net/ has a huge collection of articles like these:

Son Uses Dad’s AR-15 To Defend Home http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/son-uses-dads-ar...

Armed Citizen in TX Stops Shooting Spree and Saves Cop http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/armed-citizen-in-tx-st...

GA Woman Kills Would Be Rapist With .22 Pistol http://gunssavelives.net/self-defense/video/ga-woman-kills-w...

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by tokipin on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:06PM (#5227827)
quite frankly, the "gun in your house" thing is a very weird argument. if you actually play out a real-life instance of such a situation, it's not so simple at all. reality is much more nuanced.

for example, a gun is about 120% useless if you have it stored and the bad guy has the drop on you, which is likely the case on multiple levels given that that the 'bad guy' is the aggressor and initiator of a rare situation.

for example, the 'bad guy' may have a gun himself, and seeing you wielding one may cause him to shoot you, when he otherwise wouldn't have. and it's entirely possible or even likely that he has spent more time at the shooting range than you, or that he has killed people before. nevermind that he, having the mental preparedness that comes from being the initiator, may have the clearer presence of mind and less shaky hands

Etc. Etc. the "gun in my home to keep me safe" is a non-sequitur and only makes sense in simplistic cowboy scenarios, and I've even heard statistics saying you're more likely to hurt yourself or a loved one than the bad guy...

...but we don't really have any good ideas about that, because the gun lobby has suppressed research into these things for several years

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by spindritf on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:53PM (#5228136)
> the "gun in my home to keep me safe" is a non-sequitur and only makes sense in simplistic cowboy scenari

No, it makes perfect, quantifiable, empirical sense

>> data from the United States, show “a negative correlation,” that is, “where firearms are most dense violent crime rates are lowest, and where guns are least dense violent crime rates are highest.”[1]

[1] beware the PDF: http://www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/jlpp/Vol30_No2_Kate...

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by tokipin on Friday February 15, 2013 @08:33PM (#5229901)
> No, it makes perfect, quantifiable, empirical sense

i disagree. the reality of a criminal entering someone's home where guns are involved is much more complicated and unpredictable than that argument implies. and i've also read of other studies that show the opposite conclusion of that study

now that the research ban has been lifted, we will get a better picture eventually

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jacquesm on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:24PM (#5228778)
That must be why there are so many homicides with other weapons in Western Europe and most of Asia.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by spindritf on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:54PM (#5228907)
> That must be why there are so many homicides with other weapons in Western Europe and most of Asia.

I could never find a good response when my rational argument is met with an off-hand snark. And yet something should be said to avoid the perception that it was a valid counterpoint.

One option would be to point out that there are multiple factors at play, other differences between those countries than just gun ownership. That study after study linked in the post before show no correlation, no meaningful impact of gun ownership. That there are causes of crime that explain reality much better, like family structure.

Other would be to mock. "Sure, let's ban all the guns, jail all the blacks, and live in a crime-free utopia. Oh, and maybe nuke Detroit or New Orleans while we're at it. After all, nothing gives a better picture than a cursory glance."

I'm never satisfied with either.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by DeepDuh on Friday February 15, 2013 @08:22PM (#5229868)
You certainly do have a point. I'm Swiss and our gun ownership clocks in somewhere after USA and Canada, yet violence levels are about the same as in the rest of Europe. It really seems to have much more to do with culture than with guns themselves. However, defending this position must be quite tough as an American. It means that there is something inherently violent in your culture.

Maybe there is a correlation with suburban car culture? First there is the significant correlation between environmental lead during childhood and violence, secondly I think that having a low population density might make people feel more on their own, the highest goal being to protect their family. I'm thinking that people that are used to a high population density, who are in contact with hundreds of other humans a day, get used to this and lower their defenses. Then again I've seen a study suggesting that the violence leves in cities and on the countryside is pretty much the same (at least after lead levels have evened out).

Maybe, hopefully, the decline in violence in the US will continue and it will level out at a similar point as Europe / Asia - then we'll probably know that you were just poisoning yourselves with lead. I hope that this will have some impact on limiting the power of lobbies. Think of how much lead gasoline, lobbied into the world by the oil and car industry, has cost society, if this really was the main cause of the 70ies / 80ies crime outbursts.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jacquesm on Saturday February 16, 2013 @06:42AM (#5231201)
The thing to recognize here is that Swiss culture is the exception, not the rule. Large parts of the rest of the world do not have a culture like the Swiss and would very likely end up like the United States if you flooded them with guns and ammunition.

The idea that the presence or absence of guns is totally divorced from gunviolence is ridiculous, motive, means and opportunity. Take away the bulk means of easily dispatching fellow human beings in your average culture and you see a decrease in violent deaths. See Australia.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by DeepDuh on Sunday February 17, 2013 @03:23AM (#5234584)
I agree with you. I wasn't arguing against gun control laws. Actually, Swiss gun control is very strict, plus it's also not so easy to get ammunition. Most of the guns here are the military rifles people keep after service and the ammunition for those is unavailable - well except if you really really want it. Therefore it's not quite like people have constant access to a gun for those times when they get into the mood for murdering someone. I'm certain that more regulation in the US would help in that regard.

What I'm saying is: I'm skeptical that this alone would bring the aggression levels in the US to European levels (not even speaking about Japan, where it's another order of magnitude below). It would certainly be a good start though and it would be relatively easy to implement. Similar to software development: One should always start optimizing by getting the low hanging fruits.

It's still interesting however, to think about why there is such a cultural difference between the US and Europe, considering our heritage is so close.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by ceejayoz on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:29PM (#5227982)
> "If someone gets into your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone? You can call the police if you want, and they'll get there, and they'll take a picture of your dead body. But they can't get there in time to save your life. The first line of defense is you."

Of course, the flip side of this is "If you're horribly depressed in your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone."

Same thing for "If your teenage son's irresponsible friends are in your house..."

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by spindritf on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:06PM (#5228683)
> Of course, the flip side of this is "If you're horribly depressed in your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone."

Not much a flip side. Unless you happen to think that suicides by other means are somehow better.

>> The evidence, however, indicates that denying one particular means to people who are motivated to commit suicide by social, economic, cultural, or other circumstances simply pushes them to some other means.[1]

[1] Same PDF as in the next comment http://www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/jlpp/Vol30_No2_Kate...

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by ceejayoz on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:58PM (#5228924)
Suicides by other means tend to be less immediately deadly.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by robinh on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:58AM (#5231139)
Why should people not be able to commit suicide in the easiest possible way?
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by ceejayoz on Saturday February 16, 2013 @11:35AM (#5231976)
Because, in many cases, it's a situation of treatable mental illness rather than rational decision making.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by mootothemax on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:17PM (#5227893)
"If someone gets into your house, which would you rather have, a handgun or a telephone? You can call the police if you want, and they'll get there, and they'll take a picture of your dead body. But they can't get there in time to save your life. The first line of defense is you."

I'm really curious about how this is meant to work in large cities, where there are often lots of people living in a small amount of space, with very flimsy walls between them and so on.

Surely firing a gun in such an environment is likely to cause yet more harm (with bullets flying through windows/walls), even if you do manage to hit the intruder?

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by SoftwareMaven on Friday February 15, 2013 @03:10PM (#5228266)
There are types of ammunition that deal better with this. Lower loads, softer bullets, etc.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by mootothemax on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:28PM (#5228794)
Genuine question: with such ammunition, is there a even a tiny chance it will go through a plasterboard wall and kill my flatmate?

Would a taser be a safer-yet-effective option when living in such an apartment?

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by SoftwareMaven on Sunday February 17, 2013 @02:26PM (#5236333)
Here[1] is an example of said ammunition. The corrolary, of course, is that if something won't go through an inch wall material (most of walls are hollow, after all), penetrating inches of skin, fat, and muscle are also unlikely. I've read of some people who put the first couple of rounds using the safety slugs and then hollow-points for the rest, figuring if somebody isn't going to stop with a couple, fairly large, relatively surface wounds, then they aren't going to stop without something more serious and house mates are in danger in that situation anyway.

Regardless, before I would ever keep a gun for personal protection[2], I would make sure I have enough experience shooting it and hitting my target that my likelihood of missing at short range is exceedingly low. Stress and all that will impact your abilities, of course, but enough training can significantly reduce that risk.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glaser_Safety_Slug

2. I love shooting and have a couple, small caliber rifles locked up in the basement, but I don't currently own a gun for "personal protection".

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jlgreco on Friday February 15, 2013 @03:54PM (#5228594)
Ideally you don't have to actually fire the gun for it to be effective.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by mootothemax on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:38PM (#5228831)
I agree that thats the ideal.

However, if intruders know that people won't fire guns, surely we remove the whole point of having them?

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jlgreco on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:48PM (#5228879)
The idea is that, as a general rule, people will fire the gun if the situation is pressed. Knowing that, criminals will back down when a gun is presented. It's not bluffing, just threatening.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by snowwrestler on Friday February 15, 2013 @03:32PM (#5228436)
The essence of the argument is the emotional appeal of self-defense, which makes these considerations less important. Someone facing a violent intruder in their house is not likely to think about their neighbors. They are going to do whatever they can in that moment to defend themselves.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by mootothemax on Friday February 15, 2013 @04:36PM (#5228822)
It's a tricky one. If I fire a gun, I put everyone living immediately around me at risk. If an intruder has a weapon though, does potentially disabling him or her outweigh the risks against everyone around me?

It's something I really struggle to work out, to he honest.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by drewblaisdell on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:10PM (#5227848)
The "guns save lives" argument falls apart when you realize that the plural of anecdote is not data.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by spindritf on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:18PM (#5227901)
> The "guns save lives" argument falls apart when you realize that the plural of anecdote is not data.

No, not really. It works for real data, too.

>> Using cross-sectional time-series data for U.S. counties from 1977 to 1992, we find that allowing citizens to carry concealed weapons deters violent crimes and it appears to produce no increase in accidental deaths.[1]

Which never impresses anyone so gun advocates go for stories.

[1] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=10129

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by leot on Friday February 15, 2013 @07:49PM (#5229772)
From a self defense perspective, how much more can a lethal gun do than a paintball gun loaded with pepperballs?

Is the ability to kill necessary?

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by mapt on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:02AM (#5230839)
The problem is that enthusiast gun owners don't want to be able to deter intruders, they want to be able to stop gun-owning intruders from getting off their first shot, in the hypothetical that the resident can surprise the invader.

In discussions, 45ACP is thus favored for 'stopping power' versus the smaller 9mm. The gun-enthusiast response to the penetration concern is either to ignore it and emphasize aim & intelligent planning, or to create expensive 45ACP 'frangible rounds' that shatter into a granular powder on impact. There also exist somewhat anomalous theories about buckshot/birdshot being safer.

The most common guns, though, are lightweight, low-recoil 22LR-caliber pistols that lower the kill probability significantly over any of the more serious pistol rounds.

One can certainly create less-lethal loadings, either with traditional lead or something else like rocksalt shotshells, but things that can penetrate a chest cavity tend to be able to penetrate drywall.

I'd just go with a Taser and pepper spray if I was concerned about the small chance that penetrative shrapnel ends up energetic enough to hurt a loved one.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by dfxm12 on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:30PM (#5227584)
There is such a thing as gun violence. It is distinguished as violence involving at least one gun.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jug6ernaut on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:36PM (#5227629)
"There is such a thing as gun violence" I'm not convinced.

"It is distinguished as violence involving at least one gun."

re-read my post, i said

>> "so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence""

I'm not saying that it cant be distinguished (as others describe it), I am saying is there a big enough difference that we should focus on it over violence in general.

IN MY OPINION! focusing on "gun violence" takes away from the more important discussion on "violence" in general and diverts the discussion to matters non conducive to stowing violence in general. BUT this is not what this post is about.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by dfxm12 on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:40PM (#5227656)
I reread your post. It was the same as the first time I read it. It said "Always love how people throw out "gun violence" (as if there is such a thing) is so distinguishable that it should be focused on above "violence"."

Based on the bit I emphasized, you are implying "gun violence" is not a real concept, or doesn't exist, or something along those lines. Gun violence is real.

Further, OP is clearly not commenting on the prevalence of gun violence vs other violence. OP is commenting on things more likely to cause damage than a meteor strike.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by JoeAltmaier on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:42PM (#5227673)
We don't call out 'knife violence' or 'fist violence' or 'cricket-bat violence'. All are real too.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by arjie on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:44PM (#5227690)
Well, I suppose it depends on the relative frequency of the crimes. British newspapers are always on about 'knife crime'.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by kamjam on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:57PM (#5228159)
That's because in the UK knife violence is a much bigger than gun crime.

Having said that, drunken violence on a friday/saturday night is a big problem regardless.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by sliverstorm on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:33PM (#5227607)
as if "gun violence" is so distinguishable

Sure it's distinguishable. It's scarier, so it's easier to get people upset about it. People seem to be orders of magnitude more afraid that they will be gunned down as opposed to, say, killed with a knife or a hammer.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by jlarocco on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:42PM (#5227679)
May just be me, but I'd prefer to be gunned down than killed with a hammer.

Not that I disagree with your point - it's far easier to avoid being killed with a hammer.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by roc on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:07PM (#5227452)
Only if we assume that our mitigation efforts against those other problems would be lacking for resources, if we sent some resources to work on space object detection/defense.

If we're putting as much money and effort into automobile safety as society wants/will allow, there's no 'loss' in taking additional funds to tackle the next problem down the line. And so on.

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by dj2stein9 on Friday February 15, 2013 @06:54PM (#5229542)
Except none of those things can realistically kill every person on the planet. Nuclear war would maybe be the only threat I think has a higher likelihood of making mankind extinct than a meteor, which is why graphics like this scare the crap out of me:

http://visually.visually.netdna-cdn.com/NuclearWeapons_4fa46...

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by chakalakasp on Friday February 15, 2013 @09:47PM (#5230120)
Don't be afraid; it's not drawn to scale.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by rmc on Friday February 15, 2013 @02:37PM (#5228033)
Although those things do kill more people every year, and they are predictable numbers. We have figured out how to get along. However a meteor is currently unpredictable, and we have no plan for what happens if it hits somewhere big. The effect of all the heart attacks next year have been taken into consideration, a meter or strike to London, less so.
Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by blhack on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:59PM (#5227778)
You should just add the word "bad" to that list.

We can't work on anything until we eradicate bad! $foo is so much less important than bad!

/s

Re:Russian meteor largest in a century by JoeAltmaier on Friday February 15, 2013 @01:31PM (#5227588)
There is no line. There's just fad and fashion. What's the disease-of-the-year? Pour money into that! Never mind obesity etc. Or meteors.