If medicine floated with the cost of supply and demand, then outbreaks and epidemics would be an ethical nightmare and a commercial blessing.
Medical supplies during epidemics always fail to match the huge spike in demand, so the price would rise exponentially. Medication providers would make a fortune while only the rich would receive medication.
Depending how much you want to bend toward conspiracy theories, it would almost be like incentivizing medication providers to cause huge outbreaks.
Supply and demand doesn't work out too well when the consumer has no bargaining power.
If I'm buying a car, I can walk away if I don't agree with the terms. How does the guy with the broken back do that?
If I am an unconscious or legally incompetent person in the ICU make a rational economic decision about their course of treatment?
Re:Acts of God
by unclenoriega on Monday February 11, 2013 @01:28PM
(#5202318)
I've heard this argument before, and, while it seems logical enough, has anyone tried to estimate the cost of various procedures under this sort of system? I tend to believe that healthcare would still be too expensive for most people to afford, but I've never been able to find supporting estimates one way or the other.
My solution is to let the price of medicine float with demand and supply, like any other commodity, where it would lower in price with competition and neuter the influence of health insurance lobbyists.
Also, health is always going to be the sort of profession where the best treatment is too expensive for more people to afford. That's just a natural result of innovation. Every new technology--even those we take for granted today--were too expensive for most people to afford when they were introduced. The way that prices come down for these things is through demand and competition, not through government mandates, which provide no incentive to lower prices (another principal agent problem).