Or people who come for a few years and send it all home. Or live here for years, sending vast percentages of it home.
>paid for them to be educated or nursed through childhood
We have already paid anything there we had to, so they're sunk costs for non-immigrants. The cost of aid programs, retraining and the like are pain points for non-immigrants and the government.
Economics in one of those subject matters where vast swaths of it are only taken as real by some people in the field. Without knowing exactly what you're talking about (this labor lump policy doesn't seem to be settled economics from the cites), the fact there was a class on it doesn't necessarily mean it's something we should be making decisions on.
We have already paid anything there we had to, so they're sunk costs for non-immigrants.
...apart from the interest on the debt accrued in doing so.
Economics in one of those subject matters where vast swaths of it are only taken as real by some people in the field.
OK...and it's a lump of labor fallacy, not a lump of labor policy, and it is about as settled as anything gets in economics, having been called out as a fallacy in 1891 by DF Schloss. I defy you to find me any economic theoretician who believes int he notion of a 'lump of labor'. Even labor unions, traditionally the holdouts on this issue, have abandoned this position in recent years and accepted the importance of consumption as a factor of demand.
H1Bs still seem bad.
I admit that this won't make much sense if you haven't taken some economics classes, it's counter-intuitive.