News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Congressman Gutierrez, Please Lift Your Hold On Sili... by anigbrowl on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:01PM (#5198123)
They don't send it all home, because otherwise they wouldn't be able to live here. besides, what is sent home often creates demands for American exports.

We have already paid anything there we had to, so they're sunk costs for non-immigrants.

...apart from the interest on the debt accrued in doing so.

Economics in one of those subject matters where vast swaths of it are only taken as real by some people in the field.

OK...and it's a lump of labor fallacy, not a lump of labor policy, and it is about as settled as anything gets in economics, having been called out as a fallacy in 1891 by DF Schloss. I defy you to find me any economic theoretician who believes int he notion of a 'lump of labor'. Even labor unions, traditionally the holdouts on this issue, have abandoned this position in recent years and accepted the importance of consumption as a factor of demand.

Re:Dear Congressman Gutierrez, Please Lift Your Hold On Sili... by gte910h on Monday February 11, 2013 @05:18PM (#5203704)
Even if it is better to have immigrants than natives, why would H1Bs be the right way? Green cards would be better according to your theory than H1Bs. They would hurt current green card and citizen workers less as well.

H1Bs still seem bad.